5 Gramercy Park West
John Hone’s scrapbooks, a lost porch and its return to the western row.

A porch and a paper trail
The story of 5 Gramercy Park West begins at its front steps. Along the western walk of Gramercy Park, mid-nineteenth-century red-brick townhouses rise behind a continuous filigree of black cast-iron verandas and brownstone stoops that carry visitors from the shaded sidewalk into the parlor floor. At No. 5, that historic approach vanished in the 1920s when the house was subdivided into apartments and its porch and stoop were sheared away—leaving a ninety-year gap in the western row whose recovery became a celebrated neighborhood cause.
Behind the three-bay Greek Revival façade unfolded a rich sequence of New York lives: antebellum shipping merchant and Gramercy Park Trustee Eben B. Crocker; Wall Street stockbroker, New York Stock Exchange vice president, and Park Trustee John Hone, whose six volumes of personal scrapbooks at the New-York Historical Society preserve a Gilded Age world of dinners, voyages, and neighborhood stewardship; and twenty-first-century resident Alexander S. C. Rower, grandson of sculptor Alexander Calder and president of the Calder Foundation, who helped bring Calder’s monumental standing mobile Janey Waney into Gramercy Park in 2011 and spearheaded the 2013–2014 reconstruction of No. 5’s cast-iron porch and stoop.
At home beside the Park
A place in the west-side row
Greek Revival proportions and Trustee Eben B. Crocker
Erected between 1844 and 1850 as the first generation of brick-and-brownstone residences enclosed Samuel B. Ruggles’s private square, 5 Gramercy Park West is a classic three-bay Greek Revival townhouse rising four stories above a rusticated brownstone basement. Built to the same twenty-six-foot frontage and cornice height as its immediate neighbors at 3 and 4 Gramercy Park West, its warm red-brick façade derives its quiet authority from the measured rhythm of its six-over-six sash windows, rectangular stone lintels and sills, and bold bracketed and dentiled roof cornice.
By 1850, the newly completed townhouse was the residence of prominent Broadway shipping and commission merchant Eben B. Crocker (partner in the firm of Crocker & Warren) and his family. Actively involved in the governance of the planted enclosure across the street, Crocker was elected a Trustee of Gramercy Park in 1854, serving for twelve years through the Civil War era until 1866—the first of two Gramercy Park Trustees to make 5 Gramercy Park West his home.
Reading the streetscape between house and garden
When the New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission designated the Gramercy Park Historic District in September 1966, the commissioners emphasized that the beauty of Gramercy Park West lay in its collective harmony: five contiguous 1840s townhouses sharing a unified residential scale, warm brickwork, and ornamental ironwork answering the iron fence of the Park across the street.
As the July 2013 pre-restoration photograph makes immediately clear, the twentieth-century removal of No. 5’s high brownstone stoop and cast-iron veranda had left its plain brick front visibly recessed and detached from the elaborate porches of Nos. 4 and 3 to the north—setting the stage for one of the district’s most ambitious twenty-first-century restorations.
John Hone’s New York
Grandson of Commodore Perry, great-grandnephew of Mayor Philip Hone
In 1880, upon his marriage to Maria Cadwalader (c. 1841–1921)—of the military family of General Thomas McCall Cadwalader and Revolutionary War General John Cadwalader—thirty-five-year-old stockbroker John Hone (1844–1915) established his Manhattan residence at 5 Gramercy Park West, where he lived for the next thirty-five years.
Born on Broadway on December 14, 1844, to attorney John Hone III and Jane Perry Hone (and known in family records as John Hone Jr. or John Hone IV), he united two of nineteenth-century America’s most storied lineages. On his father’s side, he was the great-grandnephew of Mayor Philip Hone (1780–1851), the Whig patrician and Mayor of New York whose famous twenty-eight-volume manuscript diary chronicles the birth of modern Manhattan. On his mother’s side, he was the grandson of Commodore Matthew Calbraith Perry (1794–1858), the United States Navy commander who negotiated Japan’s 1854 treaty with the United States, and the nephew of financier August Belmont.
