9 Gramercy Park South
The railroad heir’s house.
The editor’s address.

A doorway and its stories
The grand parlor-floor doorway at 9 Gramercy Park South no longer opens to the street. High above the sidewalk, framed by fluted Greek Revival pilasters and leaf-carved Corinthian capitals, a multi-pane casement window now fills the threshold where nineteenth-century callers once stepped inside Gouverneur Morris Jr.’s townhouse, while a recessed doorway directly below admits residents from the pavement. Few Manhattan façades tell a century of architectural adaptation so clearly—or conceal so many unexpected chapters behind the stone.
Built in 1847–1848 as the town residence of railroad pioneer Gouverneur Morris II—only son of Founding Father Gouverneur Morris of Morrisania—and his wife, Martha (“Patsey”) Jefferson Cary Morris, the brownstone remained in the Morris family for more than seventy years, witnessing a dramatic 1882 ladder rescue of General Lloyd Aspinwall’s family and the literary salons of Mary Fairfax Morris Davenport. Remodeled into studio apartments in 1919–1920 by architect William H. Gompert, No. 9 became the New York home of Richard Johns and the editorial headquarters of his modernist quarterly Pagany from late 1930 to 1933.
From a family house to a literary address
The doorway that remembers

Corinthian pilasters around a parlor window
The most revealing architectural detail at 9 Gramercy Park South (also numbered 106 East 20th Street) is a second-story window dressed in the full ceremonial regalia of a front door. At the right (western) bay of the brownstone façade, a pair of deeply fluted pilasters rises to support richly carved Corinthian capitals and a classical entablature with a dentiled cornice. When the house was completed in 1847–1848, a high brownstone stoop ascended from the East 20th Street sidewalk directly to this doorway. Today, the steps are gone and a window occupies the frame, yet the 1847 Greek Revival threshold still commands the elevation.
When the New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission designated the Gramercy Park Historic District in September 1966, its architectural historians singled out No. 9’s fluted pilasters and Corinthian capitals while praising the house as “sympathetically remodeled”—recognizing that the dialogue between the 1847 townhouse and its early twentieth-century studio conversion had created a distinctive urban composition.
Reading a four-story brownstone built for the square
Constructed on a lot measuring 26 feet 8 inches wide by 92 feet deep, the four-story-and-basement residence was organized around the vertical hierarchy of an antebellum Manhattan family house. Above the service basement, the raised parlor floor and second-story drawing rooms looked north toward the western corner of Gramercy Park, while two upper stories of evenly spaced rectangular sash windows rose to a bold dentiled roof cornice.
In the space of a few feet, the lower façade records how a house built for a single patrician household adapted to twentieth-century apartment life: the classical door frame above, the recessed English-basement entrance below, and, beside them, a two-story polygonal dark metal bay window that projects outward to flood the former parlor and second-floor rooms with daylight.
A famous name, a different life
Gouverneur Morris II—son of the Founding Father, builder of railroads
The Gouverneur Morris who built 9 Gramercy Park South in 1847–1848 was Gouverneur Morris Jr., also known as Gouverneur Morris II (1813–1888). Born at the ancestral 2,000-acre manor of Morrisania in the Bronx on February 9, 1813, he was the only son of Founding Father Gouverneur Morris (1752–1816)—Continental Congressman, U.S. Minister to France during the French Revolution, U.S. Senator, and the draftsman who penned the Preamble to the United States Constitution—and his wife, Anne Cary Randolph Morris (1774–1837), a descendant of Pocahontas and the Randolphs of Virginia. Only three years old when his father died in 1816, the younger Morris grew up at Morrisania, where in 1840–1841 he erected and endowed St. Ann’s Episcopal Church as a family mausoleum in memory of his mother.
While his father’s fame belonged to the birth of the Republic, Gouverneur Morris II’s career belonged to the age of steam and iron rails. Captured as a young man with gold-rimmed spectacles and tousled auburn hair in an ivory watercolor miniature painted by National Academy co-founder Thomas Seir Cummings (now in the Walters Art Museum), Morris became one of mid-nineteenth-century America’s most energetic railway executives—serving as Vice President of the New York and Harlem Railroad, President of the Vermont Valley Railroad, one of the original corporators of the Illinois Central and Union Pacific railroads, and President of the Saratoga racecourse association.
