Gramercy Park Block Association
Gramercy Stories

3 Gramercy Park West

A family house, a school for women, a Dutch meeting place

The entrances to Nos. 4 and 3 Gramercy Park West in 1935, with their ornamental iron canopy, stoops and shutters; the number 3 is visible above the right-hand door.
The paired entrances of 4 Gramercy Park West (left) and 3 Gramercy Park West (right), photographed by Berenice Abbott on November 27, 1935.

Candlelight at the Park gate

On a warm graduation evening in May 1910, young women dressed in white gathered around the central fountain inside Gramercy Park. Around the square, neighbors raised their sash windows and passersby paused along the iron railings as the graduates—each carrying a lighted candle and singing in harmony—walked through the western gate and up the brownstone steps into their school at 3 Gramercy Park West.

Built in 1845–1846 by paper merchant and Gramercy Park Trustee Norman White as a Greek Revival twin to the James Harper House at No. 4—and united with its neighbor beneath a celebrated cast-iron veranda designed by Alexander Jackson Davis—No. 3 has lived an extraordinary succession of lives: the forty-one-year family home of Columbia law professor Benjamin Franklin Lee, the inaugural national graduate school of the Young Women’s Christian Association founded by Grace Hoadley Dodge, the interwar clubhouse of the Netherland Club of New York, the apartments remodeled in 1939 by modernist architect Eugene Schoen, and a familiar Gramercy façade on the television screen.

1845–1866 · LAND AND ARCHITECTURE

Two houses under one iron canopy

Norman White builds the paired houses at Nos. 3 and 4 (1845–1846)

3 Gramercy Park West belongs to the first generation of townhouses erected around Samuel B. Ruggles’s private square after Ruggles acquired the Gramercy Farm from the heirs of James Duane in 1831 and deeded the central garden to the surrounding forty-two lots. In the mid-1840s, paper merchant, philanthropist, and Gramercy Park Trustee Norman White (1805–1883) acquired the four northernmost lots along the western edge of the square.

A close view looking along No. 3’s cast-iron porch in winter sunshine, with the number 3 above the entrance, slender ornamented columns and the brick façade above.
3 Gramercy Park West, built in 1845–1846 by Norman White as a Greek Revival pair with 4 Gramercy Park West and fronted by Alexander Jackson Davis’s filigreed Gothic-and-arabesque cast-iron veranda and arched entrance canopy.

Before building the Italianate pair at 1 and 2 Gramercy Park West in 1849, White began his development in 1845–1846 with a symmetrical pair of four-story-and-basement red-brick residences at 3 and 4 Gramercy Park West. While White sold the southern house at No. 4 in 1847 to publisher and former Mayor James Harper (co-founder of Harper & Brothers), White and his wife, Mary Abiah Dodge White, made 3 Gramercy Park West their own family home for three years until they moved two doors north into the corner mansion at No. 1 in 1849. Looking toward the pair from inside the Park today, No. 3 stands on the right (north), fifty-two feet six inches south of East 21st Street.

Davis had imagined something still more extensive. A February 1842 drawing preserved at Columbia’s Avery Library proposes a symmetrical group of houses with iron porches along the whole western side of the Park. The complete row was never built as drawn. Garmey places verandas on the early houses at Nos. 5 and 6 in 1843 and dates construction of the No. 3–4 pair more precisely from May 1846 to completion in 1847.

A measured elevation of the paired houses, with No. 3 labeled on the right, flanked by enlarged drawings of cast-iron porch ornament.
Architect Albert E. Flanagan’s measured elevation and cast-iron porch detail drawing of 4 Gramercy Park West (left) and 3 Gramercy Park West (right), delineated on March 29, 1934, for the Historic American Buildings Survey (Library of Congress).

Alexander Jackson Davis’s cast-iron veranda

While the three-bay red-brick fronts, rectilinear stone lintels, and dentiled cornices of Nos. 3 and 4 follow the calm discipline of the late Greek Revival, their paired entrance stoops and shared parlor-floor veranda form one of the masterpieces of nineteenth-century New York ornamental ironwork. Attributed by the Landmarks Preservation Commission to pioneering architect Alexander Jackson Davis (1803–1892)—who lived just blocks away and championed the picturesque Gothic and Greek Revival styles—the unified cast-iron porch binds the two separate townhouses into a single architectural composition.