After enrolling at Columbia College in 1861, young John Hone left school at the outbreak of the Civil War to serve with the 7th Regiment of the New York State National Guard (receiving an honorary Bachelor of Arts degree from Columbia three decades later in 1894). Entering his uncle’s banking house of August Belmont & Co. in 1864, he founded his own Wall Street brokerage firm, John Hone & Co. (at 62 New Street), in 1869, serving for years as a Governor of the New York Stock Exchange and twice as its Vice President before retiring in 1907. With ties to Morristown and Red Bank, New Jersey, as well as Gramercy Park, he also served several terms on the New Jersey Democratic State Committee and as a delegate supporting Grover Cleveland at the 1892 Democratic National Convention.
Six scrapbooks of a Gilded Age life (1887–1911)
The most intimate portrait of life inside 5 Gramercy Park West survives at the New-York Historical Society, which holds the six large folio scrapbooks compiled by John Hone between 1887 and 1911 (MS 302). Preserving the ephemeral paper trail that most households discard after an evening out or an ocean voyage, Hone pasted into his albums engraved dinner invitations, handwritten French menus, Broadway theater and Metropolitan Opera programs, Manhattan Club and coaching-club memorabilia, typescript extracts from his great-granduncle Philip Hone’s diaries, and family photographs.
Together with his wife Maria and their daughter Hester Gouverneur Hone (who married Henry G. Bartol in 1907), Hone traveled across Europe, South America, and Asia—collecting Japanese menus, steamship passenger lists, and correspondence recalling his grandfather Commodore Perry’s legacy. John Hone died at 5 Gramercy Park West on March 21, 1915, at the age of seventy.
The Park beyond the gate
The 1906 Supreme Court victory over Gramercy Park’s tax assessment
Among the loose papers preserved inside John Hone’s scrapbooks are the legal records of a pivotal struggle for the survival of Gramercy Park itself. When the City of New York assessed the Park at $500,000 in 1903 and 1904 and then raised the assessment to $750,000 in 1905, raising the prospect of new annual levies on the surrounding lot owners, John Hone joined his fellow Trustees of Gramercy Park—Stuyvesant Fish of No. 19, James W. Pinchot of No. 2, Henry W. Poor, whose mansion stood on the site of today’s One Lexington Avenue, and James Henry Lane—in challenging the city in New York State Supreme Court.
As the Real Estate Record and Builders’ Guide reported on February 10, 1906, Justice Victor J. Dowling ruled in favor of Hone and the Trustees, holding that because Samuel B. Ruggles’s 1831 trust deed encumbered the Park land with perpetual easements for light, air, and recreation attached to the surrounding lots—whose own tax assessments already reflected the added value of facing the Park—the Park parcel itself could never be sold or built upon and therefore possessed only nominal standalone tax value.
Walter G. Jones’s 1914 elevator modernization
Four months before John Hone’s death, a building notice in the Real Estate Record and Builders’ Guide on November 14, 1914, recorded a proposal to make the house more accessible. Naming John Hone as owner and architect Walter G. Jones of 165 Broadway as designer, Plan No. 3933 called for a fireproof elevator shaft, a hand-hoist passenger elevator, and a galvanized-iron roof skylight inside 5 Gramercy Park West.
The porch disappears

The 1920s apartment conversion and loss of the veranda
After Maria Cadwalader Hone’s death in 1921, 5 Gramercy Park West followed the path of several neighboring townhouses during the 1920s housing boom: the single-family residence was sold to a real-estate corporation (5 Gramercy Park, Inc.) and subdivided into multiple apartments. In the course of lowering the entrance to the English-basement level, the builders demolished the house’s original high brownstone stoop and two-story cast-iron veranda—replacing the parlor doorway with a standard sash window and leaving the ground-floor entrance flush with the brick wall.
When Berenice Abbott photographed the western row on November 27, 1935, for her Federal Art Project series Changing New York, she framed the intact cast-iron porches and stoops of Nos. 3 and 4. Although catalogued as Gramercy Park, Nos. 3–5, the photograph shows the neighboring pair. It is the July 2013 view that shows No. 5’s lowered entrance.

Protected within the 1966 Historic District
Three decades later, on September 20, 1966, the New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission designated the Gramercy Park Historic District (LP-0251, followed by listing on the National Register of Historic Places in 1980). Even without its original porch, 5 Gramercy Park West was recognized as an integral member of the 1844–1850 western row—establishing the legal and historical framework that would eventually allow its missing porch to return.
