Gramercy Park Block Association
Gramercy Stories

The Gramercy

34 Gramercy Park East · New York’s oldest continuously operating cooperative · George W. da Cunha

Warm sunlight on the red-brick turrets of 34 Gramercy Park East, with a rainbow above the trees.
Warm sunlight catches The Gramercy’s red brick and slate-and-copper turrets beneath a rainbow above the trees of Gramercy Park.

A home on the Park · Since 1883

The name is carved in brownstone over the door—GRAMERCY, beneath a pair of winged lions—at the ten-story red-brick and terra-cotta apartment house that has stood at the northeast corner of Gramercy Park East and East 20th Street since 1883. Built when apartment ownership was still an unfamiliar experiment in New York, it was organized on a remarkably democratic principle: its promoter, Charles A. Gerlach, insisted that apartments cost the exact same on every floor so that no family would feel above another. Today, it is New York City’s oldest continuously operating cooperative.

For more than a century, the building’s original Otis passenger elevator ran on water pressure, announced by the clunk of valves and a rush of water from a tank on the roof. Over the generations, this one corner building has also gathered an extraordinary cast of residents in the arts, letters, and medicine—from concert soprano Emma Thursby, whose Friday musical salons welcomed Swami Vivekananda, Mary Garden, and Geraldine Farrar, to Emily Dickinson’s niece Martha Dickinson Bianchi, Civil War nurse and memoirist Lucy Seaman Bainbridge, and screen legends James Cagney, Gregory Peck, and Margaret Hamilton.

For those of us who grew up in the building, though, the most unforgettable address was the ninth floor: the top-floor home of the Wicked Witch of the West, whose annual Halloween tradition brought carved, candle-lit pumpkins and freshly baked cookies to the hallways.

Explore the history

The building and the lives within it

1852–1883 · A NEW KIND OF HOME

From a hotel to a home

Sanderson’s Family Hotel and the Gramercy Park House

In 1852, real-estate investor Oscar S. Stebbins bought the entire eastern blockfront of Gramercy Park between East 20th and East 21st Streets and erected a continuous row of brick-and-brownstone townhouses. The following year, the houses were joined internally as Sanderson’s Family Hotel, known by the 1860s as the Gramercy Park House.

A year before Stebbins’s purchase, Garmey records an open marble yard on the east side of the Park. His account follows the hotel through an 1854 listing as Sanderson’s Hotel and the Gramercy Park House name by 1856, with Henry Crocker operating it until 1863 and Park Trustee Curtis Judson thereafter. In 1880, Arthur G. King reopened the central section as the Gramercy Park Hotel, before the southern portion made way for No. 34.

Miller’s New York As It Is (1866) praised the establishment as a hotel “of colossal proportions” overlooking the Park’s “delightful shrubbery.” Gramercy Park historian John B. Pine remembered it as a favored resort of Southern and Cuban families before and after the Civil War, as well as the frequent meeting place of the Park’s lot owners and trustees.

By June 1882, the thirty-year-old hotel complex was being sold off in parcels. Builder James Campbell, partner in the construction firm Phyfe & Campbell (John J. Phyfe and James Campbell), acquired the southernmost sixty-one feet at the northeast corner of East 20th Street for $90,000 and demolished that section of the old hotel row. (The northern portion of the hotel survived until 1908, when it gave way to 36 Gramercy Park East.)

The Gramercy Park House hotel, with repeated entrances, iron balconies and window awnings
The Gramercy Park House hotel, with its row of entrances and iron balconies facing the Park.

A family hotel becomes a cooperative

On June 24, 1882, the Real Estate Record and Builders’ Guide announced Campbell’s project:

“George W. Da Cunha has drawn the designs for the extensive family hotel, on the European plan, to be erected on the northeast corner of Gramercy Park and Twentieth street. It will be nine stories high, with a frontage of 63 feet on the Park and 125 feet on the street with an L in the rear 27x44. … The owner, Mr. James Campbell, expects to expend at least $300,000 on this fine building.”

— Real Estate Record and Builders’ Guide, June 24, 1882

The notice promised open fireplaces in all major rooms, three open courts for direct light and air, two freight elevators, and one passenger elevator—but said not a word about cooperative ownership.

That idea arrived with promoter Charles A. Gerlach. Early in 1883, as construction neared completion, Gerlach organized a new corporation, The Gramercy Company, which took title to the corner property from James Campbell on April 14, 1883, for an expressed consideration of $327,500. Under Gerlach’s plan, apartment buyers received stock in The Gramercy Company, a proprietary lease on their apartment, and a vote for the board of trustees that managed the building.

The Gramercy Company was incorporated on March 28, 1883. Garmey identifies Judge William H. Arnoux among its leaders and records a capitalization of 6,500 shares at $100 each. Before its cooperative life, the project was known as the Gramercy Family Hotel.