Slender openwork piers cast with scrolling grapevine, lotus, and geometric fretwork motifs rise to support shallow Tudor-style arches, delicate spandrel brackets, and a copper canopy roof crowned by cast-iron palmette and anthemion cresting. At the foot of the twin brownstone stoops stand four octagonal cast-iron newel posts—those flanking No. 4 topped by iron pinecones, and those at No. 3 crowned by cast-iron acorns and wrought-iron lanterns. As architect Albert E. Flanagan’s measured drawings for the 1934 Historic American Buildings Survey reveal, the porch’s lacelike delicacy rests upon a hidden structural armature of curved wrought-iron ribs and timber boarding. Because the twin houses share a single canopy, they are often mistaken for one another: the Stanford White fireplace interiors and Bob Dylan album-cover steps belong to Mayor James Harper’s house at No. 4, while No. 3 holds an equally rich story behind its own front door.

Look closely and the vocabulary expands: stylized honeysuckle, or anthemion, sits with Greek keys, rosettes, vines, and circular “wheels of eternity.” These patterns belong to the flourishing trade in architectural cast iron represented by firms such as Daniel Badger’s ironworks and J. B. & W. W. Cornell at 135–143 Centre Street. They provide the industrial context for the porches, whose particular foundry has not been established.

1866–1907 · THE FAMILY HOUSE

The lawyer at No. 3

Professor Benjamin Franklin Lee and Mary Ray King Lee

Following Norman White’s residency and the Civil War years, 3 Gramercy Park West was purchased in 1866 by twenty-seven-year-old attorney Benjamin Franklin Lee (1839–1907), who made the townhouse his home for the remaining forty-one years of his life. A graduate of Williams College (1858) and Columbia Law School (1861), where he studied under legendary jurist Theodore W. Dwight, Lee rose to prominence as senior partner of the Nassau Street law firm Lee & Lee, specializing in patent law, real estate, and equity jurisprudence. Appointed Professor of Real Estate and Equity Jurisprudence at Columbia Law School (1883–1890) and later lecturer on patent law at New York Law School, he also chaired the Executive Committee of the Association of the Bar of the City of New York and served as a devoted Trustee of Gramercy Park.

In November 1871, Lee married Mary Ray King (1848–1897), bringing one of early New York’s most distinguished political and financial lineages to 3 Gramercy Park West: she was the daughter of Cornelius King, granddaughter of railroad president and Congressman James Gore King (of Prime, Ward & King), and great-granddaughter of both Founding Father and U.S. Senator Rufus King and New York Chamber of Commerce president Cornelius Ray.

Four decades of family life on the western walk

Inside 3 Gramercy Park West, Benjamin and Mary Ray King Lee raised four children whose lives were woven into the fabric of the square: attorneys James Gore King Lee (Williams 1894) and Franklin Lawrence Lee (Yale 1895, New York Law School 1899), Cornelia (Caroline) King Lee, and Eliot Lee (Columbia 1896). During the winter season of 1894, the parlors behind the cast-iron veranda were filled with music and callers for daughter Caroline King Lee’s society debut teas and receptions.

After Mary Ray King Lee died at 3 Gramercy Park West in January 1897—with her funeral held across the square at Calvary Church—Professor Lee remained in the house with his children until his death there on March 3, 1907, at the age of sixty-eight. Remembered in his Century Association memorial for his legal scholarship and unfailing warmth, Lee left the house to his children, who leased it the following year for a trailblazing experiment in women’s higher education.

1908–1912 · THE NATIONAL TRAINING SCHOOL

A house that prepared women to lead

Grace Hoadley Dodge returns to her great-uncle’s house

In the autumn of 1908, 3 Gramercy Park West opened its doors as the inaugural home of the National Training School of the Young Women’s Christian Association of the U.S.A.—a graduate-level academy created to train professional women executives (“secretaries”) to lead city, university, industrial, and international YWCAs across the nation and around the globe.

