Gramercy Park Block Association

Monuments of Gramercy Park

The Ruggles Fountain

A grandson’s gift. A founder remembered. A fountain flowing again.

The restored Ruggles Fountain with water flowing into its open basin, surrounded by shrubs and trees in Gramercy Park.
The restored Samuel B. Ruggles Memorial Fountain and its open semicircular basin inside the western gate of Gramercy Park in summer 2026.

Water returns to the western gate

For years, the memorial fountain inside the western gate of Gramercy Park held more shrubbery than water. Over the decades, its semicircular stone basin had been planted over as a flowerbed, surrounding path regradings had left its rim sitting low against the gravel walk, and a troublesome pump made keeping water in the basin a daily chore. In May 2026, after months of meticulous masonry and hydraulic restoration, the water returned.

Installed around 1920, the fountain honors Samuel Bulkley Ruggles (1800–1881), the visionary thirty-one-year-old lawyer who founded Gramercy Park in 1831. Combining a classical Tennessee marble stele and basin designed by architect Charles I. Berg with a bronze relief portrait sculpted by Edmond T. Quinn, the memorial was the gift of Ruggles’s grandson, John Ruggles Strong—who forty-five years earlier, in 1875, had already honored his grandfather with the bluestone tablet still set into the pavement just outside this same gate.

Historic timeline · 1831–about 1920

Origins & the grandson’s gift

The Ruggles Fountain by 1921, with its oval portrait, curved basin and neighbors on the path behind it.
The newly installed Ruggles Memorial Fountain looking northwest toward 1 Gramercy Park West and One Lexington Avenue, as published in John B. Pine’s The Story of Gramercy Park (1921). Edmond T. Quinn’s bronze medallion and inscription rise behind Charles I. Berg’s curved basin, with its marble rim standing clear above the path.

In the spring of 1831, thirty-one-year-old attorney and urban planner Samuel Bulkley Ruggles (1800–1881) purchased twenty-two acres of the old Duane farm, known as Gramercy Seat, from the heirs of post-Revolutionary New York Mayor James Duane. Much of the tract was a low valley and marsh drained by the Crummashie Vly (Gramercy Brook), and Ruggles spent thousands of dollars moving nearly a million cartloads of earth from neighboring Cedar Hill to level the ground into sixty-six building lots. On December 17, 1831, Samuel B. Ruggles and his wife, Mary Rosalie Rathbone Ruggles, conveyed forty-two lots (roughly two acres) at the center of the tract to five trustees to be enclosed and planted as a private park for the owners of the surrounding lots.

To open his new residential enclave to the growing city, Ruggles also ceded land to the municipality to cut Irving Place and Lexington Avenue north and south from Gramercy Park. Characteristically modest, he declined to attach his own name to any part of the enterprise—preserving the colonial Dutch and English name of the Duane farm for Gramercy Park, and naming his new thoroughfares for Washington Irving and the Battle of Lexington. It would fall to his grandson to place the founder’s name and likeness at the entrance to the square.

Water first played at the center of Gramercy Park in 1848, six years after the Croton Aqueduct brought running water to Manhattan. Two years earlier, in 1846, the Trustees had proposed a far grander basin modeled on the fountains in St. Peter’s Square in Rome, to be funded by subscriptions from the surrounding lot owners. When the lot owners tabled that ambitious scheme on account of cost, the Trustees erected a more modest tiered cast-iron fountain at the center of the Park in 1848. In 1866, the Park’s treasurer was authorized to crown the central fountain with a graceful new figure: a classical pewter water nymph who presided over the central paths for the next half century.

Stephen Garmey traces the larger scheme to Frederick Catherwood’s 1845 design and a Novelty Iron Works estimate of $4,800 to $5,300. The more modest “drip Fountain” that followed in 1847–48 cost $1,500. On April 28, 1866, the Trustees authorized the replacement of its original statue, which brought $40.98 when sold, and allocated $150 for the new figure. The water nymph’s sculptor is unnamed; she crowned a two-tiered fountain that rose twenty-one feet.

Below her floated a metal swan. Its small repair bills survive beside the larger commissions: Kedian & Bro. charged one dollar to repair it in 1879, and J. W. Fiske supplied a replacement on July 9, 1884, for $25. In 1918, the nymph left the central fountain for the smaller pool on the Park’s east side.

