Gramercy Park Block Association
Gramercy Stories

21 Gramercy Park South

The house behind the brick: John Bigelow, a public library, and a new audience for the arts.

The present brick façade of No. 21, framed by older houses and the trees of Gramercy Park.
21 Gramercy Park South today, showing the six-story buff-brick apartment façade installed in 1956 between the 1847 Henry M. Field House at left (No. 22) and the mansard-roofed 19 Gramercy Park South at right.

BOOKS BEHIND A CHANGED FAÇADE

A plain postwar brick front can conceal one of the most consequential addresses in New York history. Behind the doors of 21 Gramercy Park South, elder statesman, author, and former U.S. Minister to France John Bigelow spent the final thirty-one years of his ninety-four-year life surrounded by ten thousand books, children and grandchildren, and visitors ranging from Oscar Wilde and Julia Ward Howe to Mark Twain and J. Pierpont Morgan. Having defended the Union cause in Paris during the Civil War, Bigelow worked from his study on Gramercy Park to unite the Tilden Trust with the Astor and Lenox Libraries in 1895—creating the New York Public Library and serving as its founding president through the dedication of its Fifth Avenue palace in May 1911.

For two decades after his death, his daughter Grace Bigelow preserved the family’s vast historical archive and served as a Trustee of Gramercy Park, before the nineteenth-century salons welcomed modernist painter Yun Gee and the National Musical Benefit Society in the 1930s and 1940s. Refaced in buff brick and raised to six stories in 1956, No. 21 remains a vital link in the literary and civic heritage of the square.

Explore the history

The Bigelow house through time

01
1851–1880 · ANTEBELLUM ORIGINS

A brownstone beside the Park

Henry Trowbridge’s 1851 Italianate mansion

Built in 1851 as the southern perimeter of Samuel B. Ruggles’s private square filled with substantial single-family residences, 21 Gramercy Park South was erected as the home of dry-goods merchant Henry Trowbridge, head of the firm of Henry Trowbridge & Co. at 63 Maiden Lane. Constructed on a twenty-six-foot-wide lot next to the corner lot at Irving Place, the house rose four stories above a rusticated English basement in the newly fashionable Italianate style—clad in smooth ashlar brownstone with three bays of segmental-arched windows beneath molded hood lintels and crowned by a deep modillioned and bracketed roof cornice. In the 1907 photograph published in Old Buildings of New York City, those four Italianate upper stories stand framed between the high brownstone stoop of No. 22 to the east, the ivy-clad walls of No. 19 to the west, and an iron-caged Gramercy Park streetlamp at the curb.

The John Bigelow residence as published in 1907: three bays, arched windows, and a bracketed cornice.
The John Bigelow residence at 21 Gramercy Park South as published in Old Buildings of New York City (1907), showing its 1851 Italianate brownstone upper stories, segmental-arched windows, bracketed cornice, and the ground-level American-basement entrance added in 1893.

Two decades as the Benjamin J. Curtis home (1860–1880)

On February 16, 1860, Trowbridge advertised the property for sale in the New York Morning Courier as “the superior four story brown stone front house, No. 21 Gramercy Park, 20th street, next to the corner of Irving Place; built in the best manner expressly for the owner.” Purchased that year by prominent Park Place merchant Benjamin J. Curtis, the brownstone served for the next two decades—throughout the Civil War and Reconstruction—as the Curtis family residence, until John and Jane Poultney Bigelow acquired the house in 1880.

02
1880–1893 · THE BIGELOW HOUSEHOLD

A diplomat comes home

From the Evening Post and Lincoln’s Paris legation to Gramercy Park

When sixty-two-year-old John Bigelow (1817–1911) and his wife, Jane Tunis Poultney Bigelow (1829–1889), moved into 21 Gramercy Park South in 1880, Bigelow had already lived several extraordinary public lives. Born in Malden-on-Hudson, New York, and educated at Union College, he had been a prison reformer, Free-Soil antislavery activist, and from 1848 to 1861 co-owner and managing editor—alongside poet William Cullen Bryant—of the New York Evening Post. Dispatched to Paris by President Abraham Lincoln as American Consul in 1861 and elevated to U.S. Minister to France (1865–1866), Bigelow masterminded the diplomatic and intelligence campaign that blocked Napoleon III from recognizing the Confederacy and halted the secret construction of Confederate ironclad warships in French shipyards. Returning home, he served as New York’s Secretary of State (1875–1877) under Governor Samuel J. Tilden, his close friend and soon-to-be Gramercy Park neighbor.