The same price on every floor—and Louis Sherry on the eighth

Gerlach sold six of the residential floors to tenant-shareholders and retained four levels as corporation-owned rental apartments, counting on the rental income to pay the building’s mortgage interest, taxes, and operating expenses while returning a modest dividend.

When a reporter for the Real Estate Record and Builders’ Guide interviewed Gerlach in November 1883 and asked whether apartment prices varied from floor to floor, Gerlach refused to turn height into a hierarchy of social rank:

“The moment you charge a different price for each floor you at once change the caste of your whole house, and divide it into classes. The family that lives on the ninth floor of the ‘Gramercy’ feels just as happy and satisfied as the one on the first, and also quite equal, because the purchasers all pay the same for their apartments, and the tenants the same rents.”

— Charles A. Gerlach, Real Estate Record and Builders’ Guide, November 17, 1883

The building’s origins as a family hotel carried over into its domestic arrangements: residents who did not wish to keep cooks could take their meals from Louis Sherry (1855–1926). Near the start of his storied Gilded Age catering career, Sherry managed the eighth-floor restaurant at The Gramercy during its opening year, sending dinners down to private apartments via the service elevators.

Unlike many of New York’s early 1880s “Home Clubs”—whose members banded together to finance construction before ground was broken—The Gramercy was sold to its shareholders as a completed building. Flush with their success on Gramercy Park, builders Phyfe & Campbell immediately embarked on an even grander cooperative apartment house at Fifth Avenue and East 59th Street, again hiring George W. da Cunha as initial architect. That venture bankrupted the builders before completion and opened under new owners as the original Plaza Hotel. While every earlier New York cooperative eventually dissolved, was demolished, or reverted to rental or hotel use, the 1883 experiment at 34 Gramercy Park East endured.

The June 24, 1882 announcement of Da Cunha’s family hotel for James Campbell
The original announcement: a family hotel “on the European plan,” June 24, 1882.
The 1883 interview reporting a $25,000 resale and explaining equal prices on every floor
Gerlach’s own words on resale prices and the “caste” of the house, November 17, 1883.
1883–1931 · MUSIC AT HOME

Emma Thursby’s Fridays

George Peter Alexander Healy’s full-length 1879 portrait of Emma Thursby in a pale blue gown
Healy’s 1879 portrait, which hung in Thursby’s drawing room.

The soprano on the corner

Emma Thursby (1845–1931) bought her apartment in 1883 and moved in with her family. She was thirty-eight, a celebrated American concert singer who had toured Europe and repeatedly declined an operatic career. At No. 34, she made a home where musicians, writers and friends gathered for decades.

The crystal-clear coloratura that filled those rooms had carried Emma Cecilia Thursby from church choirs in Brooklyn and at Broadway Tabernacle to concert stages across Europe and North America. One of the first American women to forge an international musical career, she signed a $100,000 concert contract in 1877 with impresario Maurice Strakosch, Adelina Patti’s brother-in-law and former manager.

The drawing room had two fireplaces and windows on three sides. A full-length portrait by G. P. A. Healy, painted in Paris in 1879, showed her in pale blue satin with music in her gloved hand. Around it accumulated pictures, gifts and souvenirs from her travels.

Emma Thursby standing beside a parlor organ in an elaborate period gown
Emma Thursby beside a parlor organ in a period portrait.

Fridays at home

On winter Fridays, Emma and her sister Ina Love Thursby welcomed singers, actors, writers, artists and friends. A guest list survives in her papers, and newspapers occasionally recorded the gatherings. On February 27, 1914, the guest of honor was the opera star Mary Garden. The drawing room was also a classroom: among the young singers who studied with Thursby was the future Metropolitan Opera star Geraldine Farrar, who studied with Thursby at No. 34 from 1894 to 1898.

Even a concert celebrity had to work around the co-op’s house rules, which forbade piano practice before 8:00 A.M. or after 6:00 P.M. Between tours, the sisters’ receptions became coveted invitations in New York’s musical, literary, and artistic worlds: “Thursby Fridays.”

Garmey’s account of these gatherings also names Enrico Caruso and Nellie Melba among the celebrated singers associated with Thursby’s apartment. The Fridays brought visiting performers and young pupils into the same domestic rooms.

Swami Vivekananda (1863–1902), whom Thursby met in Chicago in 1893, became another friend. She and Sara Bull helped arrange his New York lectures; on January 28, 1895, he spoke in her drawing room. The singer and the swami also taught one another: he introduced her to Indian music, while she taught him songs by Edvard Grieg. Thursby called the voice he used for Sanskrit chants “rarely beautiful.” Their surviving letters mix practical arrangements with more personal news—including his newly acquired scarlet coat.

The bird who received letters

The household’s other celebrity was Mynah—a talking mynah bird acquired in Germany around 1887. Newspapers credited him with five languages and considerable musical ability. From the window, he reportedly watched the children in the Park and begged to join them: “Mamma, mamma, I want to get out! I’ll come right back.”