From the center to the gates

On November 13, 1918, Edmond T. Quinn and Edwin S. Dodge’s bronze monument to Edwin Booth as Hamlet was unveiled at the center of Gramercy Park, occupying the site where the old tiered fountain had stood since 1848. Not every neighbor welcomed the displacement of the nineteenth-century centerpiece. Writing three years later in The Story of Gramercy Park, 1831–1921, Trustee John B. Pine acknowledged that older residents had mourned the loss of the familiar water nymph, and offered them reassurance: she had not gone far.

To succeed the single central fountain, the Trustees commissioned architect Charles I. Berg (1856–1926)—himself a longtime Gramercy Park resident at 34 Gramercy Park East—to design a matching pair of low semicircular stone basins with stepped classical pedestals placed inside the Park’s eastern and western gates. Relieved of many accumulated coats of white and gold paint and restored to her natural pewter finish, the 1866 water nymph was placed atop Berg’s eastern fountain pedestal, where Pine thought she looked far more at home nestled among the shrubbery than on her old high iron perch.

The grandson’s gift

At the western gate, Berg’s companion fountain soon became a permanent monument to the founder of Gramercy Park. Rising from its stepped pedestal is a classical stele of pale Tennessee marble bearing an oval bronze portrait medallion of Samuel B. Ruggles in profile—modeled by Edmond T. Quinn (1868–1929), the sculptor of the Edwin Booth statue—above a rectangular bronze tablet naming Ruggles the founder of Gramercy Park. Together, Quinn’s two bronzes linked the center of the garden to its western threshold: Booth as Hamlet at the crossing of the paths, and Ruggles in profile facing the western gate.

Quinn based his relief on an earlier medallion made from life, carrying Ruggles’s likeness into the new monument. Garmey dates John Ruggles Strong’s presentation to 1919, in the period when Berg was also designing lamps for the Park’s perimeter.

The memorial was commissioned and presented around 1920 by Ruggles’s grandson, John Ruggles Strong (1851–1941)—a Columbia-educated attorney, musician, and Dante scholar who was the son of famed Civil War diarist and Trinity Church vestryman George Templeton Strong (1820–1875) and Ruggles’s daughter, Ellen Ruggles Strong (1825–1891). It was the second time Strong had honored his grandfather at this exact spot. Forty-five years earlier, in 1875, while Samuel B. Ruggles was still living, twenty-four-year-old John Ruggles Strong had set a rectangular bluestone tablet into the sidewalk pavement immediately outside the western gate recording that Gramercy Park had been founded by Samuel B. Ruggles in 1831—an inscription that still greets visitors underfoot today.

Returning to the same gate four and a half decades later with Quinn’s bronze portrait and Berg’s marble shaft, Strong completed what John B. Pine hailed in 1921 as a “long deferred and richly earned recognition.” The founder who had refused to name the square after himself now had both his name and his likeness at its gate.

Published in 1921, Pine’s history of the square recorded Strong’s gift and reproduced photographs of both the new Ruggles Memorial Fountain at the west gate and the relocated water nymph at the east gate—showing the monument already woven into the daily life of the Park, with children, benches, and shaded gravel walks close by.

Marble, bronze & the living garden

The memorial in the garden

The best place to experience the monument is from the western gate on Gramercy Park West. Look down at the pavement first: set directly in front of the iron gate lies the bluestone tablet John Ruggles Strong placed in 1875, forty-five years before the fountain rose inside the fence. Directly ahead across the gravel path stands the fountain itself: an oval bronze relief portrait of Samuel B. Ruggles in right profile set above a rectangular bronze dedication tablet on a tapered shaft of pale Tennessee marble. A projecting molded cornice crowned by an ornamental crest of carved scrolls, consoles, and rosettes finishes the top of the stele, while a stepped marble base below carries a foliate bronze mask spout that sends a steady stream of water into the basin.

In designing the fountain, Charles I. Berg translated the vocabulary of classical civic architecture into the intimate scale of a garden monument. The low, semicircular rim of the basin keeps the composition anchored close to the lawn and boxwood hedges, while Edmond T. Quinn’s finely modeled portrait medallion gives the stonework a warm human focus. Following the 2025–2026 restoration, a new course of matching Tennessee marble beneath the historic coping and monument base lifts the entire composition cleanly above the surrounding path.