The guiding spirit and benefactor behind the school was philanthropist Grace Hoadley Dodge (1856–1914). Having already co-founded Teachers College at Columbia University and the Travelers Aid Society of New York, Dodge had negotiated the 1906 merger that created the unified National Board of the YWCA and served as its founding president. In choosing 3 Gramercy Park West for the National Training School—personally guaranteeing the lease from the Lee estate, furnishing the rooms, and helping Dean Caroline B. Dow and faculty member Elizabeth Wilson design the curriculum—Dodge was returning to her own family’s roots: she was the grandniece of Norman White and Mary Abiah Dodge White, who had made 3 Gramercy Park West their home sixty years earlier.

As Elizabeth Wilson recorded in Vocations for the Trained Woman (1910) and Helen Thoburn recounted in her June 1911 magazine feature “Through Gramercy Park,” the house welcomed fifteen resident fellows in each of its first two years and thirty in its third—representing colleges across the United States alongside international students from Great Britain, Bulgaria, Mexico, and India. Taking graduate seminars in economics and sociology at Columbia University alongside resident courses in Biblical literature, labor legislation, public speaking, institutional management, and hygiene, the women prepared for salaried careers directing urban and international associations.

A photograph published in 1911 showing No. 3, its three-bay brick façade, shutters and iron porch, beside No. 2.
3 Gramercy Park West (left, beside the high stoop of 2 Gramercy Park West at right) in June 1911 during its years as the National Training School of the Young Women’s Christian Association.

Fieldwork in the city and candlelight around the fountain

Every second week, “visitation day” turned metropolitan New York into the students’ social-work laboratory—taking them to inspect women employees’ dining and recreation facilities at the Colgate plant and the Franco-American food factory in Jersey City, the New York State Reformatory for Women at Bedford Hills, immigrant settlement houses on the Lower East Side, and municipal courts. Between lectures, the students explored the city’s cultural life through symphony concerts, dollar balcony seats at the Metropolitan Opera, brass shops in the Lower East Side, Coney Island field days, and moonlight rides on the Staten Island Ferry.

Rare interior photographs published with Thoburn’s June 1911 essay show how gracefully the rooms built in 1845–1846 and later occupied by the Lee family adapted to collegiate life: students dined at round polished oak tables beneath a multi-globe chandelier, while the long double parlor—still retaining its Greek Revival pilasters, carved marble mantel, and crystal chandelier—was furnished with wicker armchairs and library tables looking out through the iron veranda into the trees of Gramercy Park.

Two historic interior photographs: a room with round tables beneath a chandelier, and a long furnished room with wicker chairs and a large wall mirror.
Two interior views of the YWCA National Training School inside 3 Gramercy Park West, published in June 1911 to illustrate Helen Thoburn’s article “Through Gramercy Park”: the dining room with round tables above, and the high-ceilinged parlor with crystal chandelier and wicker armchairs below.

For a school without a campus quad, Gramercy Park itself became the setting for its most cherished tradition. On Commencement Eve in May 1910, the white-gowned graduates entered the private garden, formed a circle around the central fountain singing their class hymn, and processed by candlelight back across the street and up the stoop of No. 3 while neighbors watched from open windows around the square.

A 1911 photograph of tree-lined paths, benches and the fence inside Gramercy Park.
Gramercy Park looking toward the central fountain as illustrated in Helen Thoburn’s June 1911 account of the YWCA National Training School, where graduating students held their annual candlelight procession.

The brass numeral “3” that traveled uptown (1912)

By 1912, the school’s success had outgrown the four-story townhouse. When the National Training School moved uptown in September 1912 into a purpose-built eleven-story headquarters at 135 East 52nd Street and Lexington Avenue (financed heavily by Grace Hoadley Dodge), the alumnae of the four Gramercy Park classes furnished an eleventh-floor common room christened “No. 3”—unscrewing the original antique brass numeral “3” from the front door of 3 Gramercy Park West and mounting it on their new door uptown. (As the New-York Tribune fondly reported at the December 1912 open house, the school’s longtime cook, Nancy, was less enamored of the skyscraper move: nine stories up in the air, she missed her old basement kitchen at 3 Gramercy Park West, where she could look out at the garden and step onto the back porch.)