His owner’s papers preserve letters addressed to the bird, including thanks for entertaining visiting children and permission from the Pullman company to travel with Thursby.

After the music

Emma died in the apartment on July 4, 1931. Ina stayed on among her sister’s belongings; a reporter visiting in 1937 still found the fireplaces, grandfather’s clock and Healy portrait in place. Ina later gave Emma’s papers to the New-York Historical Society, and the portrait followed from her estate.

1886–1985 · ACROSS THE DECADES

The neighbors upstairs

The Water Nymph fountain beneath the trees of Gramercy Park, about 1922
One of the Park’s fountains, about 1922. Charles I. Berg lived at No. 34 before designing the pair.

Artists from the start

From the beginning, The Gramercy drew an unusually high concentration of figures in the arts—a tradition begun in 1883 in Emma Thursby’s musical drawing room and carried across the decades by architects, poets, and Hollywood legends. Some of those earliest creative residents left their mark just beyond the front door: architect Charles I. Berg, who gave No. 34 as his address by 1886, designed the two fountains facing the Park’s east and west gates.

Emily Dickinson’s niece

In the early 1900s, an apartment at No. 34 was home to Martha Gilbert Dickinson Bianchi, the niece and literary heir of Emily Dickinson. A poet and novelist in her own right, Bianchi later helped bring her reclusive aunt’s unpublished manuscripts to a wider public—publishing The Single Hound in 1914 and following it with the collections of poems and letters that helped secure Dickinson’s place in American literature.

Read the clipping and literary background →

A surgeon and his mother

Few residents led a more intrepid life than Lucy Seaman Bainbridge (1842–1928), who shared an apartment at No. 34 with her son, Dr. William Seaman Bainbridge (1870–1947), an internationally prominent surgeon, cancer specialist, and U.S. Navy medical commander. A former Civil War nurse with the Union Army in Virginia who later traveled around the world and spent sixteen years leading the Woman’s Branch of the New York City Mission Society, Mrs. Bainbridge was not easily deterred: as she recounted in her 1924 memoir Yesterdays, when seaside beaches were fouled by city waste, she disguised herself, chartered a tugboat, and chased New York’s garbage scows out to sea to prove they were dumping refuse illegally close to shore. She lived at No. 34 until her death in November 1928, when her funeral service was held in the family apartment; Dr. Bainbridge remained in residence until his death in September 1947.

James Cagney in a Warner Bros. publicity portrait
James Cagney in a studio publicity portrait, circa 1930s.
Dr. William Seaman Bainbridge in a formal portrait
Dr. William Seaman Bainbridge.
Lucy Seaman Bainbridge in a formal portrait
Lucy Seaman Bainbridge, whose memoir Yesterdays appeared in 1924.
Gregory Peck in a studio publicity portrait from 1944
Gregory Peck in a studio publicity portrait, 1944.
The James Cagney plaque at No. 34, recording his 1965–1968 residence and naming Margaret Hamilton and Emma Thursby
The plaque at No. 34 commemorates James Cagney and names Margaret Hamilton and Emma Thursby.

Seventy-five years of neighbors

On March 28, 1958, fifty residents gathered in the apartment of Mr. and Mrs. Frederick Garfield to drink champagne to The Gramercy’s seventy-fifth birthday. The New York Times found a building whose apartments had changed while its three original elevators still ran by pulling a cable. Its residents included “doctors, lawyers, actors, editors and business executives.” The New Yorker marked the anniversary too, in a piece called “Seventy-Five.”

Two leading men

Actors John Carradine and Mildred Dunnock also appear among the residents in Garmey’s account, extending the building’s theatrical company beyond its better-known screen stars.

James Cagney lived here from 1965 to 1968, the years recorded on the plaque outside; he and his wife, Frances, were regulars in the dining room of the nearby Gramercy Park Hotel. Fellow screen legend Gregory Peck also made his home at No. 34. For the building’s children, however, another movie star had a far more powerful hold on the imagination.

Margaret Hamilton as the Wicked Witch of the West leaning toward Judy Garland as Dorothy in The Wizard of Oz
Margaret Hamilton’s Wicked Witch confronts Judy Garland’s Dorothy in The Wizard of Oz (1939).

Halloween with the Wicked Witch

Margaret Hamilton lived on the ninth floor. Her performance in The Wizard of Oz had made her face and voice terrifying to generations of children. Away from the screen, the former kindergarten teacher was deeply concerned about that effect. At No. 34, she helped turn Halloween into a celebration that filled the hallways.

Hamilton started a yearly tradition of decorating the hallways with carved, candle-lit pumpkins and setting out baskets of candy and freshly baked cookies. A former neighbor, Susan Tunick, remembered one year when Hamilton hung her Wicked Witch costume in the doorway to greet the children who rang her bell.

