2 Gramercy Park West
A New York home at the meeting of art, society, and conservation.
Guests at the Pinchots’ table
In June 1893, naturalist John Muir sat at the dining table of 2 Gramercy Park West and held the room spellbound with the story of an Alaskan glacier crossing and a brave little dog named Stickeen. Three springs later, on April 6, 1896, former President Benjamin Harrison and his bride Mary Scott Lord Dimmick stepped down from their carriage at the front stoop to celebrate their wedding breakfast in the parlors. For three decades, the townhouse just south of the East 21st Street corner was the Manhattan home of the Pinchot family—where James and Mary Eno Pinchot and their son Gifford Pinchot helped launch the American conservation movement, the United States Forest Service, and the Yale Forest School.
Completed in 1849 by paper merchant and Gramercy Park Trustee Norman White as an Italianate twin to 1 Gramercy Park West next door, No. 2 was remodeled into duplex and studio apartments in 1917–1922 by architects Grosvenor Atterbury and Aymar Embury II—acquiring the white-pilastered fifth-floor studio loggia that still crowns its red-brick façade overlooking the Park.
Behind the windows of No. 2
Two houses beside the Park
Norman White builds Nos. 1 and 2 Gramercy Park West (1849)
The architectural story of 2 Gramercy Park West began as half of a symmetrical composition. Having erected the Gothic Revival pair at 3 and 4 Gramercy Park West in the mid-1840s, paper merchant, philanthropist, and Gramercy Park Trustee Norman White (1805–1883) completed his development of the northern half of the western block in 1849 by building a matching pair of four-story-and-basement Italianate residences at 1 and 2 Gramercy Park West.
Built in compliance with Samuel B. Ruggles’s 1831 trust deed surrounding the private garden, the twin houses introduced the rounded lines of the Italianate style to the western edge of the square. Above rusticated brownstone basements and wrought-iron forecourt railings, each twenty-six-foot red-brick front rose three bays wide, animated by floor-length parlor windows opening onto delicate cast-iron balconies, segmental-arched brownstone window hoods, and a deep bracketed roof cornice.
Colonel Richard French and the Field family (1850s–1887)
While Norman White moved into the corner mansion at No. 1 and Dr. Valentine Mott followed him there in 1859, 2 Gramercy Park West became the longtime residence of Colonel Richard French (1804–1872)—proprietor of the famous French’s Hotel on Park Row opposite City Hall (later purchased by Joseph Pulitzer for the New York World Building), Tammany Hall leader, and New York City Police Commissioner. French lived at 2 Gramercy Park West until his death in June 1872, after which his widow Matilda French maintained the house until 1884.
In 1884, the townhouse was acquired by Laura Belden Field (1835–1901)—widow of Dudley Field and daughter-in-law of Gramercy Park legal reformer David Dudley Field II—who held the property until January 1887, when the Real Estate Record and Builders’ Guide reported her sale of the four-story brick dwelling at 2 Gramercy Park to James Wallace Pinchot for $57,500.
The Pinchots come to Gramercy
Between Gramercy Park and Grey Towers
When James Wallace Pinchot (1831–1908) and his wife, Mary Jane Eno Pinchot (1838–1914), moved into 2 Gramercy Park West in 1887, they united two influential New York and Pennsylvania lineages. Born in Milford, Pennsylvania, to a family of French Huguenot immigrants whose lumbering operations had cleared thousands of acres of the upper Delaware River valley, James Pinchot had amassed a fortune in the Manhattan wallpaper importing trade (Pinchot, Warren & Co.), retiring at forty-four to devote himself to civic philanthropy, the arts, and forest restoration. A Vice President of the National Academy of Design, a founder of the American Museum of Natural History, and a Trustee of both the Metropolitan Museum of Art and Gramercy Park, he had married Mary Jane Eno—daughter of Manhattan real-estate titan Amos Richards Eno, builder of the Fifth Avenue Hotel at Madison Square.