1912–1939 · A DUTCH MEETING PLACE

The Netherland Club comes to Gramercy

Purchasing 3 Gramercy Park West for $52,000 (1912)

In the very month that the YWCA students departed for East 52nd Street, 3 Gramercy Park West welcomed an international clubhouse. By a deed dated September 5, 1912, and reported in the Real Estate Record and Builders’ Guide at $52,000, executor Eliot Lee conveyed 3 Gramercy Park Carriageway—described in the transfer as a four-story-and-basement brick dwelling with a two-story rear extension on a lot measuring 26 feet 3 inches by 110 feet, expressly “with rights to Gramercy Park”—to The Netherland Club of New York (De Nederlandsche Club).

Incorporated in 1903 to foster commercial, cultural, and social ties among Dutch-born New Yorkers, Americans of Dutch descent, and visitors from the Kingdom of the Netherlands, the club relocated to No. 3 from its earlier quarters on East 25th Street—joining the venerable lineup of Gramercy Park clubhouses that included The Players at No. 16, the National Arts Club at No. 15, the Columbia University Club at No. 18, and the Princeton Club on the north side of the square.

Center of Dutch New York and the 1926 New Amsterdam Tercentenary

For twenty-seven years, behind the striped window awnings and cast-iron veranda captured by photographer Berenice Abbott on November 27, 1935, 3 Gramercy Park West served as the diplomatic and social hearth of the Dutch community in America. In May 1925, at the club’s annual banquet inside No. 3, the Envoy Extraordinary and Minister Plenipotentiary of the Netherlands to the United States, Jonkheer Dr. A. C. D. de Graeff (later Foreign Minister of the Netherlands and Governor-General of the Dutch East Indies), called upon Dutch citizens across New York to gather monthly around the club’s table on Gramercy Park.

The following year, during the 1926 Tercentenary of the Founding of New Amsterdam (1626–1926), the Dutch journal Neerlandia directed all overseas delegations arriving in New York to report first to club secretary H. Crommelin at 3 Gramercy Park West. The Netherland Club remained on the square until late 1939, when it moved uptown to Holland House at 10 Rockefeller Plaza.

1939–TODAY · MODERNISM, HOLLYWOOD & THE SCREEN

New households behind the old front

Modernist architect Eugene Schoen converts the house (1939)

Upon the Netherland Club’s departure for Rockefeller Center in 1939, 3 Gramercy Park West was acquired and remodeled into nine residential apartments by architect, interior designer, and professor Eugene Schoen (1880–1957). Born in New York and trained in architecture at Columbia University before studying under Otto Wagner in Vienna, Schoen was one of the foremost champions of European modernism and Art Deco design in America—renowned for designing the streamlined interiors of the RKO Roxy (Center) Theatre at Rockefeller Center, the Nathan Straus Milk Pasteurization Laboratory, and custom modernist galleries and furniture. Respecting the 1846 Greek Revival brickwork and Alexander Jackson Davis’s cast-iron veranda on the exterior, Schoen deftly subdivided the deep townhouse and its rear extension into nine light-filled apartments.

Actor John Garfield’s final night (May 21, 1952)

Thirteen years after Schoen’s conversion, 3 Gramercy Park West became the setting of a poignant final chapter in American theater and film history. Stage and screen star John Garfield (born Jacob Julius Garfinkle, 1913–1952)—who had lived as a young Group Theatre actor across the square at the Hotel Irving (26 Gramercy Park South) before earning Academy Award nominations for Four Daughters (1938) and Body and Soul (1947), and starring in Pride of the Marines (1945) and Gentleman’s Agreement (1947)—had seen his film career cut short in 1951–1952 by the Hollywood blacklist after refusing to “name names” before the House Un-American Activities Committee.

Returning to the Broadway stage in a revival of Clifford Odets’s Golden Boy, the thirty-nine-year-old actor suffered a fatal heart attack in his sleep on the morning of May 21, 1952, while staying in the apartment of his friend, Broadway actress Iris Whitney (1914–1986), at 3 Gramercy Park West. More than ten thousand New Yorkers lined the streets for his funeral.

Historic District protection and a star turn on television

On September 20, 1966, the New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission designated the Gramercy Park Historic District (LP-0251, followed by listing on the National Register of Historic Places in 1980), singling out the paired townhouses and cast-iron porches of 3 and 4 Gramercy Park West as signature jewels of the square.