Samuel B. Ruggles
Founder of
Gramercy Park
1831

The memorial’s founding inscription

The year 1831 cast into the bronze plaque commemorates the founding of Gramercy Park rather than the erection of the monument. Installed around 1920 through John Ruggles Strong’s generosity, the tablet placed the square’s origin story where neighbors and guests passing through the western gate would encounter it every day.

Other furnishings reward a slower look around the garden. The cast-iron birdhouses took their model from a Union Square birdhouse of about 1859, from the era when English sparrows were being introduced to American cities. In the northeast quadrant, a marble wellhead carved with bacchanalian scenes recalls a later gift: Henry Bruère presented it to the Park in November 1932.

A close view of the restored Ruggles Fountain, including the carved marble crest, bronze medallion and inscription, and water entering the basin.
The restored Samuel B. Ruggles Memorial Fountain in summer 2026, showing Edmond T. Quinn’s bronze portrait medallion, the 1831 founding tablet, the carved Tennessee marble crest, and the flowing bronze mask spout.

Active stewardship · 2025–2026

Restoring the fountain

By the early 2020s, a century of incremental changes in the surrounding garden had carried the Ruggles Fountain far from Charles I. Berg’s original design. Its semicircular basin had been filled with soil and planted over with dense shrubs, decades of path resurfacing had raised the surrounding gravel nearly flush with the stone rim, and recurring pump failures had made maintaining water in the fountain a daily struggle for Gramercy Park’s longtime Head Gardener, Amando Flores.

The comprehensive restoration of 2025–2026 was made possible by a generous gift to Gramercy Park from a Gramercy Park neighbor—a fitting centennial echo of John Ruggles Strong’s original gift around 1920. Just as one personal gift had brought the founder’s memorial into the garden, another restored its voice and proportions a century later.

Preservation architect Thomas A. Fenniman prepared the historical analysis and restoration drawings, with architectural conservation specialists B and H Art in Architecture, Ltd. serving as contractor. Following approval by the New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission, the Trustees of Gramercy Park announced the commencement of the restoration in October 2025.

The restored fountain with an open water basin and exposed stone rim, aligned to the pre-restoration view.After · 2026
Before restoration, shrubs surround the memorial and fill the fountain basin, concealing much of its stone edge.Before restoration
Slide to compare
From a planted basin to flowing water: the Samuel B. Ruggles Memorial Fountain before restoration and in summer 2026 following the 2025–2026 conservation.

Raising the basin, stone by stone

Restoring the monument’s original presence required a precise vertical adjustment measured in inches. Guided by the 1921 archival photographs in John B. Pine’s history—which showed the basin rim standing boldly above the gravel walk—Fenniman’s design raised the fountain’s perimeter seven and a half inches by inserting a new course of Tennessee marble beneath the cleaned and reset 1920 coping stones, paired with a matching new Tennessee marble plinth lifting the central monument shaft by the same height.

Remarkably, the new stone blocks were cut from the very same Tennessee marble quarry that had supplied the monument’s original stonework more than a century earlier.

On-site work began in late September 2025 when the overgrown shrubs and soil were cleared from the basin, the stonework was gently washed, and the monument was carefully dismantled section by section. The Trustees’ progress photographs from the autumn of 2025 reveal the intricate craftsmanship hidden beneath the finished garden: hand excavation around the foundations, rigging and chain-hoisting of the heavy marble blocks inside temporary scaffolding, and precision leveling of each reset stone course.

The restoration on paper

The July 2025 architectural drawings prepared by Thomas A. Fenniman illustrate the structural intervention at a glance. Shaded in orange are the new 7½-inch courses of Tennessee marble inserted beneath the semicircular basin coping and beneath the monument base, with the original 1920 marble elements cleaned, conserved, and reset directly above them.

Bringing the water back

Beneath the shimmering surface of the water lies engineering that no passerby sees: a concrete block infill and pitched topping slab sealed with a sanded liquid waterproof membrane, stainless-steel dowels anchoring the raised marble rim, a refurbished stainless-steel sump pit, and a durable new granite basin floor designed to hold water without leaking.

Annotated section through the proposed fountain showing a seven-and-a-half-inch marble addition, granite floor, waterproof membrane, anchors and retained sump pit.
Architect Thomas A. Fenniman’s July 2025 cross-section detail revealing the concealed waterproofing, stainless-steel anchors, granite basin floor, and new Tennessee marble courses (shaded in orange). Select the drawing to read the annotations.