Margaret Hamilton as the Wicked Witch of the West, with her handwritten dedication to Nicholas and Timothy
The Wicked Witch portrait Hamilton signed for Nick and Timothy.

Having grown up at No. 34, I remember that Halloween tradition fondly—even if, as a little boy, there was a time I wouldn’t go near the ninth floor. To a child’s imagination, the Wicked Witch lived right upstairs in the “attic,” and my older brother, Nick, was every bit as terrified as I was. When we finally met our upstairs neighbor in person, the spell broke instantly: she was petite, soft-spoken, and profoundly kind, signing a studio portrait of herself as the Witch for Nick and me.

Her life on screen and around the Park, along with my childhood memories of her at No. 34, are the subject of the first profile in our People of Gramercy series:

Read The Wicked Witch Upstairs: Margaret Hamilton →

1883–1911 · THE ARCHITECTURE

Behind the winged lions

Carved faces and foliage on one of The Gramercy’s projecting bays
Faces and foliage among the building’s carved ornament.

The heads outside the window

Susan Tunick, the neighbor who remembered Hamilton’s costume at the door, found another subject to occupy her at No. 34. She came to New York in 1969 and lived here for a time. Working in clay, she began to wonder about the ornament outside her window.

“I would notice beautiful heads outside of our window,” she recalled in 2020, “and it was a red brick building from 1883.” If the building was brick, she reasoned, “those ornaments must be clay also.” Her curiosity led her to architectural terra cotta, to the newly formed Friends of Terra Cotta, of which she became president, and to Terra-Cotta Skyline, her 1997 book on the city’s ornament.

From the sidewalk

Da Cunha’s design was described in 1882 as “in the Renaissance style.” What he built is now called Queen Anne. The AIA Guide to New York City called it “a craggy, mysterious red brick and red terra-cotta pile whose Queen Anne forms are among the city’s most spectacular.”

Looking up from the sidewalk, the first two stories are rusticated brownstone carved with foliage and flowers, fronted by a porch resting on polished granite columns. Above the columns is carved the name GRAMERCY, guarded by a pair of winged lions. Beyond them rises red pressed brick striped with brownstone and banded with terra cotta, where carved faces peer out from the walls beneath a roofline of slate-capped turrets, mansards, dormers, and a pedimented gable.

Terra cotta was a material New York’s architects were only beginning to trust. The Landmarks Commission points to No. 34 as an early example, with the ornament applied here and there to a building supported by massive masonry walls.

Inside the door

Inside the brownstone portico, the entrance vestibule and lobby were designed to resemble the reception hall of a private Victorian mansion: leaded stained glass overhead and flanking the oak doors, patterned encaustic tile underfoot, a carved wood fireplace mantel, dark wainscot paneling, and beveled glass.

Garmey identifies Minton tiles in the vestibule and describes twenty-four-inch interior brick walls and floors flashed with tin to keep mice from passing between rooms. The practical precautions belonged to the same building as the stained glass and carved entrance hall.

The Gramercy’s red-brick facade, corner bays and slate-capped turrets
The Gramercy at 34 Gramercy Park East (northeast corner of Gramercy Park East and East 20th Street), designed by George W. da Cunha in 1882–1883 in the Queen Anne style with a rusticated brownstone base, pressed red brick, architectural terra cotta, and slate-capped turrets.
The carved entrance portico with GRAMERCY lettering, winged lions and polished granite columns
The entrance in 2011, before the recent replacement of its brownstone capitals.
The entrance vestibule with stained-glass ceiling and doors beneath a carved stone arch
Stained glass, carved wood and brownstone just inside the entrance.
Original 1911 publication scan of Nos. 36 and 34 Gramercy Park East
“The oldest apartment and one of the newest”: No. 34 at right beside No. 36, 1911.

A place among the houses

At 112 feet, The Gramercy was startlingly tall for a home in 1883. So tall, in fact, that two years later, when the city capped new apartment houses at seventy feet on narrow streets and eighty on wide ones, it could no longer have been built as an apartment house. Nothing in Samuel B. Ruggles's covenant for the Park stood in its way. It required brick or stone dwellings and kept out trade. As the Record explained in 1911, the restriction “did not covenant against many-family houses.”

That article pictured No. 34 beside its new neighbor at No. 36: “The oldest apartment and one of the newest.” The people inside had the same Park privileges as the owners of private houses—and, as shareholders, a stake in keeping the surroundings residential.

1883–1994 · A WATER-POWERED ELEVATOR

An elevator run on water

Illustration of an elevator car in its shaft, with ropes, pulleys and passengers waiting at a landing
An elevator’s car, shaft and pulleys, illustrated in Christopher Gray’s 1994 “Streetscapes” article.

