Gramercy Park Block Association
Gramercy Stories

8 Gramercy Park South

A vanished church, a city’s conscience, and the family behind the garden gate.

The present apartment house at East 20th Street and Park Avenue South, on the former All Souls site.
8 Gramercy Park South (also known as 100–104 East 20th Street and 245–249 Park Avenue South), the six-story Art Moderne brick apartment house designed by architect Jacob M. Felson and completed in October 1938 on the former site of All Souls Unitarian Church and its rectory.

A church before the apartment house

Long before steel-framed corner windows and an awning marked 8 Gramercy Park South stood at the southeast corner of Park Avenue South and East 20th Street, one of nineteenth-century America’s most audacious landmarks rose on this ground: a Byzantine-and-Italian Romanesque church banded in alternating stripes of scarlet brick and cream-colored Caen stone beneath a towering patterned dome. Immediately alongside it at 104 East 20th Street stood an equally fantastical polychrome rectory—the home of Unitarian minister Henry Whitney Bellows, who helped organize and led the United States Sanitary Commission for the Union Army.

Though fire claimed the vacated church in August 1931 as the congregation prepared its new home uptown, the history of this corner bridges two centuries of Gramercy life—from Jacob Wrey Mould’s Victorian polychromy and architect Jacob M. Felson’s 1938 Art Moderne apartment house to the Flores family, whose thirty-four years caring for 8 Gramercy Park South introduced Head Gardener Amando Flores to the private park just down the block.

Explore the history

Behind the garden gate

1853–1855 · THE CHURCH OF THE HOLY ZEBRA

The church that startled New York

All Souls at Fourth Avenue and East 20th Street, with Mould’s striped walls, circular window, and dome.
All Souls Unitarian Church (“The Church of the Holy Zebra”) at the southeast corner of Fourth Avenue (now Park Avenue South) and East 20th Street, designed by architect Jacob Wrey Mould in alternating bands of red brick and pale Caen stone and dedicated on Christmas Day 1855 (The New York Public Library).

Henry Whitney Bellows, Moses H. Grinnell, and Jacob Wrey Mould

When the First Congregational Unitarian Church in the City of New York—founded in 1819 and numbering William Cullen Bryant, Peter Cooper, and Cyrus W. Field among its pews—outgrew its downtown sanctuaries in the early 1850s, it acquired the prominent corner lot at Fourth Avenue (now Park Avenue South) and East 20th Street, half a block west of Gramercy Park. Leading the congregation were two men of bold vision: its eloquent Harvard-educated minister, the Reverend Dr. Henry Whitney Bellows (1814–1882), and its building-committee chairman, clipper-ship merchant prince Moses Hicks Grinnell (1803–1877), partner in Grinnell, Minturn & Co. (owners of the record-breaking clipper Flying Cloud), and President of the New York Chamber of Commerce.

As the trustees weighed conventional Gothic and classical designs in 1852–1853, Grinnell championed a brilliant twenty-seven-year-old English architect who had just arrived in New York from London: Jacob Wrey Mould (1825–1886), a pupil of color theorist Owen Jones whose later work in Central Park included the carvings of Bethesda Terrace and collaboration on Belvedere Castle. Grinnell, as Bellows later recalled, was “bewitched by the architect,” and Mould rewarded his patron’s daring with a building unlike anything New York had ever seen.

Polychrome masonry and the unbuilt campanile donated to the Union

Dedicated on Christmas Day, December 25, 1855, as the Church of All Souls, Mould’s Greek-cross sanctuary drew inspiration from the medieval Lombard and Byzantine churches of northern Italy, particularly the Cathedral of Monza. Rejecting monochromatic brownstone, Mould built color directly into the walls—alternating horizontal bands of red Philadelphia pressed brick and pale imported French Caen limestone across the facades, around the deep Romanesque entrance arches, and framing a monumental wheel window on Fourth Avenue, all crowned by a towering drum and tiled dome. Stunned and delighted, New Yorkers christened the landmark “The Church of the Holy Zebra” (and, in a nod to roast beef with streaks of fat and lean, “The Beefsteak Church”).

Mould’s boundary-pushing craftsmanship came at a steep price: construction of the church and its adjoining rectory exceeded the original budget by roughly $48,000, a deficit Moses Grinnell generously helped cover from his own pocket. As a result, the soaring 200-foot Venetian campanile that Mould had designed to stand beside the entrance was postponed. Six years later, when the Civil War broke out in 1861, the congregation voted to donate the entire reserve fund accumulated for their bell tower to the United States Sanitary Commission—making the absent tower on East 20th Street a quiet monument to wartime sacrifice.