Garmey relates an unusually tactful gift behind the Bigelows’ home on the square: Tilden put the house in Grace Bigelow’s name, knowing that her father would refuse such generosity if it were offered directly to him. Their friendship extended from politics and books into the practical arrangements of neighboring households. Bigelow also served as president of the Century Association, another gathering place for the literary and artistic friends who visited Gramercy Park.

Salon life and the 1893 stoop removal

Dividing their year between 21 Gramercy Park South and their Hudson Highlands country estate, The Squirrels, in Highland Falls, John and Jane Bigelow—together with their daughters Grace, Jennie, and Annie, and sons John Bigelow Jr. and Poultney Bigelow—made No. 21 one of Manhattan’s liveliest intellectual salons. In January 1882, they hosted Oscar Wilde at dinner during his American lecture tour; in December 1882, they threw a glittering debutante ball and cotillion in the parlors for their daughter Annie; in February 1886, while John and eldest daughter Grace sailed to Panama with French engineer Philippe Bunau-Varilla to inspect Ferdinand de Lesseps’s canal works, Jane hosted a dinner at No. 21 for Julia Ward Howe and her daughters; and on April 28, 1886, three hundred guests—including the Duke of Sutherland, J. Pierpont Morgan, and Whitelaw Reid—gathered at 21 Gramercy Park South for the wedding breakfast of daughter Jennie Poultney Bigelow and attorney Charles Edward Tracy.

Jane’s dinner for Wilde brought a sharper note into the salon. The twenty-seven-year-old visitor turned heads around New York in a velvet suit, black silk stockings, and buckled shoes, with a white walking stick in his lavender-gloved hands. His 1882 American lecture tour accompanied the D’Oyly Carte Opera Company’s New York production of Gilbert and Sullivan’s Patience, and society hostesses filled his Grand Hotel suite with flowers and invitations. But Gramercy poet, critic, and Wall Street broker Edmund Clarence Stedman, a presiding figure at the conservative Century Club, wanted nothing to do with the fashionable visitor.

Stedman angrily refused his close friend Jane’s invitation to meet Wilde at No. 21. He went further: any future dinner she gave for Stedman himself, he told her, would now seem far less of an honor, since she had extended the same hospitality to Oscar Wilde.

For all its sociability, the house followed John Bigelow’s strict personal regimen. In the family recollections discussed by Garmey, he distrusted hot-air furnaces and relied on coal fires in the fireplaces. He took cold baths each morning, drove out daily in an open carriage even in winter, and avoided tea, coffee, and vanilla as stimulants. Andrew Carnegie nevertheless sent Scotch whisky and oatmeal as birthday presents.

After Jane Poultney Bigelow died at 21 Gramercy Park South in February 1889, eldest daughter Grace Bigelow (1852–1932) assumed leadership of the household, joined by her sisters Annie Bigelow Harding (widowed in 1890, whose daughter Charlotte was born at No. 21 that year) and Jennie Bigelow Tracy (widowed in 1896). In October 1893, Grace Bigelow commissioned architect Francis Conlon and builders P. McCormack & Son for a $10,000 modernization that gave the house the appearance recorded in the 1907 photograph: removing the original 1851 high brownstone stoop in favor of a street-level American-basement entrance framed by classical columns, and converting the former second-story entrance doorway into a third arched parlor window overlooking the Park.