Water at the top of the house

The “one passenger elevator” of the 1882 plan was an Otis, and like the two service cars it was hydraulic. In 1883 that meant water. Where the street mains could not be relied on, Otis Brothers explained in an advertisement that summer, the pressure came from a tank at the top of the house. “The water is exhausted by the machine into a tank placed in the cellar, and from this lower tank the water is again transferred to the upper tank by means of a pump.”

The Gramercy’s machine worked that way, and it was still working that way in 1994.

Already a curiosity in 1947

The company’s earlier house records preserve less grand elevator history. On May 21, 1902, Mrs. J. P. Day complained that the gate had torn a silk skirt made from fabric costing $14 a yard. A notice dated July 27, 1908, concerned damage outdoors: a runaway horse and wagon had broken sixteen feet of the front iron railing. Garmey quotes these small administrative episodes from the building’s archives.

In 1947, The New Yorker reported that The Gramercy’s three hydraulic elevators had inherited the city’s seniority after the Murray Hill Hotel’s lift retired. A cable ran through each car from floor to ceiling. The machinery would keep working for nearly another half-century.

What Christopher Gray found

In August 1994, as the co-op set about replacing it, the architectural historian Christopher Gray described the machinery in his “Streetscapes” column in the Times. There were tanks on the roof and in the basement and, in a narrow rear shaft, a piston assembly five stories long. Water pressure drove the piston. The piston, through pulleys and hoisting ropes, moved the car. A rope running down through the cab worked the valves until about 1991, when push buttons finally took its place. The doorman worked that rope, and every so often he would let those of us who were children in the building take hold and pull.

It was not a quiet ride. The machine announced itself with a clunk and a rush of water. Its speed, by the reckoning of the co-op’s president, Charles Bonnes, was about fifty feet a minute, and a change of load could speed it up or stop it. The superintendent, Raymond Santiago, regarded its repairs as plumbing. Gray called it “generally considered the oldest one operating in New York City, and perhaps the United States,” while noting that no one had taken a census.

A hard thing to give up

Replacing the century-old system in 1994 cost about $700,000, and project architect Robert E. Meadows estimated that the new electric drive would carry residents upstairs at roughly three times the speed. Drawing on old woodcuts and surviving details, Christopher Gray described how the passenger cab had originally risen through an open iron cage, with the main staircase winding around it.

After 111 years of service, the water-powered drive went. The historic passenger car stayed, and it still carries residents home today.

Otis’s 1883 explanation of a hydraulic elevator using a roof tank, cellar tank and pump
An 1883 Otis Brothers notice explaining the roof-tank hydraulic system used at The Gramercy.
1966–PRESENT · PRESERVATION

Keeping The Gramercy

The restored entrance, with carved capitals, winged lions and GRAMERCY lettering
The entrance after restoration.

The edge of the district

When the Landmarks Preservation Commission designated the Gramercy Park Historic District on September 20, 1966, it ran the boundary down Gramercy Park East as far as the northern property line of No. 34 and wrapped it around the building. The Gramercy was in. Its neighbor to the north was not, and for the next twenty-two years No. 34 was the district’s last building on that side of the Park, until the district was extended to include No. 36 in 1988.

Brownstone, slate and six new capitals

Caring for a Victorian facade of soft brownstone, pressed brick, and terra cotta is a generational task. After early patching and repointing in the summer of 1985, the co-op retained Walter B. Melvin Architects in 1998 to steward the exterior—including a 2005 campaign that mended the winged lions and stripped later stucco from the portico parapet.

Brownstone flakes as weather works into its layers, and by 2021 a full survey showed how far that had gone. The result was the most ambitious restoration yet, reaching from the street-level entrance to the rooftop turrets: masonry repair and repointing, new slate roofs and restored copperwork.

The six column capitals at the entrance were replaced in brownstone, and the lettering above them restored. The architects’ comparison shows how much of the carving had been lost.

Comparison of a weathered column capital at left and its newly carved replacement at right
A weathered capital, left, and its replacement, right.
Two views of the slate-roof restoration, showing workers beside a turret and completed slate and copperwork
Slate and copper work on the turrets.

In 2025 the Victorian Society in America named the project one of its three preservation award winners for the year, “for expert and extensive repair and restoration of deteriorated exterior masonry and stonework.” Its citation calls No. 34 “New York City’s oldest continuously operating cooperative.”

Stand across the street and look at the porch. The six capitals are new, the winged lions are mended and the restored letters read GRAMERCY.