With their three children—Gifford (born 1865), Antoinette Eno, or “Nettie” (born 1868), and Amos Richards Eno (born 1873)—the Pinchots divided their year between 2 Gramercy Park West and Grey Towers, the ancestral Normandy-style stone château in Milford, Pennsylvania, that Richard Morris Hunt had completed for them in 1886. On December 21, 1892, the parlors of 2 Gramercy Park West were decked with palms and white roses for one of the season’s most celebrated diplomatic weddings, as Antoinette Pinchot married British diplomat Alan Vanden-Bempde-Johnstone (later Sir Alan Johnstone, British Minister to Denmark and the Netherlands).
Fifteen-year-old Edith Dresser’s winter before Biltmore (1888)
During the winter of 1888, while the Pinchots were traveling, they leased 2 Gramercy Park West to social matriarch Susan Elizabeth Fish LeRoy—niece of Governor Hamilton Fish and cousin of Stuyvesant Fish across the square at 19 Gramercy Park South—who gathered her five recently orphaned Dresser grandchildren under her wing in the house. As biographer Denise Kiernan recounts in the opening chapter of The Last Castle, among the teenagers living at 2 Gramercy Park West that winter was fifteen-year-old Edith Stuyvesant Dresser (1873–1958), a childhood friend of Nettie Pinchot from Newport dancing classes. Ten years later, Edith Dresser married George Washington Vanderbilt II and became mistress of Biltmore Estate in Asheville, North Carolina—where her Gramercy neighbor Gifford Pinchot had helped establish the estate’s pioneering forestry program.
The wilderness at the dinner table
John Muir dines at No. 2 and tells the story of Stickeen (1893)
Few Manhattan dining rooms ever witnessed a more consequential gathering for the American environment than the parlor floor of 2 Gramercy Park West. Determined to atone for the clear-cutting of Pennsylvania’s forests, James Pinchot had urged his eldest son, Gifford Pinchot (1865–1946), to become the first professionally trained American forester—sending him after his 1889 graduation from Yale to study at the French National School of Forestry in Nancy.
In June 1893, during a whirlwind visit to New York before sailing for Europe, naturalist and Sierra Club founder John Muir (1838–1914) was welcomed to 2 Gramercy Park West by James, Mary, and twenty-seven-year-old Gifford Pinchot alongside Century Magazine associate editor Robert Underwood Johnson. Writing to his wife Louie on June 12, 1893, Muir described how he had “dined in grand style” at the Pinchots’ house on Gramercy Park—noting young Gifford’s trailblazing work in forestry—and recounted how he held the table spellbound with his true adventure of crossing a perilous Alaskan glacier crevasse in a storm alongside a fearless little dog named Stickeen, the tale Muir eventually published as his classic book Stickeen (1909).
Biltmore, the U.S. Forest Service, and the Yale Forest School
Six months after that dinner, in December 1893, while residing at 2 Gramercy Park West and managing the experimental forest at George Vanderbilt’s Biltmore Estate, Gifford Pinchot opened America’s first consulting forestry office in New York City. Appointed chief of the federal Division of Forestry in 1898 and chosen by President Theodore Roosevelt in 1905 to serve as the first Chief of the United States Forest Service, Pinchot coined the term “conservation” as a public ethic—managing hundreds of millions of acres of national forests for “the greatest good of the greatest number in the long run.”
In 1900, inside the family circle linking 2 Gramercy Park West and Grey Towers, James, Mary, Gifford, and Amos Pinchot provided the $150,000 founding endowment to establish the Yale Forest School (today the Yale School of the Environment), with Grey Towers serving each summer as the outdoor field camp where Yale students trained in scientific forestry.
A president’s wedding day
Benjamin Harrison and Mary Scott Lord Dimmick’s wedding reception (1896)
On Monday afternoon, April 6, 1896, 2 Gramercy Park West stepped onto the national front page as the setting for a presidential wedding celebration. Following their marriage ceremony at St. Thomas Episcopal Church at Fifth Avenue and 53rd Street, twenty-third President of the United States Benjamin Harrison (1833–1901) and his bride, Mary Scott Lord Dimmick (1858–1948)—who had grown up in Honesdale, Pennsylvania, near the Pinchots’ country home in Milford—rode by carriage down to Gramercy Park, where James and Mary Pinchot hosted the bridal reception and wedding breakfast inside No. 2.