John Bigelow in a nineteenth-century portrait from the Brady–Handy collection.
John Bigelow (1817–1911), co-editor of the New York Evening Post and Abraham Lincoln’s envoy to Paris during the Civil War, photographed in the 1860s by the Mathew Brady studio (Library of Congress).
03
1886–1911 · FOUNDING THE NEW YORK PUBLIC LIBRARY

A library for the whole city

Fulfilling Samuel J. Tilden’s bequest (1886–1895)

No achievement connected to 21 Gramercy Park South touched more New Yorkers than the creation of the New York Public Library. Six doors west at 15 Gramercy Park South lived Bigelow’s lifelong friend and political ally, former Governor and 1876 presidential popular-vote winner Samuel J. Tilden. When Tilden died in August 1886, leaving the bulk of his $5 million estate to establish a free public library and reading room in New York City, Bigelow—as chief executor and president of the Tilden Trust, alongside co-trustees Andrew H. Green and George W. Smith—fought through years of courtroom challenges before conceiving a bold masterstroke: uniting the Tilden Trust’s endowment with the struggling reference collections of the Astor Library on Lafayette Place and the Lenox Library on Fifth Avenue.

Negotiated by Bigelow and signed on May 23, 1895, the articles of consolidation created The New York Public Library, Astor, Lenox and Tilden Foundations. Elected the Library’s first president on May 27, 1895—a post he held for the remaining sixteen years of his life—Bigelow worked with director Dr. John Shaw Billings and architects Carrère & Hastings to secure the old Croton Reservoir site at Fifth Avenue and 42nd Street for the monumental Beaux-Arts library building.

Benjamin Franklin’s Autobiography and a ninety-four-year life

Inside his upstairs “book room” at 21 Gramercy Park South—where an 1888 family ledger preserved at Union College recorded thousands of volumes and historic autographs beneath a portrait of Benjamin Franklin over the mantelpiece—Bigelow remained a prolific scholar well into his nineties. Having tracked down and published the original autograph manuscript of Benjamin Franklin’s Autobiography while serving in Paris, he edited the definitive ten-volume Complete Works of Benjamin Franklin (1887–1888), the two-volume Life of Samuel J. Tilden (1895), and his own five-volume Retrospections of an Active Life (1909–1913). On New Year’s Day 1906, following a visit to J. Pierpont Morgan’s newly completed marble library on East 36th Street, the eighty-eight-year-old Bigelow sent Morgan from 21 Gramercy Park South a New Year’s gift of original manuscript notes relating to Franklin’s Autobiography, still preserved at the Morgan Library & Museum.

On May 23, 1911—the sixteenth anniversary of the consolidation agreement—the ninety-three-year-old Bigelow stood beside President William Howard Taft, Governor John A. Dix, and Mayor William Jay Gaynor to dedicate the completed New York Public Library on Fifth Avenue. Seven months later, on December 19, 1911, New York’s “First Citizen” died peacefully at 21 Gramercy Park South at the age of ninety-four.

John Bigelow in his eighties, holding his spectacles in his study at 21 Gramercy Park South.
John Bigelow in his eighties during his presidency of the New York Public Library, photographed in his book-lined study at 21 Gramercy Park South.
04
1911–1932 · STEWARDSHIP OF THE ARCHIVE & THE PARK

Grace keeps the record

Preserving a century of letters and diaries

For two decades after her father’s death in 1911, Grace Bigelow maintained 21 Gramercy Park South as the family homestead and archival repository—hosting her niece Charlotte K. Harding’s society debut in the house and presiding over the library where her father had worked. Determined that her father’s correspondence with Lincoln, Seward, Bryant, Tilden, Twain, and Thackeray belong to the public institution he had helped found, she donated the core of the John Bigelow Papers to the New York Public Library between 1924 and 1932, with additional family books and manuscripts later joining his alma mater, Union College.

A Gramercy Park Trustee

Like her father—who in 1902 had convened meetings of neighborhood homeowners in the parlor of No. 21 to defend the residential scale of the square when the nine-story Hotel Irving rose at No. 26—Grace Bigelow devoted herself to the governance of Gramercy Park. As John B. Pine recorded in The Story of Gramercy Park, 1831–1921, she was elected a Trustee of Gramercy Park in 1916, helping steward the private garden across the street until her death at sea aboard the liner Rotterdam on October 14, 1932, at the age of eighty.