34 Gramercy Park East illuminated at night beyond the Park’s trees, beside the pale facade of No. 36.
The Gramercy after dark, with the pale facade of No. 36 alongside it.
  • Lucy Seaman Bainbridge (1842–1928)— Civil War nurse, philanthropist, and author who served with the Union Army in Virginia and later led the Woman’s Branch of the New York City Mission Society for sixteen years. Her memoir Yesterdays (1924) recalled a life of travel and public service, including her investigation of illegal dumping from New York’s garbage scows. She shared an apartment at 34 Gramercy Park East with her son, Dr. William Seaman Bainbridge, and lived there until her death in 1928.
  • William Seaman Bainbridge, M.D. (1870–1947)— Surgeon, cancer researcher, and medical author who also served as a U.S. Navy medical commander. He shared an apartment at 34 Gramercy Park East with his mother, the Civil War nurse and memoirist Lucy Seaman Bainbridge, and remained in residence after her death until his own in September 1947.
  • Charles I. Berg (1856–1926)— Architect who designed the two classical fountains facing Gramercy Park’s east and west gates. He gave 34 Gramercy Park East as his address by 1886, joining the building’s early community of artists and leaving a lasting mark on the Park outside his door.
  • Martha Gilbert Dickinson Bianchi (1866–1943)— Poet, novelist, and literary editor who became the sole heir of her aunt, Emily Dickinson. She published The Single Hound (1914) and later collections of Dickinson’s poems and letters, helping bring the unpublished work to a wider public. Bianchi lived at 34 Gramercy Park East in the early 1900s.
  • James Cagney (1899–1986)— Academy Award–winning actor and dancer. Born on Manhattan’s Lower East Side, Cagney starred in The Public Enemy (1931), Angels with Dirty Faces (1938), Yankee Doodle Dandy (1942), and White Heat (1949), and received the AFI Life Achievement Award and Presidential Medal of Freedom. Alongside his farm in Dutchess County, he and his wife, Frances, maintained an apartment at 34 Gramercy Park East from 1965 to 1968. A bronze medallion on the facade commemorates his years in the building.
  • Frederick Stuart Church (1842–1924)— Painter, illustrator, etcher, and National Academician. Church’s whimsical allegories and animal illustrations attracted collectors including Charles Lang Freer, and his work was exhibited at the National Academy of Design. He maintained top-floor studio quarters at 34 Gramercy Park East in the late nineteenth century and belonged to the building’s artistic circle.
  • George W. da Cunha (1846–1894)— Architect of The Gramercy. Da Cunha designed the building in 1882–1883 as a family hotel, with a ten-story Queen Anne facade of red brick, brownstone, and decorative terra cotta, hydraulic elevators, and a tiled lobby. Charles A. Gerlach organized its conversion into a shareholder cooperative in 1883. Today, it remains New York City’s oldest continuously operating cooperative apartment house.
  • Charles A. Gerlach (c. 1848–1908)— Real-estate promoter who organized The Gramercy Company in 1883 and converted the newly completed family hotel into a shareholder cooperative. Buyers received company stock, a proprietary lease, and a vote in the building’s management. Gerlach insisted on equal apartment prices on every floor so that height would not become a hierarchy of social rank.
  • Hermann Hagedorn (1882–1964)— Poet, Theodore Roosevelt biographer, and preservationist. Harvard’s Class Poet of 1907, Hagedorn became a prolific biographer of his friend Roosevelt, writing Roosevelt in the Bad Lands and The Roosevelt Family of Sagamore Hill. He lived at 34 Gramercy Park East while serving as executive director of the Theodore Roosevelt Association and overseeing the restoration of the Theodore Roosevelt Birthplace at 28 East 20th Street.
  • Margaret Hamilton (1902–1985)— Stage and screen actress and neighborhood preservationist. A former kindergarten teacher and veteran character actress, Hamilton became internationally known as Miss Almira Gulch and the Wicked Witch of the West in The Wizard of Oz (1939). She lived for decades in Apartment 9B at 34 Gramercy Park East and served on the board of Gramercy Neighborhood Associates. At home, she helped establish the building’s Halloween tradition of candle-lit pumpkins, candy, and freshly baked cookies in the hallways, welcoming the children who knew the Wicked Witch as their upstairs neighbor.
  • Goddard Lieberson (1911–1977) & Vera Zorina (1917–2003)— Columbia Records president; ballerina and actress. Lieberson championed the LP format and landmark Broadway cast recordings including My Fair Lady, West Side Story, and Camelot, helping shape a label associated with Miles Davis, Glenn Gould, Leonard Bernstein, and Bob Dylan. Zorina danced with the Ballet Russe de Monte Carlo and appeared in I Married an Angel and On Your Toes. The couple maintained an apartment at 34 Gramercy Park East.
  • Mildred Natwick (1905–1994)— Tony- and Academy Award–nominated stage, film, and television actress. Natwick’s theater work included Blithe Spirit, The Waltz of the Toreadors, and Barefoot in the Park, while her screen roles included John Ford’s She Wore a Yellow Ribbon and The Quiet Man and Alfred Hitchcock’s The Trouble with Harry. She made her home at 34 Gramercy Park East during her New York theater career.
  • Gregory Peck (1916–2003)— Academy Award–winning actor and Presidential Medal of Freedom recipient. Peck studied at the Neighborhood Playhouse and made his Broadway debut in Emlyn Williams’s The Morning Star in 1942 before establishing his Hollywood career in films including The Keys of the Kingdom and Spellbound. He made his New York home at 34 Gramercy Park East with his first wife, Greta Kukkonen. His later films included Roman Holiday and To Kill a Mockingbird.
  • Louis Sherry (1855–1926)— Restaurateur, caterer, and confectioner whose career became closely associated with Gilded Age New York. During The Gramercy’s opening year in 1883, he operated its eighth-floor dining room and sent meals down to residents’ apartments by service elevator, carrying the building’s origins as a family hotel into cooperative life.
  • Emma Cecilia Thursby (1845–1931)— Internationally celebrated concert soprano and inaugural 1883 shareholder. Acclaimed throughout Europe and North America, Thursby purchased a ninth-floor apartment at 34 Gramercy Park East when the building opened in 1883. For nearly five decades, she and her sister Ina hosted Friday musicales overlooking the Park, welcoming a circle that included Mark Twain, Thomas Edison, Augustus Saint-Gaudens, and John La Farge. Young soprano Geraldine Farrar studied voice in Thursby’s drawing room, and Swami Vivekananda became a friend and visiting lecturer.
  • Ina Love Thursby (1848–1937)— Musical patron, archivist, and salon co-host. Ina shared the ninth-floor apartment at 34 Gramercy Park East with her sister Emma for more than forty-five years and helped host its celebrated Friday salons. After Emma’s death in 1931, she preserved the household’s musical legacy and donated the extensive Thursby correspondence and archives to the New-York Historical Society.
  • Swami Vivekananda (1863–1902)— Indian Hindu monk and philosopher whose New York lectures brought him into Emma Thursby’s circle. Thursby and Sara Bull helped arrange his lectures, and he spoke in Thursby’s drawing room at 34 Gramercy Park East on January 28, 1895. Their friendship also included an exchange of music: he introduced her to Indian music, while she taught him songs by Edvard Grieg.
Building at a glance