Harrison kept the church guest list small. After the ceremony, more than thirty distinguished guests—led by New York Governor and former Vice President Levi P. Morton, former Navy Secretary Benjamin F. Tracy, former Treasury Secretary Charles Foster, and former Attorney General William H. H. Miller—gathered around the Pinchots’ table overlooking Gramercy Park before the newlyweds changed into traveling attire and boarded their private railroad car for Indianapolis.
Bach recitals, Secretary John G. Carlisle, and F. Hopkinson Smith’s fiction
Throughout the turn-of-the-century years, Mary Eno Pinchot made the drawing rooms of 2 Gramercy Park West a center for music, letters, and public affairs—hosting events such as music critic W. J. Henderson and the Bach Singers’ February 1900 lecture-recital on Passion music. In 1903, while the Pinchots were in Washington, they leased the house to former Speaker of the U.S. House of Representatives, U.S. Senator from Kentucky, and U.S. Secretary of the Treasury John Griffin Carlisle (1834–1910) and his wife, Mary Goodson Carlisle.
The townhouse even entered American fiction during the Pinchots’ ownership. When engineer, artist, and novelist F. Hopkinson Smith published his bestselling 1898 novel Caleb West, Master Diver, he modeled the Gramercy Park residence of the benevolent society matron Mrs. Leroy directly on the Pinchots’ house at 2 Gramercy Park West—an identification confirmed by literary historian Arthur Bartlett Maurice in The New York of the Novelists (1917).
The house changes its work
Amos Pinchot and the 1907 dressmaking controversy
After James and Mary Pinchot shifted their primary winter residence to Washington, D.C.—where they built a mansion near Dupont Circle to be close to Gifford’s work with President Theodore Roosevelt—their younger son, reform attorney, progressive publicist, and future American Civil Liberties Union co-founder Amos Richards Eno Pinchot (1873–1944), managed the Gramercy Park house. In June 1907, a story in The New York Times headlined “Trade in Gramercy Park” reported a lively neighborhood stir when Amos Pinchot granted a five-year lease on 2 Gramercy Park West to society dressmaker Mrs. C. W. Sherwin. Though a few traditionalists fretted that a couturier’s atelier might breach the square’s residential calm, Mrs. Sherwin kept her establishment completely discreet behind the 1849 brick façade, and she told the newspaper that no neighbor had complained to her directly.
Ronald C. Lee, Grosvenor Atterbury, and Aymar Embury II (1917–1918)
Following James Pinchot’s death in 1908 and Mary Eno Pinchot’s death in 1914, the Pinchot estate sold 2 Gramercy Park West in February 1917 to real-estate broker and civic leader Ronald Currie Lee. That year Lee embarked on a studio-apartment transformation of No. 2. At 1 Gramercy Park West next door, architect Adolph Mertin undertook a separate apartment conversion.
After initial studio plans were announced in April 1917 by architect Grosvenor Atterbury, architect Aymar Embury II (1880–1966)—celebrated designer of country houses and later chief architect for the Triborough Bridge and New York City Parks Department—filed the definitive $15,000 alteration plans in May 1917. Embury removed the 1849 high brownstone stoop, relocated the main entrance down to the English-basement level, installed a passenger elevator and interior mezzanine levels, and rebuilt the top of the façade with its signature Classical Revival feature: a tall fifth-floor studio loggia framed by four white pilasters, three multi-pane studio windows with curved wrought-iron Juliet balconies, and a crowned rooftop balustrade. By March 1918, the newly completed studio and duplex apartments were fully rented.