1855–1882 · THE RECTORY & THE SANITARY COMMISSION

A remarkable house, a national cause

104 East 20th Street—the Bellows family’s polychrome parsonage

Immediately east of the church on the Gramercy Park block, at 104 East 20th Street, Jacob Wrey Mould designed a narrow four-story rectory nearly as inventive as the sanctuary itself. Above a twin-arched ground floor and brownstone stoop, a grand two-story projecting stone bay window gathered paired colonnettes and circular oculi beneath a striped, round-arched hood, topped by a pierced stone parapet balcony and a steep, dormered gable next to the church’s dome.

For Henry Whitney Bellows, his wife Eliza Townsend Nevins Bellows (1817–1869), and their children, 104 East 20th Street was both a family home and a bustling civic salon. As writer Helen W. Henderson recorded in A Loiterer in New York (1917), the architect’s split-level rooms and labyrinthine staircases left very different impressions on mother and daughter: Bellows’s daughter Anna L. Bellows fondly remembered, “I thought the complicated and somewhat mysterious and inconvenient parsonage delightful—but my mother did not.”

The rectory at 104 East 20th Street, photographed for Old Buildings of New York City (1907). The church’s dome rises beside it.
The All Souls rectory and parish house at 104 East 20th Street—home to Rev. Dr. Henry Whitney Bellows—photographed for Old Buildings of New York City (1907), showing Jacob Wrey Mould’s polychrome masonry, Venetian-traceried parlor bay, and the patterned dome of All Souls rising at right.

Louisa Lee Schuyler and the birth of the U.S. Sanitary Commission (1861)

Through the parish circle centered on All Souls and its rectory, Henry Whitney Bellows and the women of the congregation helped launch the largest civilian relief organization of the American Civil War. In April 1861, days after the fall of Fort Sumter, Bellows joined twenty-three-year-old All Souls parishioner Louisa Lee Schuyler (1837–1926)—great-granddaughter of Alexander Hamilton and General Philip Schuyler—alongside Eliza Bellows and Sarah Bedell Cooper to organize the Woman’s Central Association of Relief (WCAR).

Traveling to Washington in May 1861, Bellows persuaded a reluctant War Department and President Abraham Lincoln—who signed the enabling order on June 13, 1861—to establish the United States Sanitary Commission, with Bellows serving as its national president throughout the war and Frederick Law Olmsted as general secretary. Mobilizing thousands of local aid societies from its New York nerve center under Schuyler’s leadership, the Sanitary Commission raised more than $25 million in money and supplies, staffed hospital ships and soldiers’ homes, and revolutionized battlefield medicine and camp hygiene. (A decade later, building directly on that wartime experience at All Souls, Louisa Lee Schuyler founded the New York State Charities Aid Association in 1872 and the pioneering Bellevue Hospital Training School for Nurses in 1873.)

On Friday evening, June 21, 1861, the newly authorized commissioners gathered inside Bellows’s rectory at 104 East 20th Street to organize their work. Henry Whitney Bellows served as president, his Gramercy Park North neighbor George Templeton Strong became national treasurer, and Frederick Law Olmsted took the post of general secretary. The congregation committed its entire reserve for Jacob Wrey Mould’s unbuilt 200-foot Venetian bell tower to the Commission’s relief work.

In January 1862, Bellows and Strong went together to the White House to ask Abraham Lincoln to hear the Commission’s recommendation before appointing a new Surgeon General. Lincoln agreed that “anybody shall be heered before anything’s done.” That April, Bellows gained access to the President while he was being shaved and pressed the case for Dr. William A. Hammond, who received the appointment.

The work soon took Bellows from the White House into the war zone. In May 1862, during the Peninsula Campaign, he served as chief pastor aboard the surgical hospital steamer Knickerbocker. Ellen Ruggles Strong, the treasurer’s wife, volunteered aboard the same vessel as a nurse.

Henry Whitney Bellows, minister of All Souls and president of the United States Sanitary Commission.
The Reverend Dr. Henry Whitney Bellows (1814–1882), minister of All Souls for forty-three years and founding president of the United States Sanitary Commission during the Civil War (Library of Congress).
1870S–1910S · ENGINEERING, EDUCATION & CHARITY

A house put to work

The American Society of Civil Engineers and the Gramercy Park Tool-House

By the late 1870s, as the Bellows family shifted their domestic quarters and Henry Whitney Bellows approached the end of his forty-three-year ministry in January 1882, the former rectory at 104 East 20th Street took on an extraordinary life as an incubator for engineering, progressive education, and urban charity.