Water flowed back into the basin in May 2026. Over the following weeks, Amando Flores and the conservation team fine-tuned the flow and water level, completing final adjustments in early June 2026. With its semicircular pool open to the sky and its raised Tennessee marble rim standing proud of the gravel path, the monument has recovered the crisp classical proportions seen in its 1921 photographs.

Framed by boxwood and Japanese maples just inside the western gate, the sound and sparkle of running water once again greet every neighbor stepping into Samuel B. Ruggles’s square.

  • Charles I. Berg (1856–1926)— Architect of the Park’s paired fountains. Trained at the École des Beaux-Arts in Paris, Berg designed 14 East 60th Street and the Gillender Building, lived at 34 Gramercy Park East, and served as secretary of the Gramercy Park Association. After the Booth statue displaced the old central fountain, he designed matching semicircular basins and classical pedestals inside the eastern and western gates. The western fountain became the setting for the Samuel B. Ruggles memorial installed around 1920.
  • Edmond Thomas Quinn (1868–1929)— Sculptor of the Ruggles portrait medallion. A Philadelphia- and Paris-trained portrait sculptor, Quinn also created Gramercy Park’s bronze statue of Edwin Booth as Hamlet. For the fountain, he modeled the oval bronze relief of Samuel B. Ruggles set into Charles I. Berg’s marble memorial. His two portraits connect the founder’s memorial at the western gate with the actor’s monument at the center of the Park.
  • Samuel Bulkley Ruggles (1800–1881)— Founder of Gramercy Park and New York canal commissioner. A Yale-educated lawyer, urban planner, and canal commissioner, Ruggles acquired the twenty-two-acre Duane farm in 1831 and moved nearly a million cartloads of earth to level the terrain. On December 17, 1831, he and his wife, Mary Rosalie, conveyed the central square of the development to trustees as an ornamental private park for the surrounding lot owners. The fountain, presented by his grandson around 1920, commemorates that founding gift.
  • John Ruggles Strong (1851–1941)— Attorney, musician, Dante scholar, and donor of the memorial. A Columbia-educated attorney, musician, and Dante scholar, Strong was the son of diarist George Templeton Strong and Ellen Ruggles Strong, and the grandson of Samuel B. Ruggles. In 1875 he placed the commemorative bluestone tablet still set outside the Park’s western gate. Around 1920 he commissioned and presented the fountain memorial, adding his grandfather’s bronze likeness to the place where he had first honored him.
The monument at a glance

Western end of Gramercy Park · Around 1920

Name
The Ruggles Fountain · Samuel B. Ruggles Memorial Fountain (historically, the West Fountain)
Location
Inside the western end of Gramercy Park, facing the Gramercy Park West gate, Manhattan. The east and west gates were the subject of S. B. Althouse’s May 8, 1844 ironwork bill.
Date
Installed c. 1920 (following the November 1918 unveiling of the Edwin Booth statue). The 1831 date on the plaque commemorates the founding of Gramercy Park. Garmey dates Strong’s presentation of the memorial to 1919.
Architect / sculptor
Charles I. Berg (1856–1926), architect of the twin fountain basins and pedestals; Edmond T. Quinn (1868–1929), sculptor of the bronze portrait medallion of Samuel B. Ruggles. Quinn’s portrait follows an earlier medallion made from life.
Original gift
Presented by John Ruggles Strong (1851–1941), grandson of Samuel B. Ruggles and son of diarist George Templeton Strong and Ellen Ruggles Strong. Strong had earlier placed the 1875 commemorative bluestone tablet still set into the pavement outside the western gate.
Materials
Tennessee marble stele, carved scroll-and-rosette crest, and semicircular basin coping (over a granite basin floor added in 2025–2026); bronze relief portrait medallion, dedication plaque, and foliate mask water spout.
Stewardship
Trustees of Gramercy Park.
Landmark status
Contributing monument within the Gramercy Park Historic District, designated by the NYC Landmarks Preservation Commission on September 20, 1966 (LP-0251), and listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1980.
Recent restoration
2025–2026, funded by a generous gift from a Gramercy Park neighbor. Restoration architect: Thomas A. Fenniman; conservation contractor: B and H Art in Architecture, Ltd. Water restored in May–June 2026.