The building record

Address34 Gramercy Park East · 142–146 East 20th Street (Earlier Nos. 33 and 34 Gramercy Park; Manhattan Block 876, Lot 18)
Built1882–1883 (Announced June 24, 1882; deeded to The Gramercy Company on April 14, 1883)
ArchitectGeorge W. da Cunha (1846–1894)
BuildersPhyfe & Campbell (John J. Phyfe and James Campbell)
Cooperative promoterCharles A. Gerlach · The Gramercy Company (Owner of record since April 14, 1883) Incorporated March 28, 1883; Garmey records 6,500 shares at $100 each and Judge William H. Arnoux among the company’s leaders.
Earlier building on siteSanderson’s Family Hotel / Gramercy Park House (1852–1882)
Form & styleTen-story (including lobby) Queen Anne apartment house in rusticated brownstone, pressed red brick, and architectural terra cotta with slate-and-copper turrets; load-bearing masonry walls 16 to 32 inches thick
Dimensions & scaleLot 61 ft. × 125 ft. · Height 112 ft. (Built two years before New York’s June 1885 height cap of 70–80 feet on new apartment houses)
ApartmentsOriginally three large apartments per residential floor (45 units in current municipal records)
ElevatorsThree 1883 Otis roof-tank water-powered hydraulic elevators; passenger drive converted to electricity in 1994 while retaining the historic wooden cab
Historic districtGramercy Park Historic District (Designated September 20, 1966, LP-0251)
Restoration & honorsWalter B. Melvin Architects (Stewardship since 1998; comprehensive masonry, brownstone capital, slate, and copper restoration 2021–2025) · Victorian Society in America Preservation Award (2025)

Over time

  1. 1852–1853

    Sanderson’s Family Hotel and the Gramercy Park House

    Oscar S. Stebbins builds a row of townhouses along the eastern blockfront of Gramercy Park that are united in 1853 as Sanderson’s Family Hotel, known by the 1860s as the Gramercy Park House.

  2. June 1882

    Da Cunha’s corner design is announced

    Builder James Campbell of Phyfe & Campbell acquires the southernmost 61-by-125-foot corner parcel at East 20th Street and commissions architect George W. da Cunha to design a $300,000 Queen Anne family hotel.

  3. April 14, 1883

    The Gramercy Company takes title

    Promoter Charles A. Gerlach organizes The Gramercy Company, takes title to the completed building, and sells shares and proprietary leases with the same apartment price on every floor, while Louis Sherry runs the eighth-floor dining room.

  4. 1883–1931

    Emma Thursby’s Friday musical salons

    Concert soprano Emma Thursby buys her corner apartment in 1883, welcoming musicians, writers, pupil Geraldine Farrar, and in January 1895 Swami Vivekananda—alongside her polyglot talking mynah bird.