From May 1877 until April 1881—as documented by the Landmarks Preservation Commission—104 East 20th Street served as the national headquarters and library of the American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE), founded in 1852 as America’s oldest national engineering society. Its members met in Mould’s rooms to discuss the engineering of a rapidly expanding country. In the early 1880s, the building housed the innovative Gramercy Park School and Tool-House, championed by nineteenth-century reformer Courtlandt Palmer in his 1884 book The New Education as a model academy where boys and girls combined classical studies with hands-on laboratory science, woodworking, and metalcraft.

The New York Flower Mission carries spring into the hospital wards

The All Souls Parish House at 104 East 20th Street also served for decades as the headquarters of one of Manhattan’s most beloved volunteer charities: the New York Flower Mission, established in 1870. Every Monday and Thursday morning from May through October, suburban railroads and Long Island Sound steamboats delivered hundreds of baskets of lilacs, roses, carnations, and ferns free of charge to 104 East 20th Street. Inside the parish house, women volunteers tied the blossoms into thousands of individual nosegays and carried them by hand to the bedside of sick and impoverished patients in Bellevue, Charity, and Gouverneur Hospitals and tenement sickrooms across the city.

When author Helen W. Henderson visited 104 East 20th Street during the First World War, she found the exterior Caen stone of the sixty-year-old church weathered by city coal smoke, yet the parish house next door remained a beehive of weekday philanthropy—its custodian guiding visitors through the interior passage into Mould’s domed sanctuary.

The New York Flower Mission visiting a hospital ward. This 1877 illustration depicts the mission’s work, not the interior of the Gramercy rectory.
Volunteers of the New York Flower Mission—which operated from its headquarters at the All Souls Parish House, 104 East 20th Street—distributing fresh cut flowers to patients in a hospital women’s ward (Frank Leslie’s Illustrated Newspaper, May 5, 1877).
1929–1932 · MOVING UPTOWN & THE 1931 FIRE

The end of the striped church

The 1929 sale, the Wall Street crash, and the Baker family’s rescue

By the late 1920s, the once-residential blocks of Fourth Avenue around 20th Street had been overtaken by towering commercial lofts and silk houses, while the majority of All Souls’ parishioners now lived on the Upper East Side. Under the leadership of the Reverend Dr. Minot Simons, the congregation agreed to sell its historic Gramercy corner for $475,000 in 1929 and purchased a new site at Lexington Avenue and East 80th Street.

Just as the move was underway, the October 1929 Wall Street crash struck a double blow: the real-estate developer who had contracted to buy the Fourth Avenue church was wiped out financially and defaulted, while donors to the uptown building fund saw their fortunes evaporate—leaving All Souls trapped with two properties and two heavy mortgages. Stepping forward at the height of the crisis, longtime church trustee and First National Bank chairman George Fisher Baker (1840–1931) and his son George F. Baker Jr. contributed critical rescue financing that enabled the congregation to complete and dedicate its new Georgian Revival sanctuary at 80th Street in November 1932.

The three-alarm fire of August 23, 1931

One important memorial had already been brought to safety. Augustus Saint-Gaudens’s life-size bronze bas-relief of Henry Whitney Bellows, set in an architectural frame designed by Stanford White, had been dedicated inside All Souls on June 11, 1886. Rescued before the old church burned, it preserved the minister’s likeness and the congregation’s tribute through the move uptown.

Down at Fourth Avenue and East 20th Street, Jacob Wrey Mould’s vacated 1855 church did not wait for the wreckers’ ball. On Sunday afternoon, August 23, 1931, a fast-moving three-alarm fire broke out inside the shuttered building, sending flames through the dome and drawing thousands of spectators toward the edge of Gramercy Park. The fire gutted the interior and roof, and the ruins of both the Church of the Holy Zebra and the rectory at 104 East 20th Street were subsequently razed—leaving the L-shaped corner lot vacant during the depths of the Great Depression until residential construction returned in 1938.

1938–TODAY · ART MODERNE APARTMENTS

A quieter kind of architecture

Samuel Barkin & Son and architect Jacob M. Felson (1938)

On Friday, October 14, 1938, the real-estate pages of the New York Sun announced the rebirth of the historic corner under the headline “In the Gramercy Park Section,” publishing a photograph of the newly completed six-story elevator apartment house at 8 Gramercy Park South. Erected by veteran builders Samuel Barkin & Son to designs by prolific New York apartment architect Jacob M. Felson (1889–1944), the building spanned the combined footprint of the old church and rectory (carrying the alternate municipal addresses 100–104 East 20th Street and 245–249 Park Avenue South) and opened with fifty-nine modern one-and-a-half- to four-room apartments.