Today the house is a nine-unit residential cooperative. Its 1846 façade and filigreed iron veranda gained a new generation of admirers in 2023–2025 when the exterior was chosen as the Gramercy Park townhouse of columnist Carrie Bradshaw (played by Sarah Jessica Parker) in the HBO series And Just Like That…—bringing television cameras to the same iron-framed doorway where candles once glowed on graduation night in 1910.

  • Alexander Jackson DavisPioneering American Gothic Revival and Greek Revival architect (1803–1892); credited by the Landmarks Preservation Commission with designing the paired cast-iron verandas and entrance canopies at 3 and 4 Gramercy Park West
  • Jonkheer Andries Cornelis Dirk de GraeffDutch diplomat, Foreign Minister, and Envoy to the United States (1872–1957); honored speaker at the Netherland Club at 3 Gramercy Park West in 1925
  • Grace Hoadley DodgePhilanthropist, co-founder of Teachers College at Columbia University, founding president of the National Board of the YWCA, and grandniece of builder Norman White (1856–1914); established the YWCA National Training School at 3 Gramercy Park West in 1908
  • John GarfieldStage and Hollywood film star (Four Daughters, Body and Soul, Gentleman’s Agreement) (1913–1952); died of a heart attack at age thirty-nine while staying at 3 Gramercy Park West on May 21, 1952
  • Benjamin Franklin LeePatent and equity lawyer, Columbia Law School professor, and Trustee of Gramercy Park (1839–1907); purchased 3 Gramercy Park West in 1866 and lived here until his death in 1907
  • Mary Ray King LeeSociety matron, granddaughter of Congressman James Gore King, and great-granddaughter of Founding Father Rufus King (1848–1897); mistress of 3 Gramercy Park West from 1871 until her death in 1897
  • Eugene SchoenVienna-trained modernist architect and Art Deco designer of the RKO Roxy Theatre interiors (1880–1957); owned 3 Gramercy Park West and converted the building into apartments in 1939
  • Norman WhitePaper merchant, Vice President of the American Bible Society, and Trustee of Gramercy Park from 1848 to 1860 (1805–1883); built 3 and 4 Gramercy Park West in 1845–1846 and lived at No. 3 before moving to No. 1 in 1849
  • Iris WhitneyBroadway stage actress (1914–1986); mid-century resident of 3 Gramercy Park West in whose apartment friend John Garfield died in May 1952
Building at a glance

The building record

Address
3 Gramercy Park West (historically 3 Gramercy Park and 3 Gramercy Park Carriageway; Manhattan Block 876, Lot 12)
Historic names
The Norman White–Benjamin Franklin Lee House · YWCA National Training School (1908–1912) · The Netherland Club (1912–1939)
Built
1845–1846 (developed by Gramercy Park Trustee Norman White as the northern half of the No. 3–4 pair) Garmey’s construction chronology runs from May 1846 to completion in 1847.
Cast-iron veranda & canopy
Attributed to Alexander Jackson Davis (1803–1892) An unbuilt February 1842 drawing at Avery Library shows Davis’s broader proposal for a symmetrical west-side row.
Architecture
Four-story-and-basement Greek Revival red-brick and brownstone townhouse (26 ft. 3 in. x 110 ft. lot, with two-story rear extension) fronted by a Gothic-and-arabesque cast-iron porch shared with No. 4
1939 apartment conversion
Eugene Schoen, owner and architect
Present use
Nine-unit residential cooperative
Park access & landmark status
Deeded key privileges to Gramercy Park; within the 1966 NYC Gramercy Park Historic District (LP-0251) and 1980 National Register of Historic Places district

Over time

1831

Ruggles establishes Gramercy Park

Samuel B. Ruggles acquires the Gramercy Farm from the heirs of James Duane and deeds the central square to the forty-two surrounding residential lots.

1845–1846

Norman White builds Nos. 3 and 4

Paper merchant and future Gramercy Park Trustee Norman White erects the paired Greek Revival townhouses at 3 and 4 Gramercy Park West—adorned with Alexander Jackson Davis’s shared cast-iron veranda—and lives at No. 3 with his family until moving to No. 1 in 1849.