A garden at the door
Aymar Embury II’s 1922 penthouse addition
Five years after the studio conversion, owner Ronald C. Lee called once more upon architect Aymar Embury II. In July 1922, Embury filed plans for a $5,000 rooftop penthouse addition set back behind the fifth-floor balustrade, completing the building’s vertical evolution from a four-story antebellum family home into a multi-level house of sunlit studios and duplexes.
The 1945 Gramercy Park garden prize
Even after its conversion into apartments, 2 Gramercy Park West remained a model of neighborhood pride along the western walk. In the spring of 1945, at the annual Gramercy Park Flower Show and doorway competition, Ronald C. Lee’s building was awarded a neighborhood prize for its lushly planted front courtyard—where English ivy, clipped privet hedges, and cascading parlor-balcony window boxes framed the ground-floor entrance opposite the iron gates of the Park.
Preserving the western row
Landmark protection and architectural dialogue (1966–today)
On September 20, 1966, the New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission designated the Gramercy Park Historic District (LP-0251, followed by listing on the National Register of Historic Places in 1980), recognizing 2 Gramercy Park West as an essential anchor of the square’s celebrated western row. In their designation report, the commissioners highlighted how the 1849 Italianate pair at Nos. 1 and 2 and the 1840s Gothic Revival pair at Nos. 3 and 4 formed a cohesive nineteenth-century streetscape whose early-twentieth-century studio alterations had become an integral part of the neighborhood’s artistic character.
Reading the house from the sidewalk today
Organized today as an eight-unit residential cooperative, 2 Gramercy Park West invites any passerby on the western sidewalk to read two distinct eras of Gramercy history in a single glance. On the lower floors, the rusticated brownstone basement, wrought-iron parlor balcony, and segmental-arched brownstone window hoods still mirror its 1849 twin at No. 1—preserving the proportions of the dining room where John Muir spoke of glaciers and President Benjamin Harrison toasted his bride. High above, the tall multi-pane windows and white classical pilasters of the 1917 studio loggia catch the morning light across the trees of Gramercy Park.
Residents of Note
The People of Gramercy- John Griffin CarlisleSpeaker of the U.S. House of Representatives, U.S. Senator from Kentucky, and U.S. Secretary of the Treasury (1834–1910); leased 2 Gramercy Park West with his wife Mary in 1903
- Edith Stuyvesant Dresser (Mrs. George W. Vanderbilt)Philanthropist and mistress of Biltmore Estate (1873–1958); lived at 2 Gramercy Park West as a fifteen-year-old with her grandmother Susan Elizabeth Fish LeRoy during the winter of 1888
- Aymar Embury IIArchitect of the 1917 studio conversion and 1922 penthouse addition at 2 Gramercy Park West (1880–1966), later chief architect for the New York City Parks Department and Triborough Bridge Authority
- Richard FrenchAntebellum proprietor of French’s Hotel on Park Row and New York City Police Commissioner (1804–1872); lived at 2 Gramercy Park West from the 1850s until his death in 1872
- Amos Richards Eno PinchotReform attorney, Progressive Party co-founder, and founding board member of the American Civil Liberties Union (1873–1944); grew up at 2 Gramercy Park West and managed the property in the 1900s
- Gifford PinchotFirst Chief of the United States Forest Service (1905–1910), co-founder of the Yale Forest School, and two-term Governor of Pennsylvania (1865–1946); lived at 2 Gramercy Park West and opened his first consulting forestry office in New York in 1893
- James Wallace PinchotWallpaper merchant, patron of American forestry, Vice President of the National Academy of Design, and Trustee of the Metropolitan Museum of Art and Gramercy Park (1831–1908); purchased 2 Gramercy Park West in January 1887
- Mary Jane Eno PinchotPhilanthropist, conservation benefactor, and daughter of real-estate developer Amos R. Eno (1838–1914); presided over the literary, musical, and political salon at 2 Gramercy Park West from 1887 to 1914
- Norman WhitePaper merchant, Vice President of the American Bible Society, and Trustee of Gramercy Park from 1848 to 1860 (1805–1883); built the Italianate pair at 1 and 2 Gramercy Park West in 1849