Where Mould’s 1855 church had startled Victorian Manhattan with theatrical stripes and a dome, Felson’s 1938 design embraced the clean, horizontal lines of late-1930s Art Moderne residential architecture. Clad in warm red-brown tapestry brick with a flat parapet roofline and ground-floor storefronts along the avenue, the building placed its canopied residential entrance on quieter East 20th Street looking east toward the trees of Gramercy Park.

New York Sun clipping dated October 14, 1938, showing the newly completed apartment house at 8 Gramercy Park South and naming its builders and architect.
Completion photograph and announcement of 8 Gramercy Park South in the New York Sun on Friday, October 14, 1938 (“In the Gramercy Park Section”), crediting builders Samuel Barkin & Son and architect J. M. Felson.

Corner casements at the gateway to the square

The signature architectural gesture of Felson’s façade is its vertical stacks of steel-framed corner casement windows, which wrap continuously around the building’s ninety-degree angles—dissolving the masonry corner so light and views toward East 20th Street and Gramercy Park pour into the corner living rooms. Although the western boundary of the 1966 Gramercy Park Historic District stops just east of the lot line on East 20th Street, 8 Gramercy Park South has served for nearly ninety years as the residential gateway between bustling Park Avenue South and the quiet enclave of the square.

1990S–TODAY · STEWARDS OF BUILDING & GARDEN

From the building to the garden

Superintendent Alberto Flores’s thirty-four years at No. 8

In our own time, 8 Gramercy Park South became part of a lasting family connection to Gramercy Park through its longtime building superintendent, Alberto Flores. For thirty-four years, Alberto cared for the mechanical systems, halls, and households of No. 8. As a young man, his son Amando Flores began working alongside his father in the building—coming to know the neighbors along East 20th Street and the locked two-acre garden just steps down the block.

As Amando recounted in a 2016 Gramercy Park Block Association profile, his father’s work at No. 8 opened the gate to the Park itself. In the early 1990s, Amando began filling in for the Park attendant during vacations and assisting with grounds maintenance; the Trustees of Gramercy Park appointed him Gardener of Gramercy Park in the mid-1990s.

Alberto Flores, left, with his son Amando. Alberto’s thirty-four years as superintendent at No. 8 helped connect his son with Gramercy Park.
Alberto Flores (left), building superintendent at 8 Gramercy Park South for thirty-four years, with his son Amando Flores, whose early work helping his father at No. 8 led to his career as Head Gardener of Gramercy Park.

Amando Flores—from Puebla’s roses to Head Gardener of Gramercy Park

Born in Puebla, Mexico, where he had first learned to cultivate and prune roses at the age of fifteen, Amando brought that early experience to Samuel B. Ruggles’s 1831 square, deepening his craft through formal horticultural studies supported by the Trustees. Over more than three decades as Head Gardener, Amando has cared for the trees, lawns, paths, bulb beds, and flowering shrubs inside the fence—turning a neighborhood connection that began in his father’s workshop at 8 Gramercy Park South into his life’s work.

Amando Flores in Gramercy Park, where a connection made through his father’s work at No. 8 became a life’s work.
Amando Flores inside Gramercy Park, where a neighborhood bond forged through his father’s decades of service at 8 Gramercy Park South blossomed into a lifelong stewardship of the garden.
  • Rev. Dr. Henry Whitney BellowsMinister of All Souls Unitarian Church for forty-three years (1839–1882), co-founder of The Century Association and The Union League Club, and founding president of the United States Sanitary Commission during the Civil War (1814–1882); lived in the All Souls rectory at 104 East 20th Street on this site
  • Alberto FloresBuilding superintendent at 8 Gramercy Park South for thirty-four years, whose decades of devoted service on East 20th Street introduced his son Amando Flores to Gramercy Park
  • Amando FloresHead Gardener of Gramercy Park since the mid-1990s; began working alongside his father Alberto at 8 Gramercy Park South before being hired by the Trustees of Gramercy Park to steward the two-acre private garden
  • Moses Hicks GrinnellClipper-ship merchant (partner in Grinnell, Minturn & Co.), U.S. Congressman, and President of the New York Chamber of Commerce (1803–1877); chaired the All Souls building committee and championed architect Jacob Wrey Mould for the 1855 church and rectory on this site
  • Jacob Wrey MouldLondon-born architect of the 1855 All Souls Church (“Church of the Holy Zebra”) and its rectory at 104 East 20th Street (1825–1886); his Central Park work included the Bethesda Terrace carvings and Belvedere Castle
  • Louisa Lee SchuylerGreat-granddaughter of Alexander Hamilton, All Souls leader who co-organized the Woman’s Central Association of Relief for the U.S. Sanitary Commission in 1861, and founder of the State Charities Aid Association and the Bellevue Hospital Training School for Nurses (1837–1926)
Building at a glance