Patsey Jefferson Cary and town-and-country life on Gramercy Park
In 1842, Gouverneur Morris II married his Virginia cousin, Martha (“Patsey”) Jefferson Cary (1820–1873), a great-niece of President Thomas Jefferson. Built in 1847–1848, 9 Gramercy Park South served as the family’s Manhattan winter residence while they maintained Old Morrisania in the Bronx. After Patsey’s death in 1873 and Morrisania’s annexation to New York City in 1874, Morris moved his country residence to Pelham, at Bartow-on-the-Sound.
Because Morris’s railroad enterprises and country estates kept the family moving between Manhattan, Westchester, and New England, 9 Gramercy Park South functioned both as a family home and, during seasons when the Morrises were in the country, as a leased town residence for fellow families of New York society. When Gouverneur Morris II died at Bartow-on-the-Sound in August 1888 at age seventy-five, ownership of 9 Gramercy Park South passed to his children, led by daughter Mary Fairfax Morris Davenport.
The Morris household shared this stretch of the square with a very different establishment next door: Miss Haines’s school at No. 10. Among its teachers was Henriette Deluzy-Desportes, whose life after the notorious Praslin affair in Paris would inspire Rachel Field’s 1938 novel All This, and Heaven Too. Garmey recalls a precise daily routine in 1851: thirteen girls, led by their French teacher, making six circuits of Gramercy Park each morning.

A ladder at the window
December 22, 1882—the rescue of General Lloyd Aspinwall’s family
On the morning of Friday, December 22, 1882, while 9 Gramercy Park South was leased by the Morrises to General Lloyd Aspinwall (1830–1886) and his wife, Harriet Prescott Aspinwall, the townhouse became the scene of a dramatic front-page rescue. The son of Pacific Mail Steamship and Panama Railroad founder William Henry Aspinwall, General Aspinwall had commanded the 22nd Regiment of the New York National Guard during the Civil War, served as aide-de-camp to General Ambrose Burnside at the Battle of Fredericksburg, and was a prominent Gramercy clubman and yachtsman.
Shortly after breakfast on December 22, an overheated furnace flue in the basement ignited the dumbwaiter shaft and main staircase—sending dense clouds of smoke and flame surging to the top of the four-story house and trapping Mrs. Aspinwall, their children Lloyd Aspinwall Jr. and Nina Aspinwall, and five household maids on the upper floors while General Aspinwall was downtown. Responding to the alarm within minutes, firemen of Engine Company No. 14 and Hook and Ladder Company No. 3 raised scaling ladders to the third- and fourth-story windows along East 20th Street, carrying the children, Mrs. Aspinwall, and the servants safely down through the smoke to the street. Fire and water caused $18,000 in damage to the house and its furnishings.
Mary Fairfax Morris Davenport, Browning readings, and Revolutionary diaries
Repaired and restored with its original mahogany doors and colonial woodwork intact, 9 Gramercy Park South returned in the late 1880s and 1890s to the occupancy of Gouverneur Morris II’s daughter, Mary Fairfax Morris Davenport (1849–1919), her husband, U.S. Naval Academy graduate Lieutenant Commander (later Commodore) Richard Graham Davenport, and their two daughters, Beatrix Cary Davenport and Hetty Gouverneur Davenport.
Inside the drawing rooms where fire hoses had once played, Mrs. Davenport presided over an active literary and social calendar. In March 1888, she hosted afternoon dramatic readings of the poetry of Robert Browning performed by celebrated stage actress and elocutionist Sarah Cowell Le Moyne (1859–1915)—who had read personally for Browning in London and whose husband, actor William J. Le Moyne, would become a charter member of Edwin Booth’s club The Players, founded that December farther east at No. 16. Six years later, in December 1894, the parlors of No. 9 were illuminated for the formal society debut dinner introducing daughters Beatrix Cary and Hetty Gouverneur Davenport to New York society. (By 1898, the Davenports had moved to London and were leasing the house. Beatrix Cary Davenport later edited and published her great-grandfather’s two-volume A Diary of the French Revolution by Gouverneur Morris in 1939.)
Mahogany doors, a new beginning
The March 1919 sale after seventy-one years in the Morris family
On March 22, 1919, a paragraph in the Real Estate Record and Builders’ Guide marked the end of the seventy-one-year Morris era at 9 Gramercy Park South. Acting for attorney Charles S. McVeigh as trustee for Mary Fairfax Morris Davenport and the heirs of Gouverneur Morris II, Washington Square real-estate brokers Pepe & Bro. sold the four-story brownstone dwelling—on its lot measuring 26 feet 8 inches by 92 feet immediately adjoining All Souls Unitarian Church at 8 Gramercy Park South—to Captain George W. Bond.