Grace was the Park’s first woman Trustee. In 1932, the final year of her life, she became President of the Trustees, carrying the family’s long involvement with the square into its second generation.

05
1934–1946 · PAINTING AND PERFORMANCE

The salon opens to the arts

Modernist painter Yun Gee and the National Musical Benefit Society

Following Grace Bigelow’s death in 1932, the Bigelow estate leased the historic townhouse to the National Musical Benefit Society, which transformed the ground- and parlor-floor reception rooms into a “Main Salon” for chamber recitals, benefit concerts, and art exhibitions—extending the cultural corridor anchored a few doors west by The Players at No. 16 and the National Arts Club at No. 15.

In January 1934, the salon at 21 Gramercy Park South hosted a remarkable dual event: an exhibition of modernist oil paintings paired with a solo classical Chinese dance and musical recital by artist, poet, and inventor Yun Gee (1906–1963). Born in Kaiping, Guangdong, before immigrating to San Francisco at fifteen and achieving acclaim in Paris and New York as the founder of “Diamondism” and painter of the 1932 Museum of Modern Art showstopper Wheels: Industrial New York, Gee used the nineteenth-century parlor of the Bigelow house to bring avant-garde painting and performance together under one roof.

The 1940 tax photograph and the 1946 sale

Captured in the New York City municipal tax photograph around 1940, 21 Gramercy Park South still wore its nineteenth-century brownstone elevation—its segmental-arched windows, bracketed cornice, and 1893 ground-level portico standing intact between red-brick No. 22 and mansard-roofed No. 19—until May 1946, when the New York Sun reported that the Bigelow heirs had sold the property after sixty-six years of family ownership.

No. 21 at center in the municipal tax photograph, c. 1940, before the brownstone façade was replaced.
21 Gramercy Park South (center) in the c. 1940 municipal tax photograph—still wearing its nineteenth-century Italianate brownstone façade and 1893 ground-floor portico alongside 22 Gramercy Park South (left) and 19 Gramercy Park South (right).
06
1956–TODAY · THE POSTWAR APARTMENT HOUSE

The house behind the brick

The 1956 six-story reconstruction

A decade after the Bigelow estate sale, at the height of the mid-century apartment boom around Gramercy Park, 21 Gramercy Park South underwent a radical physical transformation in 1956. Builders stripped away the 1851 Italianate brownstone façade, arched window hoods, and bracketed cornice, added a full sixth story above the old roofline, reclad the street front in pale buff Roman brick with two wide bays of steel-casement windows per floor, and subdivided the interior into twenty-three compact apartments.

Memory and preservation in the Historic District

Ten years after that refacing, on September 20, 1966, the New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission designated the Gramercy Park Historic District (LP-0251), followed by listing on the National Register of Historic Places in 1980. Although the 1956 brick exterior speaks the spare utilitarian language of postwar Manhattan housing rather than the Victorian splendor of 1851, the structural party walls, twenty-six-foot footprint, and archival photographs of 21 Gramercy Park South preserve the memory of the brownstone study where John Bigelow gave New York City its great public library.

  • Grace BigelowArchivist of the Bigelow family papers, philanthropist, and Trustee of Gramercy Park elected in 1916 (1852–1932); lived at 21 Gramercy Park South from 1880 until her death in 1932
  • Jane Tunis Poultney BigelowSocial hostess and wife of diplomat John Bigelow (1829–1889); presided over the literary and diplomatic salon at 21 Gramercy Park South from 1880 until her death here in 1889
  • John BigelowCo-editor of the New York Evening Post, U.S. Minister to France under Abraham Lincoln, Tilden Trust executor, and founding president of the New York Public Library (1817–1911); lived at 21 Gramercy Park South from 1880 until his death here at ninety-four in December 1911
  • Benjamin J. CurtisNineteenth-century New York merchant at 15 Park Place; owned and resided at 21 Gramercy Park South with his family from 1860 to 1880
  • Yun GeeChinese-born modernist painter, poet, and founder of “Diamondism” (1906–1963); exhibited his paintings and performed a classical dance recital at the National Musical Benefit Society at 21 Gramercy Park South in January 1934
  • Henry TrowbridgeDry-goods merchant and head of Henry Trowbridge & Co. on Maiden Lane; built the four-story Italianate brownstone at 21 Gramercy Park South in 1851 and lived here until 1860
Building at a glance