A Calder across the street
Resident Alexander S. C. Rower and the loan of Janey Waney (2011)
In January 2004, 5 Gramercy Park West was acquired by Alexander S. C. Rower—grandson of American modernist sculptor Alexander Calder (1898–1976) and president of the Calder Foundation—who embarked on returning the multi-unit apartment building to a single-family townhouse.
On October 5, 2011, Rower’s stewardship bridged his front door and the garden across the street when a crane gently lowered Alexander Calder’s monumental 1969 red-painted steel standing mobile Janey Waney over the iron fence into the southeast quadrant of Gramercy Park. In their October 6, 2011 announcement, the Trustees of Gramercy Park expressed their gratitude to neighbor Alexander S. C. Rower and the Calder Foundation for making the loan possible—inaugurating a celebrated tradition of temporary outdoor sculpture installations inside the private park.
“A piece of the 20th century in the 19th century”
Rising vibrant and kinetic against the Park’s sycamores, gravel paths, and the Greek Revival brickwork surrounding the square, Janey Waney was clearly visible to every pedestrian strolling outside the Park’s iron railings. Welcoming the installation, Rower described his grandfather’s mobile as “a piece of the 20th century in the 19th century.” Apart from a temporary hiatus for European museum exhibitions in 2014, Janey Waney graced Gramercy Park for nearly a decade until August 2021.
Bringing back the porch
Neighborhood testimony before the Landmarks Commission (2013–2014)
Two years after Janey Waney arrived in the Park, Alexander S. C. Rower’s restoration of 5 Gramercy Park West reached its defining architectural milestone: an application to the Landmarks Preservation Commission to reconstruct the townhouse’s lost high brownstone stoop, parlor entrance, and two-story cast-iron veranda to harmonize with the surviving Alexander Jackson Davis porches at Nos. 3 and 4 next door.
At the Commission’s public hearing on July 16, 2013, Gramercy Park Block Association president Arlene Harrison testified in strong support on behalf of both the Block Association and the Trustees of Gramercy Park, reading a statement from Trustee the Reverend Dr. Thomas F. Pike pointing to historic photographs of the western row and calling the porch’s return “a gift for all the public to enjoy.” On August 13, 2013, the Landmarks Preservation Commission voted unanimously (8–0–0) to approve application 14-4222 for reconstruction of the porch and stoop. On August 12, 2014, it approved a front-façade amendment to Certificate of Appropriateness 15-1480 covering the window openings and masonry details.
Closing the ninety-year gap on Gramercy Park West
Compare the July 2013 pre-restoration photograph with the September 2022 view of the completed work, and the transformation of the western walk is unmistakable. Rising above a newly built brownstone stoop, forecourt iron fence, and gas-lit newel post lantern, the reconstructed two-story cast-iron veranda at 5 Gramercy Park West—cast with intricate foliate, scroll, and geometric fretwork panels and crowned by rooftop anthemion cresting—extends the rhythm of Nos. 3 and 4 down the block, closing a ninety-year gap in one of Manhattan’s most cherished nineteenth-century streetscapes.
Residents of Note
The People of Gramercy- Hester Gouverneur Hone BartolDaughter of John and Maria Cadwalader Hone; grew up at 5 Gramercy Park West and accompanied her parents on the international journeys documented in the Hone scrapbooks before marrying Henry G. Bartol in 1907
- Eben B. CrockerNineteenth-century New York shipping merchant (partner in Crocker & Warren on Broadway) and Trustee of Gramercy Park from 1854 to 1866; first documented resident of 5 Gramercy Park West from c. 1850
- John Hone (John Hone IV)Founder of Wall Street brokerage firm John Hone & Co., twice Vice President of the New York Stock Exchange, grandson of Commodore Matthew Calbraith Perry, great-grandnephew of Mayor Philip Hone, and Trustee of Gramercy Park (1844–1915); lived at 5 Gramercy Park West from 1880 until his death here on March 21, 1915
- Maria Cadwalader HoneSociety hostess, member of the Cadwalader military family, and wife of John Hone (c. 1841–1921); presided over the household at 5 Gramercy Park West from her marriage in April 1880 until 1915
- Walter G. JonesEarly twentieth-century New York architect at 165 Broadway; designed the November 1914 elevator and skylight modernization at 5 Gramercy Park West for owner John Hone
Building at a glance
Gramercy Park West · Between East 20th and East 21st Streets
The building record
- Address
- 5 Gramercy Park West (between East 20th and East 21st Streets; Manhattan Block 876, Lot 14)
- Historic names
- The Eben B. Crocker–John Hone House
- Built
- c. 1844–1850
- Architectural style
- Greek Revival red-brick and brownstone townhouse (three-bay front, four stories over an English basement, with reconstructed two-story cast-iron veranda and brownstone stoop)
- Original architect
- Unknown
- Documented alterations & restoration
- November 1914 (architect Walter G. Jones files plans for an elevator and skylight for John Hone) · 1920s (converted into apartments; original stoop and porch removed) · 2013–2016 (returned to single-family use; cast-iron porch and brownstone stoop reconstructed following LPC approval of application 14-4222 in 2013 and an amendment to Certificate of Appropriateness 15-1480 in 2014)
- Present use
- Single-family residence
- Park access & landmark status
- Deeded key privileges to Gramercy Park; within the 1966 NYC Gramercy Park Historic District (LP-0251) and 1980 National Register of Historic Places district
Over time
The Greek Revival house and Trustee Eben B. Crocker
Built as part of the five-house 1844–1850 western row, 5 Gramercy Park West becomes the residence by 1850 of Broadway shipping merchant Eben B. Crocker, who serves as a Trustee of Gramercy Park from 1854 to 1866.