Even in the spare prose of a real-estate trade journal, the interior craftsmanship of the 1847–1848 townhouse commanded respect: “This is the former residence of Gouverneur Morris, and now owned by his daughter, Mrs. Davenport, and others,” the Record and Guide noted. “The old house still contains the original mahogany doors, panels and is a very good type of the old Colonial interior. The purchaser is Capt. G. W. Bond, who will probably remodel.”

Architect William H. Gompert’s 1919–1920 remodeling
Within months of the sale, the property was transferred to investor John P. Peel, who commissioned prominent New York architect William H. Gompert (1875–1946)—President of the Brooklyn Chapter of the American Institute of Architects and soon-to-be Superintendent of School Buildings for the City of New York—to remodel the mansion into non-housekeeping bachelor and studio suites (followed in 1927 by a further alteration adding kitchenettes for eight apartments).
It was Gompert’s 1919–1920 transformation that gave 9 Gramercy Park South the striking street elevation it wears today: removing the 1847 high brownstone stoop, framing a new street-level entrance in the rusticated English basement, turning the Corinthian-pilastered parlor doorway into a multi-pane casement window, and projecting the two-story polygonal dark metal bay window across the parlor and second floors to create sunlit front studios looking toward the Park.
A little magazine with a large address book
Richard Johns brings Pagany: A Native Quarterly to No. 9 (1930)
A decade after the house was divided into studio apartments, one of the most influential “little magazines” of American literary modernism set up its editorial desk inside 9 Gramercy Park South. In late 1930, twenty-six-year-old editor, writer, and photographer Richard Johns (1904–1970)—the literary pseudonym of Boston-born Richard Janney—relocated his residence and the editorial offices of his quarterly review, Pagany: A Native Quarterly, from Beacon Hill in Boston into an apartment at 9 Gramercy Park South.
Launched in January 1930 with the encouragement and close collaboration of poet-physician William Carlos Williams—who gave the magazine its title from his 1928 novel A Voyage to Pagany and serialized his groundbreaking novel White Mule across its issues—Pagany was dedicated to publishing experimental American and transatlantic writing during the early years of the Great Depression. Priced at fifty cents a copy or two dollars a year, its full-page Winter 1931 advertisement in Experimental Cinema proudly bore the imprint at the bottom of the page: “Edited by RICHARD JOHNS · 9 GRAMERCY PARK · NEW YORK CITY.”
Williams, Pound, Stein, and the Objectivist circle
During the years Johns edited the journal from his rooms at 9 Gramercy Park South (documented in the Richard Johns–Pagany Papers at the University of Delaware Library), he corresponded with a wide circle of twentieth-century writers. Shortly after Johns completed his move to No. 9 in December 1930, poet Louis Zukofsky visited the Gramercy Park apartment to discuss the emerging “Objectivist” poetics.
Across its twelve quarterly issues between January 1930 and February 1933—when financial pressures following the 1932 death of Johns’s father brought the journal’s three-year run to a close—Pagany published landmark poems, stories, essays, and photographs by William Carlos Williams, Ezra Pound, Gertrude Stein, Louis Zukofsky, Kenneth Rexroth, Erskine Caldwell, John Dos Passos, E. E. Cummings, H.D. (Hilda Doolittle), Mina Loy, Mary Butts, Djuna Barnes, Robert McAlmon, Horace Gregory, Edward Dahlberg, and French photographer Eugène Atget. Behind a quiet 1847 brownstone front built for a Founding Father’s son, American literary modernism found a home on Gramercy Park.

What the street still tells us
Recognized with its changes in the 1966 Historic District
On September 20, 1966, the New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission designated the Gramercy Park Historic District (LP-0251, followed by listing on the National Register of Historic Places in 1980), placing the western boundary of the district on the south side of East 20th Street directly along the lot line between 9 Gramercy Park South and 8 Gramercy Park South. In its designation report, the Commission specifically praised No. 9 as a “sympathetically remodeled” 1847–1848 townhouse, highlighting how its original Greek Revival doorway pilasters and its early twentieth-century studio alterations worked together to enrich the streetscape.
Reading a century and three-quarters from the sidewalk
Maintained today as a ten-unit residential building with a planted iron-fenced forecourt, 9 Gramercy Park South invites any neighbor walking along East 20th Street to read its layered biography in three architectural details: the fluted Corinthian pilasters of the 1847 upstairs doorway that recall Gouverneur Morris II and Mary Fairfax Davenport’s drawing rooms; the third- and fourth-story sash windows from which General Lloyd Aspinwall’s children were carried down fire ladders in December 1882; and the 1919–1920 metal studio bay and ground-level entrance of the building where Richard Johns edited Pagany.