The John Bigelow House · Built 1851 · Refronted 1956

The building record

Address
21 Gramercy Park South (Manhattan Block 875, Lot 62)
Historic names
The John Bigelow House (1880–1946) · earlier Henry Trowbridge House (1851–1860) & Benjamin J. Curtis House (1860–1880) Grace Bigelow, the Park’s first woman Trustee, became President of the Trustees in 1932.
Built
1851 (ground-level American-basement entrance added October 1893; raised to six stories and refaced in buff brick in 1956)
Original architecture
Four-story-and-basement Italianate brownstone (26-foot frontage); refaced in 1956 as a six-story mid-century brick apartment building
Architects
Original 1851 architect unknown · Francis Conlon (October 1893 entrance & interior alterations, with builders P. McCormack & Son)
Current form
Six-story residential apartment building (23 units)
Park access & landmark status
Deeded key privileges to Gramercy Park; within the 1966 NYC Gramercy Park Historic District (LP-0251) and 1980 National Register of Historic Places district

Over time

1851–1860

Henry Trowbridge builds the brownstone

Dry-goods merchant Henry Trowbridge erects a four-story Italianate brownstone over an English basement at 21 Gramercy Park South, selling the house in February 1860 to merchant Benjamin J. Curtis, whose family lives here until 1880.

1880–1889

John and Jane Poultney Bigelow’s salon

Former Evening Post editor and U.S. Minister to France John Bigelow and his wife Jane Tunis Poultney Bigelow acquire 21 Gramercy Park South, hosting figures including Oscar Wilde (1882) and Julia Ward Howe (1886).

Oct. 1893

Grace Bigelow removes the stoop

Following Jane Bigelow’s death in 1889, daughter Grace Bigelow commissions architect Francis Conlon for a $10,000 alteration that removes the high brownstone stoop, creates a street-level American-basement entrance, and converts the old second-floor doorway into a third parlor window.

May 23, 1895

Founding the New York Public Library

Acting as chief executor for his late Gramercy neighbor Samuel J. Tilden, John Bigelow orchestrates the merger of the Tilden Trust with the Astor and Lenox Libraries and is elected its founding president four days later.

May–Dec. 1911

Dedication of the Fifth Avenue Library and Bigelow’s death

At age ninety-three, Bigelow speaks beside President William Howard Taft at the May 23, 1911 dedication of the New York Public Library on Fifth Avenue; he dies at 21 Gramercy Park South on December 19, 1911, at ninety-four.

1916–1932

Grace Bigelow as Park Trustee and archivist

Elected a Trustee of Gramercy Park in 1916, Grace Bigelow donates her father’s papers to the New York Public Library between 1924 and her death in October 1932.

1934–1946

National Musical Benefit Society and Yun Gee

Leased by the Bigelow estate to the National Musical Benefit Society, the house hosts concerts and modernist painter Yun Gee’s January 1934 painting exhibition and dance recital before the family sells the property in May 1946.

1956 & 1966

Mid-century brick refacing and Historic District

A 1956 renovation strips the brownstone front, adds a sixth story, and reconfigures the building into twenty-three apartments behind a buff-brick façade; ten years later, the site is included within the 1966 Gramercy Park Historic District.

The life of an address

  1. 1851–1880 · The Trowbridge & Curtis house
  2. 1880 · The Bigelows arrive
  3. 1893 · Lowering the entrance & removing the stoop
  4. 1895 · A public library is formed
  5. 1911 · A lifetime closes
  6. 1934 · Painting meets performance
  7. 1956 · The brick façade appears
Sources cited
Photo credits for this page