1866–1907

The Benjamin Franklin Lee household

Columbia Law School professor, patent attorney, and Gramercy Park Trustee Benjamin Franklin Lee purchases 3 Gramercy Park West in 1866, raising his family here with his wife Mary Ray King Lee until his death on March 3, 1907.

1908–1912

The YWCA National Training School

Philanthropist Grace Hoadley Dodge—grandniece of builder Norman White—equips 3 Gramercy Park West as the graduate National Training School of the YWCA, famous for its May 1910 candlelight commencement procession through Gramercy Park; moving uptown in September 1912, the alumnae take the brass door numeral “3” with them.

Sept. 1912–1939

The Netherland Club of New York

The Netherland Club purchases No. 3 from the Lee estate for $52,000, making the townhouse the center of Dutch diplomatic and cultural life in New York—including the 1926 New Amsterdam Tercentenary—until moving to 10 Rockefeller Plaza in 1939.

1934 & 1935

Federal architectural and photographic landmarks

Architect Albert E. Flanagan delineates measured drawings of the paired houses and ironwork for HABS on March 29, 1934, and Berenice Abbott photographs the twin entrances on November 27, 1935, for Changing New York.

1939 & May 21, 1952

Eugene Schoen’s apartments and John Garfield

Modernist architect Eugene Schoen converts No. 3 into nine apartments in 1939; on May 21, 1952, blacklisted actor John Garfield dies of a heart attack at age thirty-nine while staying in actress Iris Whitney’s apartment at No. 3.

Sept. 20, 1966–Today

Historic District and screen fame

Protected within the Gramercy Park Historic District since 1966, the nine-unit cooperative serves in 2023–2025 as the exterior of Carrie Bradshaw’s Gramercy Park residence in And Just Like That….