Building at a glance
2 Gramercy Park West · Built 1849
The building record
- Address
- 2 Gramercy Park West (between East 20th and East 21st Streets; Manhattan Block 876, Lot 11)
- Historic names
- The James W. & Mary Eno Pinchot House · earlier Col. Richard French House
- Built
- 1849 (developed by Gramercy Park Trustee Norman White as an Italianate twin to 1 Gramercy Park West)
- Original architect
- Unknown
- 1917–1922 studio & penthouse alterations
- Ronald C. Lee, owner; Grosvenor Atterbury (initial April 1917 studio plans) and Aymar Embury II (May 1917 studio conversion and July 1922 penthouse addition)
- Architecture
- Five-story (plus basement and setback penthouse) red-brick and brownstone townhouse combining an 1849 Italianate lower façade with a 1917 Classical Revival pilastered fifth-floor studio loggia
- Present use
- Eight-unit residential cooperative
- Park access & landmark status
- Deeded key privileges to Gramercy Park; within the 1966 NYC Gramercy Park Historic District (LP-0251) and 1980 National Register of Historic Places district
Over time
An Italianate pair rises
Paper merchant and Gramercy Park Trustee Norman White completes 1 and 2 Gramercy Park West as matching four-story-and-basement Italianate townhouses.
The French and Field households
Police Commissioner and hotelier Colonel Richard French lives at No. 2 until his death in 1872, and his widow Matilda remains until 1884. Laura Belden Field, widow of Dudley Field and daughter-in-law of David Dudley Field II, sells the house to James W. Pinchot for $57,500 in January 1887.
The Pinchots, Edith Dresser, and a diplomatic wedding
James and Mary Eno Pinchot establish their New York home at No. 2; teenage Edith Stuyvesant Dresser (future mistress of Biltmore) winters here in 1888, and daughter Antoinette Pinchot marries British diplomat Alan Johnstone in the parlor in December 1892.
John Muir dines at No. 2
Naturalist John Muir dines with James, Mary, and Gifford Pinchot at 2 Gramercy Park West and recounts his Alaskan glacier adventure with the dog Stickeen; six months later, Gifford Pinchot opens America’s first consulting forestry office in New York.
President Benjamin Harrison’s wedding reception
Former President Benjamin Harrison and Mary Scott Lord Dimmick hold their wedding reception and breakfast at the Pinchots’ house following their marriage at St. Thomas Church.
Founding the Yale Forest School and Secretary Carlisle’s tenancy
The Pinchot family endows the Yale Forest School in 1900, and former U.S. Treasury Secretary John G. Carlisle leases 2 Gramercy Park West in 1903.
Aymar Embury II’s studio and penthouse conversion
Purchased from the Pinchot estate by Ronald C. Lee in February 1917, the house has its high stoop removed and is remodeled into studio apartments with a white-pilastered fifth-floor loggia (1917) and rooftop penthouse (1922).
A prize-winning courtyard garden
At the annual Gramercy Park Flower Show, Ronald C. Lee’s building wins a neighborhood prize for its ivy- and privet-planted entrance courtyard and balcony window boxes.
Gramercy Park Historic District
2 Gramercy Park West is designated within the New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission’s Gramercy Park Historic District.
An eight-unit cooperative on the western row
Maintained as an eight-unit residential cooperative with deeded key privileges to Gramercy Park, 2 Gramercy Park West preserves both its 1849 Italianate lower stories and its 1917 Classical Revival fifth-floor studio loggia.
A house through time
Sources cited
- New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission. Gramercy Park Historic District, LP-0251. September 20, 1966, especially p. 2. The west-side architectural group, Italianate classification, and district designation.
- Erskine Norman White. Norman White: His Ancestors and His Descendants (New York: Printed for Private Distribution, 1905), pages 46 and 79. Documents Norman White’s development of the northern half of Gramercy Park West and the completion of the Italianate pair at Nos. 1 and 2 in 1849.
- Real Estate Record & Builders’ Guide. January 22, 1887, p. 106. Contemporary notice of the sale to James W. Pinchot. Columbia University Libraries.