  5. 1886–1947

    Architects, poets, and physicians

    Architect Charles I. Berg (designer of the Park’s two gate fountains), Emily Dickinson’s niece and editor Martha Gilbert Dickinson Bianchi, Civil War nurse and author Lucy Seaman Bainbridge, and surgeon Dr. William Seaman Bainbridge make their homes at No. 34.

  6. March 28, 1958

    Seventy-five years as a cooperative

    Residents gather to toast the seventy-fifth anniversary of New York’s oldest surviving cooperative while its three original 1883 hydraulic elevators still run by pulling an operating cable.

  7. 1960s–1985

    Hollywood on Gramercy Park and Halloween on the ninth floor

    Screen legends James Cagney (resident 1965–1968) and Gregory Peck live at No. 34, while ninth-floor resident Margaret Hamilton transforms Halloween with candle-lit pumpkins and homemade cookies.

  8. September 20, 1966

    Landmark designation

    The New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission designates the Gramercy Park Historic District, anchoring its southeastern boundary around 34 Gramercy Park East.

  9. August 1994

    Retiring the 111-year-old water-powered elevator drive

    After more than a century of operation from roof and basement water tanks, the 1883 Otis hydraulic passenger mechanism is replaced with an electric drive while preserving the historic passenger cab.

  10. 2021–2025

    Comprehensive exterior restoration and national award

    Walter B. Melvin Architects completes a full restoration of the brick, terra cotta, slate turrets, copper cresting, carved brownstone portico capitals, and winged lions, earning the 2025 Victorian Society in America Preservation Award.

Sources cited

Trade-press reports, city records, a singer’s papers and the restoration architects document different chapters of the house. The elevator account draws on The New Yorker in 1947 and Christopher Gray’s 1994 column.

Photo credits for this page
  • Gramercy Park House hotel (c. 1875): Reproduced in Eugene E. Weise, M.D., A Tour of Historic Gramercy Park (Gramercy Park Block Association, May 7, 2006), p. 37.
  • The Gramercy beneath a rainbow and after dark: Gramercy Park Block Association archive (rainbow photograph signed TÉCHIN).
  • Corner exterior and carved terra-cotta faces: Photographs by Tom Miller, Daytonian in Manhattan (March 2019).
  • Entrance portico in May 2011: Photograph by Beyond My Ken, Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0).
  • June 24, 1882 hotel announcement and November 17, 1883 Charles A. Gerlach interview: Real Estate Record and Builders’ Guide (June 24, 1882, p. 620; November 17, 1883, p. 903), Avery Architectural & Fine Arts Library, Columbia University. 1882 issue 1883 issue
  • 34 and 36 Gramercy Park East in 1911: Real Estate Record and Builders’ Guide (November 25, 1911, p. 781), Avery Architectural & Fine Arts Library, Columbia University. Original issue
  • 1883 Otis Brothers hydraulic elevator notice: The American Architect and Building News (July 7, 1883, trade supplement). USModernist Library original scan at the Internet Archive
  • Hydraulic elevator cutaway diagram: Reproduced in Christopher Gray, “Streetscapes/34 Gramercy Park East; City’s Oldest Elevator System Being Replaced,” The New York Times, August 14, 1994.
  • George Peter Alexander Healy, Emma Cecilia Thursby (1879): Oil on canvas, The New York Historical (Accession 1944.17, Gift of the Estate of Ina Love Thursby). Collection record
  • Emma Thursby beside a parlor organ: Nineteenth-century cabinet portrait, public domain. Aranyozott kor
  • Gramercy Park fountain designed by Charles I. Berg (c. 1922): Photograph by Frances Benjamin Johnston, Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division (LC-DIG-ppmsca-16153). Collection record
  • Entrance vestibule stained glass and woodwork: Gramercy Park Block Association archive / History’s Homes.
  • James Cagney commemorative medallion at 34 Gramercy Park East: Photograph by Larry Gertner, Historical Marker Database (Plaque by the New York Landmarks Preservation Foundation).
  • Restored entrance portico, brownstone capital comparison, and turret slate and copper restoration: Courtesy of Walter B. Melvin Architects (2025).
  • James Cagney (c. 1930s) and Gregory Peck (1944): Studio publicity portraits, Wikimedia Commons (public domain).
  • Lucy Seaman Bainbridge: Portrait reproduced in Lucy Seaman Bainbridge, Yesterdays (New York: Fleming H. Revell Co., 1924), pp. 116–117. Wikimedia Commons record
  • Dr. William Seaman Bainbridge: Portrait reproduced in Louis Effingham de Forest, Ancestry of William Seaman Bainbridge (1950). Wikimedia Commons record
  • Margaret Hamilton and Judy Garland in The Wizard of Oz (MGM, 1939): Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer production still. Looking to God
  • Autographed portrait of Margaret Hamilton as the Wicked Witch of the West inscribed to Nicholas and Timothy Cohen: Collection of Timothy Cohen. The Wicked Witch Upstairs