Residents of Note
The People of Gramercy- General Lloyd AspinwallCivil War commander of the 22nd New York Regiment, aide-de-camp to General Ambrose Burnside, and son of steamship pioneer William H. Aspinwall (1830–1886); leased 9 Gramercy Park South with his family at the time of the dramatic December 22, 1882 ladder rescue
- Beatrix Cary DavenportHistorian, granddaughter of Gouverneur Morris II, and editor of A Diary of the French Revolution by Gouverneur Morris (1874–1960); grew up at 9 Gramercy Park South and made her society debut here in December 1894
- Mary Fairfax Morris DavenportSociety hostess and daughter of Gouverneur Morris II (1849–1919); presided over Browning readings and family receptions at 9 Gramercy Park South and co-owned the house until its March 1919 sale
- Richard Johns (Richard Janney)Modernist editor, writer, and photographer (1904–1970); lived at 9 Gramercy Park South and edited the influential literary quarterly Pagany: A Native Quarterly from his apartment here from late 1930 to 1933
- Sarah Cowell Le MoyneCelebrated stage actress and dramatic reader of Robert Browning (1859–1915); performed Browning readings in the parlor of 9 Gramercy Park South in March 1888
- Gouverneur Morris II (Gouverneur Morris Jr.)Railroad executive (Vice President of the New York and Harlem Railroad, President of the Vermont Valley Railroad) and only son of Founding Father Gouverneur Morris (1813–1888); built 9 Gramercy Park South in 1847–1848 as his Manhattan residence
Building at a glance
Built 1847–1848 · Greek Revival
The building record
- Address
- 9 Gramercy Park South (also 106 East 20th Street; Manhattan Block 875, Lot 77) Original Gramercy Park deed lot: Lot 9.
- Historic names
- The Gouverneur Morris Jr. (Gouverneur Morris II) House
- Built
- 1847–1848 (for railroad executive Gouverneur Morris II and Martha “Patsey” Jefferson Cary Morris)
- Original architect
- Unknown
- 1919–1920 studio remodeling
- Architect William H. Gompert (1875–1946), following the March 1919 sale by the Morris heirs
- Architecture
- Four-story-and-basement Greek Revival brownstone townhouse (26 ft. 8 in. × 92 ft. lot) retaining its 1847 fluted Corinthian parlor doorway pilasters alongside a 1919–1920 two-story polygonal cast-metal studio bay and street-level entrance
- Present use
- Ten-unit residential apartment building
- Historical associations
- Gouverneur Morris II & Patsey Jefferson Cary Morris · General Lloyd Aspinwall (1882 fire rescue) · Mary Fairfax Morris Davenport & Beatrix Cary Davenport · Richard Johns & Pagany: A Native Quarterly (1930–1933)
- Landmark status
- Westernmost building on the south side within the 1966 NYC Gramercy Park Historic District (LP-0251); also within the 1980 National Register of Historic Places district
Over time
Gouverneur Morris II builds the townhouse
Railroad executive Gouverneur Morris II (1813–1888)—only son of Founding Father Gouverneur Morris of Morrisania—and his wife Patsey Jefferson Cary Morris build a four-story-and-basement Greek Revival brownstone at 9 Gramercy Park South.
The Aspinwall fire and ladder rescue
While the house is leased to Civil War General Lloyd Aspinwall, a morning furnace fire traps Mrs. Aspinwall, two children, and five servants on the upper floors; firefighters of Engine Co. 14 and Hook & Ladder Co. 3 rescue the entire household by scaling ladders from the third- and fourth-story windows.
Mary Fairfax Morris Davenport’s salon
Gouverneur Morris II’s daughter Mary Fairfax Morris Davenport and her husband Richard Graham Davenport occupy No. 9, hosting Robert Browning readings by actress Sarah Cowell Le Moyne in March 1888 and the society debut dinner of daughters Beatrix Cary and Hetty Gouverneur Davenport in December 1894.
Sale after seventy-one years and William H. Gompert’s remodeling
Trustee Charles S. McVeigh sells No. 9 on behalf of the Morris heirs in March 1919; architect William H. Gompert remodels the mansion into studio apartments in 1919–1920, removing the high stoop, converting the Corinthian-pilastered doorway into a window, and adding the two-story polygonal metal bay.
Richard Johns edits Pagany at No. 9
Editor Richard Johns (Richard Janney) moves his residence and the editorial offices of the modernist literary quarterly Pagany: A Native Quarterly from Boston to 9 Gramercy Park South, publishing William Carlos Williams, Ezra Pound, Gertrude Stein, and Louis Zukofsky.