- The New York Times, December 22, 1892. Account of the December 21, 1892 wedding of Antoinette Eno Pinchot and British diplomat Alan Johnstone (later Sir Alan Johnstone) at the residence of James W. Pinchot, 2 Gramercy Park.
- Kiernan, Denise. The Last Castle. Touchstone, 2017, chapter 1, “A Winter’s Tale.” Documents fifteen-year-old Edith Stuyvesant Dresser’s winter at 2 Gramercy Park West in 1888 with her grandmother Susan Elizabeth Fish LeRoy.
- Muir, John. Letter to Louie Strentzel Muir, June 12–13, 1893. John Muir Correspondence, item 924; Holt-Atherton Special Collections, University of the Pacific. Muir’s account of dinner at the Pinchots’ Gramercy house.
- Forest History Society. “Gifford Pinchot (1865–1946).” Forestry training, Biltmore, federal appointments, and conservation work.
- Forest History Society. “Grey Towers Estate History.” The family’s residences and the development of Grey Towers.
- Yale School of the Environment. “History,” The Forest School. The school’s foundation in 1900 and first summer training at Grey Towers in 1901.
- Richmond Dispatch. April 7, 1896. Contemporary report of the Harrison–Dimmick wedding. Library of Congress newspaper collection. The bridal party’s reception at No. 2 after the church ceremony.
- Maurice, Arthur Bartlett. The New York of the Novelists. Dodd, Mead, 1917, p. 224. Identification of No. 2 with Mrs. Leroy’s house in F. Hopkinson Smith’s Caleb West, Master Diver.
- Smith, F. Hopkinson. Caleb West, Master Diver. Houghton, Mifflin, 1898. The novel’s fictional Gramercy Park house and Mrs. Leroy’s household.
- Real Estate Record & Builders’ Guide. February 10, 1917, p. 191. Sale from the Pinchot estate and the former asking price.
- Real Estate Record & Builders’ Guide. February 17, 1917, p. 230. Brokerage report and discussion of a prospective apartment-house improvement.
- Real Estate Record & Builders’ Guide. April 7, 1917, p. 494. Atterbury’s announced studio-apartment commission for Ronald C. Lee.
- Real Estate Record & Builders’ Guide. May 26, 1917, p. 345. Filed alteration plans naming Aymar Embury; plan 1351.
- Real Estate Record & Builders’ Guide. July 15, 1922, p. 94. Aymar Embury II’s penthouse proposal for Ronald C. Lee; plan 1481.
- Miller, Tom. “The James Pinchot House—No. 2 Gramercy Park.” Daytonian in Manhattan, August 1, 2014. Early occupants, household events, later tenancy, the garden award, and an illustrated history.
- The New York Times. “Trade in Gramercy Park.” June 9, 1907, p. 6. Mrs. C. W. Sherwin’s tenancy, Amos Pinchot’s lease, and neighbors’ reactions.
Photo credits for this page
- Exterior view of 2 Gramercy Park West: Photograph by Tom Miller (2014), Daytonian in Manhattan.
- Mary Jane Eno Pinchot, Gifford Pinchot, and James Wallace Pinchot at Grey Towers: Grey Towers National Historic Site / Grey Towers Heritage Association.
- Gramercy Park West (Nos. 1–4) before the 1917 studio conversions, c. 1909 (Carousel 1/2): Photograph by George F. Arata; Museum of the City of New York.
- Gramercy Park West before the 1917 studio conversions (Carousel 2/2): Gramercy Park Block Association historical archive.
- Naturalist John Muir (1902): Photograph by Helen Lukens Jones; Library of Congress, Prints and Photographs Division (LC-USZ62-52000).
- Illustration of Mary Scott Lord Dimmick Harrison (April 1896): The Pullman Herald, April 11, 1896.
- Gramercy Park West showing Nos. 2, 3, and 4 in the late 1930s: Photograph by Beecher Ogden; Museum of the City of New York.