8 Gramercy Park South (100–104 East 20th Street) · All Souls Site (1855) · Apartment House (1938)

The building record

Address
8 Gramercy Park South (also 100–104 East 20th Street and 245–249 Park Avenue South; Manhattan Block 875, Lot 79)
Present building
Completed October 1938 (six stories, built with 59 apartments; 55 residential units today with ground-floor avenue retail)
Present architect & builder
Jacob M. Felson (1889–1944), architect; Samuel Barkin & Son, builders
Present architecture
Late-1930s Art Moderne red-brown brick elevator apartment house featuring wraparound steel corner casement windows
Earlier landmark on site (1855–1931)
All Souls Unitarian Church (“The Church of the Holy Zebra,” dedicated December 25, 1855) and the All Souls Rectory & Parish House at 104 East 20th Street, designed by architect Jacob Wrey Mould (1825–1886)
Earlier historical associations
Rev. Dr. Henry Whitney Bellows & the U.S. Sanitary Commission · Louisa Lee Schuyler · Moses H. Grinnell · New York Flower Mission · American Society of Civil Engineers (1877–1881) · Gramercy Park School and Tool-House (described by Courtlandt Palmer in 1884)
Neighborhood & Park connection
Gateway to Gramercy Park South at Park Avenue South; workplace for 34 years of superintendent Alberto Flores, father of Gramercy Park Head Gardener Amando Flores

Over time

Dec. 25, 1855

Jacob Wrey Mould’s “Church of the Holy Zebra” is dedicated

Championed by merchant Moses H. Grinnell and minister Rev. Dr. Henry Whitney Bellows, English architect Jacob Wrey Mould’s polychrome red-brick-and-Caen-stone Church of All Souls and its adjoining rectory at 104 East 20th Street open at Fourth Avenue and East 20th Street.

April–June 1861

Birth of the United States Sanitary Commission

From the All Souls rectory and parish circle, Rev. Henry Whitney Bellows, Louisa Lee Schuyler, Eliza Bellows, and Sarah Bedell Cooper organize the Woman’s Central Association of Relief and persuade President Abraham Lincoln to establish the U.S. Sanitary Commission, with All Souls donating its bell-tower fund to Union relief.

1870–1884

Flower Mission, Civil Engineers, and the Gramercy Tool-House

The rectory and parish house at 104 East 20th Street serve the New York Flower Mission, founded in 1870, the American Society of Civil Engineers (1877–1881), and the Gramercy Park School and Tool-House, described by Courtlandt Palmer in his 1884 book The New Education.

1929–1931

All Souls plans its move uptown; fire destroys the 1855 church

Following the 1929 agreement to sell the site and rescue financing from the George F. Baker family after the Wall Street crash, the congregation builds its new church at Lexington Avenue and East 80th Street; on August 23, 1931, a three-alarm fire destroys the vacated 1855 church on Fourth Avenue.

Oct. 14, 1938

The completion of 8 Gramercy Park South is reported

The New York Sun announces the completion of the six-story brick apartment house with wraparound corner windows on the former church and rectory site, crediting builders Samuel Barkin & Son and architect Jacob M. Felson.

1990s–Today

Alberto and Amando Flores

Superintendent Alberto Flores’s thirty-four years of service at 8 Gramercy Park South introduce his son Amando Flores to the neighborhood, leading to Amando’s appointment in the mid-1990s as Head Gardener of Gramercy Park.

One corner, many lives

  1. Dec. 1855Jacob Wrey Mould’s All Souls Church opens
  2. June 1861Rev. Henry W. Bellows & the Sanitary Commission
  3. 1877–1884Civil Engineers, Flower Mission & Tool-House
  4. 1929All Souls agrees to sell the site and move uptown
  5. Aug. 23, 1931Fire destroys the vacated 1855 church
  6. Oct. 1938J. M. Felson’s apartment house is completed
  7. 1990s–todayAlberto & Amando Flores: from No. 8 to the Park
Sources cited
Photo credits for this page