Historic timeline

  1. 1831
  2. 1848
  3. 1866
  4. 1875
  5. Nov. 13, 1918
  6. Around 1920
  7. Sept. 20, 1966
    The New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission designates the Gramercy Park Historic District, encompassing the Park and its historic monuments.
  8. 2006–2009
    Trustees’ annual reports document mechanical pump maintenance, basin repairs, and seasonal plantings around the fountain.
  9. Sept.–Oct. 2025
  10. May–June 2026
Sources cited

The profile draws on John B. Pine’s 1921 history of Gramercy Park, archival collections, landmark records, and the Trustees’ restoration files and reports.

Origins and the grandson’s gift

  • John B. Pine, The Story of Gramercy Park, 1831–1921 (New York: Gramercy Park Association, 1921), pages 7–16 and 46–48. Documents Samuel B. Ruggles’s 1831 purchase of the Duane farm, the leveling of Cedar Hill into the marsh, and his naming of Gramercy Park, Irving Place, and Lexington Avenue (quoting Columbia College president Charles King’s 1851 address, pages 7–10); John Ruggles Strong’s 1875 western gate tablet (pages 11–12); the 1844 planting, 1846 St. Peter’s fountain proposal, 1848 central fountain, and 1866 water nymph (pages 12–15); and the November 13, 1918 unveiling of the Edwin Booth Memorial and relocation of the pewter nymph (pages 14–15, 46–48).
  • Samuel Bulkley Ruggles Papers (1811–1881), Manuscripts and Archives Division, The New York Public Library, documenting Ruggles’s urban planning and canal work.
  • Strong Family Papers (MS 602), New-York Historical Society, including the diaries of John Ruggles Strong (1851–1941); and Daniel Aaron, “The Greatest Diarist,” American Heritage, Vol. 39, No. 2 (March 1988), on George Templeton Strong, Ellen Ruggles Strong, and their sons.
  • Stephen Garmey, Gramercy Park (1984), pp. 34–35, 39, 44–45, 85, 132–133, 138–139, 171, 174–175. Additional details of the gates, fountains, memorials, lamps, birdhouses, and wellhead, drawing on the Archives of the Trustees of Gramercy Park, 1844–1932, cited and reproduced in Garmey’s history.

The gift and the architecture

  • John B. Pine, The Story of Gramercy Park, 1831–1921 (1921), pages 15–16 and photographic plates (“The West Fountain” and “The East Fountain”), identifying architect Charles I. Berg, sculptor Edmond T. Quinn, and donor John Ruggles Strong, and transcribing the memorial inscription.
  • Thomas A. Fenniman, Architect, Samuel B. Ruggles Memorial Fountain Restoration (Project No. 65200, July 2025 submission for the Trustees of Gramercy Park), three-sheet architectural drawing set documenting the historical chronology (c. 1920), existing condition survey, and restoration design—including the new 7½-inch Tennessee marble courses, granite basin floor, waterproofing membrane, stainless-steel anchors, and retained sump pit.
  • Library of Congress, Prints and Photographs Division, “Gramercy Park, New York, New York. Fountain” (c. 1922), Frances Benjamin Johnston Collection (LC-DIG-ppmsca-16153 / LCCN 2007685078), showing Charles I. Berg’s companion eastern fountain and the relocated water nymph.

Active stewardship and the living garden

  • New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission, Gramercy Park Historic District Designation Report (LP-0251, September 20, 1966).
  • Trustees of Gramercy Park, Annual Reports (2007–2009) and Fountain Restoration Project Records (2023–2026), documenting caretaking and pump maintenance reports, the September 2025 site preparation, and autumn 2025 progress photography.
  • Trustees of Gramercy Park, “The Ruggles Fountain: A Landmark Renewed” (October 16, 2025), announcing Landmarks Preservation Commission approval, Thomas A. Fenniman’s restoration design, disassembly of the monument, and the sourcing of new blocks from the original Tennessee marble quarry.
  • Gramercy Park Block Association, “In the Park & Around the Neighborhood” (June 2026), reporting the fountain’s return to full operation in May–June 2026.

Some of the fountain’s story is still missing: the exact date the memorial was dedicated, and what became of the fountain in the middle decades of the twentieth century, including when its basin was first planted. If you have photographs, letters or memories of the fountain from those years, we would love to hear from you through our contact page.

Photo credits for this page

Continue reading