No. 3 through the years

  1. 1845–1846 · Norman White & A. J. Davis’s paired houses
  2. 1866 · Benjamin Franklin Lee’s house
  3. 1908 · A school for women opens
  4. 1910 · A candlelight commencement
  5. 1912 · The Netherland Club buys No. 3
  6. 1939 · Schoen converts the house
  7. 1966 · Historic district protection
  8. 2025 · Carrie Bradshaw’s exterior
Sources cited
01 · The land, the pair and the porch
  • John B. Pine, The Story of Gramercy Park, 1831–1921 (New York: Gramercy Park Association, 1921), pages 7–8 and 23 — Documenting the Duane estate purchase, Samuel B. Ruggles’s 1831 trust deed, and the early governance of the Park.
  • Erskine Norman White, Norman White: His Ancestors and His Descendants (New York: Printed for Private Distribution, 1905), pages 45–46 — Documenting Norman White’s construction of 3 and 4 Gramercy Park West in 1845–1846 and his residence at No. 3 prior to completing Nos. 1 and 2 in 1849.
  • Historic American Buildings Survey, James Harper House (including 3 Gramercy Park West), HABS No. NY-435 (HABS NY,31-NEYO,12), Library of Congress — Historical data report and Sheet 5 of 8 measured elevation and cast-iron porch detail drawing by architect Albert E. Flanagan, March 29, 1934.
  • New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission, Gramercy Park Historic District Designation Report (LP-0251, September 20, 1966), page 2 — Describing the western row and attributing the paired cast-iron porches of Nos. 3 and 4 to architect Alexander Jackson Davis.
  • Alexander Jackson Davis, February 1842 design for houses along the west side of Gramercy Park, Avery Architectural and Fine Arts Library, Columbia University; discussed in Stephen Garmey, Gramercy Park (1984), pp. 54–60. The drawing records the larger, unrealized composition behind the west-side porch tradition.
  • Stephen Garmey, Gramercy Park (1984), pp. 54–60, 116–117. West-side building chronology and ornamental ironwork; the Harper family’s house and Stanford White’s dining room.
02 · The Lee household
03 · The YWCA school and its students
  • Elizabeth Wilson, “The Young Women’s Christian Association,” in Agnes F. Perkins, ed., Vocations for the Trained Woman: Opportunities Other Than Teaching (Boston: Women’s Educational and Industrial Union, 1910), pages 68–70 — Detailing the 1908 opening of the National Training School at 3 Gramercy Park, curriculum, $350 annual tuition and board, and graduate salaries.
  • Helen Thoburn, “Through Gramercy Park,” The Crescent of Gamma Phi Beta, Vol. XI, No. 3 (June 1911), pages 197–202 — Firsthand illustrated account of student life inside 3 Gramercy Park, industrial and reformatory field visits, interior parlor and dining-room photographs, and the May 1910 candlelight commencement procession around the Gramercy Park fountain.
  • Elizabeth Wilson, “A Maker of Secretaries,” The Association Monthly: In Memory of Grace H. Dodge (March 1915), pages 108–110, and Abbie Graham, Grace H. Dodge: Merchant of Dreams (New York: The Womans Press, 1926) — Documenting Grace Hoadley Dodge’s role in leasing, equipping, and guiding the school at 3 Gramercy Park.
  • “No Joy for the Cook,” New-York Tribune, December 6, 1912, page 23 — Reporting the school’s September 1912 move to 135 East 52nd Street, the alumnae living room named “No. 3” with the original brass numeral from the Gramercy Park front door, and cook Nancy’s recollections of the Gramercy kitchen.
04 · The purchase and the Netherland Club
  • Real Estate Record and Builders’ Guide, September 14, 1912, page 120 — Recording the September 5, 1912 conveyance of 3 Gramercy Park Carriageway (26.3 x 110 ft., four-story-and-basement brick dwelling and two-story extension, “with rights to Gramercy Park”) by Eliot Lee, executor of Benjamin Franklin Lee, to the Netherland Club for $52,000.
  • Neerlandia: Orgaan van het Algemeen Nederlandsch Verbond (1925) — Reporting the May 1925 annual dinner address of Dutch envoy Jonkheer Dr. A. C. D. de Graeff at the Netherland Club, 3 Gramercy Park West, and directing visitors for the 1926 New Amsterdam Tercentenary to club secretary H. Crommelin at No. 3.
  • The New York Times (1912–1939) — Chronicles of the Netherland Club of New York at 3 Gramercy Park West prior to its 1939 relocation to Holland House at 10 Rockefeller Plaza.
05 · Apartments, landmark protection and the screen
  • New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission, 14 West 10th Street House Designation Report (LP-2510, 2012) & Avery Architectural & Fine Arts Library — Documenting modernist architect Eugene Schoen (1880–1957) as owner and architect of the 1939 apartment conversion of 3 Gramercy Park West.
  • The New York Times, May 22, 1952 (“John Garfield Dies in Apartment Here; Actor, 39, Succumbs to a Heart Ailment in Gramercy Park Home of Friend, Iris Whitney”), and Robert Nott, He Ran All the Way: The Life of John Garfield (Limelight Editions, 2003).
  • National Park Service, Gramercy Park Historic District, National Register of Historic Places Inventory-Nomination Form (NRHP No. 80002691, listed January 23, 1980).
  • Condé Nast Traveler / Architectural Digest (2023–2025) — Coverage of 3 Gramercy Park West as the exterior filming location for Carrie Bradshaw’s Gramercy Park townhouse in HBO’s And Just Like That….
Photo credits for this page
  1. Entrance and cast-iron veranda of 3 Gramercy Park West (January 18, 2018): Photograph by Eden, Janine and Jim, via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0).
  2. Paired entrances of 4 Gramercy Park West (left) and 3 Gramercy Park West (right), November 27, 1935: Photograph by Berenice Abbott, Changing New York (Federal Art Project / WPA); The New York Public Library, Miriam and Ira D. Wallach Division of Art, Prints and Photographs (Image ID 482721).
  3. Measured east elevation and cast-iron porch details of 4 and 3 Gramercy Park West, March 29, 1934: Delineated by architect Albert E. Flanagan for the Historic American Buildings Survey; Library of Congress, Prints and Photographs Division (HABS NY,31-NEYO,12, Sheet 5 of 8).
  4. Exterior of 3 Gramercy Park West, two interior student rooms, and view of Gramercy Park, published June 1911: Helen Thoburn, “Through Gramercy Park,” The Crescent of Gamma Phi Beta, Vol. XI, No. 3 (June 1911), pages 198, 200, and 202; Gamma Phi Beta Digital Archives.