Gramercy Park Historic District
The New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission designates the Gramercy Park Historic District, praising 9 Gramercy Park South’s Greek Revival Corinthian pilasters and sympathetic studio remodeling.
Seven moments at No. 9
- 1847–1848Gouverneur Morris Jr.’s brownstone rises
- Dec. 22, 1882General Lloyd Aspinwall’s family rescued by ladder
- 1888–1894Mary Fairfax Davenport’s Browning readings & debuts
- March 1919The Morris heirs sell after seventy-one years
- 1919–1920Architect William H. Gompert’s studio remodeling
- 1930–1933Richard Johns edits Pagany at No. 9
- Sept. 1966Gramercy Park Historic District designation
Sources cited
- New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission. Gramercy Park Historic District Designation Report (LP-0251, September 20, 1966). Building description for 9 Gramercy Park South (106 East 20th Street), 1847–1848 construction date, Corinthian doorway pilasters, and sympathetic remodeling.
- New York Genealogical and Biographical Record, Vol. XIX, No. 4 (October 1888), pages 177–179 (“Obituary: Gouverneur Morris”), and Blake A. Bell, Historic Pelham (August 14, 2014) — Documenting Gouverneur Morris II’s life at Morrisania, railroad career, and family history.
- The Walters Art Museum, Baltimore. Thomas Seir Cummings, Gouverneur Morris II (1813–1888), watercolor on ivory miniature (c. 1840–1860, Accession No. 38.492).
- The New York Times, December 23, 1882 — Reporting the morning fire of December 22, 1882, at the residence of General Lloyd Aspinwall, 9 Gramercy Park, and the ladder rescue of Mrs. Aspinwall, her children, and servants from the upper windows.
- Tom Miller, “The 1847 Gouverneur Morris, Jr. House — 9 Gramercy Park,” Daytonian in Manhattan, February 12, 2020 — Documenting the Aspinwall fire, Mary Fairfax Morris Davenport’s Browning readings and 1894 debut dinner, and the 1919–1920 studio-apartment remodeling by architect William H. Gompert.
- Real Estate Record and Builders’ Guide, March 22, 1919, page 368 (“Gramercy Park”); Avery Architectural & Fine Arts Library, Columbia University — Contemporary sale notice recording Pepe & Bro.’s sale of 9 Gramercy Park for trustee Charles S. McVeigh and Mrs. Davenport to Captain G. W. Bond, noting the surviving original mahogany doors and colonial woodwork.
- University of Delaware Library, Special Collections. Richard Johns–Pagany Collection (MSS 0110, 1925–1970, bulk 1929–1933), and Stephen Halpert with Richard Johns, A Return to Pagany: The History, Correspondence, and Selections from a Little Magazine, 1929–1932 (Boston: Beacon Press, 1969).
- Steel Wagstaff, “Richard Johns and Pagany,” The Objectivists (University of Wisconsin–Madison), “The Work” and “The Lives” — Documenting Johns’s late-1930 move to 9 Gramercy Park South, Louis Zukofsky’s visit, and the serialization of William Carlos Williams’s White Mule.
- Pagany: A Native Quarterly, Winter 1931 advertisement in Experimental Cinema (No. 3, 1931), listing editor Richard Johns at 9 Gramercy Park, New York City.
- Rachel Field, All This, and Heaven Too (1938). A novel inspired by Henriette Deluzy-Desportes Field’s life; a literary treatment of the Praslin affair and her later American life.
- Stephen Garmey, Gramercy Park (1984), pp. 82–83, 97–98, 170–171, 173. Miss Haines’s school, Henriette Desportes, the Barlow household, and Robert Henri’s studio.
Photo credits for this page
- Exterior and entrance views of 9 Gramercy Park South: Photographs by Tom Miller (2020), Daytonian in Manhattan.
- Portrait miniature of Gouverneur Morris II (c. 1840–1860, watercolor on ivory by Thomas Seir Cummings): The Walters Art Museum, Baltimore (38.492; Gift of the A. Jay Fink Foundation, Inc., in memory of Abraham Jay Fink, 1963).
- Sale notice for 9 Gramercy Park (March 22, 1919): Real Estate Record and Builders’ Guide, page 368; Avery Architectural & Fine Arts Library, Columbia University.
- Advertisement for the Winter 1931 issue of Pagany: A Native Quarterly (9 Gramercy Park, New York City): Published in Experimental Cinema (1931); digitized via Internet Archive.