John and Maria Cadwalader Hone’s residence
Stockbroker John Hone (1844–1915)—twice Vice President of the New York Stock Exchange, grandson of Commodore Matthew Calbraith Perry, and great-grandnephew of Mayor Philip Hone—and his bride Maria Cadwalader Hone move into 5 Gramercy Park West in 1880. Between 1887 and 1911, John compiles six volumes of scrapbooks here.
Defending Gramercy Park’s tax status
Serving as a Trustee of Gramercy Park alongside Stuyvesant Fish, James W. Pinchot, Henry W. Poor, and James Henry Lane, John Hone helps win a landmark New York Supreme Court ruling protecting the private park from standalone commercial tax assessments.
An elevator for John Hone
Architect Walter G. Jones files plans in November 1914 to install an interior passenger elevator and skylight at 5 Gramercy Park West; John Hone dies in the house four months later on March 21, 1915.
Apartment conversion and loss of the porch
Sold after Maria Cadwalader Hone’s death in 1921, the house is subdivided into apartments in the 1920s and stripped of its high stoop and cast-iron porch, leaving a gap beside the intact verandas that Berenice Abbott photographs in November 1935.
Gramercy Park Historic District
The New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission designates the Gramercy Park Historic District, protecting the five 1840s townhouses of Gramercy Park West.
Alexander S. C. Rower and Calder’s Janey Waney
With the assistance of 5 Gramercy Park West owner Alexander S. C. Rower, president of the Calder Foundation, Alexander Calder’s 1969 standing mobile Janey Waney is installed inside Gramercy Park.
Reconstructing the cast-iron porch and stoop
Supported by testimony from the Gramercy Park Block Association and the Trustees of Gramercy Park, the Landmarks Preservation Commission approves the reconstruction of No. 5’s two-story cast-iron veranda and brownstone stoop in August 2013 and a façade amendment in August 2014. The rebuilt porch restores the continuous sweep of ironwork along the western row.
Turning points
- 1844–1850 The Greek Revival row & Trustee Eben B. Crocker
- 1880–1915 Stockbroker John Hone’s residence & scrapbooks
- Feb. 1906 Hone & the Trustees defend the Park’s tax status
- Nov. 1914 Architect Walter G. Jones’s elevator modernization
- 1920s–1935 Apartment conversion & loss of the original porch
- Oct. 2011 Alexander S. C. Rower & Calder’s Janey Waney
- 2013–2022 Reconstructing the cast-iron porch & stoop
Sources cited
- New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission · 1966.
- John B. Pine · 1921.The Story of Gramercy Park, 1831–1921 (New York: Gramercy Park Association, 1921), page 52: recording Eben B. Crocker’s service as a Trustee of Gramercy Park from 1854 to 1866.
- New York Historical · John Hone scrapbooks, MS 302.
- Contemporary biography · 1914.
- The New York Times · March 22, 1915.“John Hone Is Dead; Long an Invalid; Grandson of Commodore Perry Dies in His Home, 5 Gramercy Park.”
- Real Estate Record and Builders’ Guide · February 10, 1906.
- Real Estate Record and Builders’ Guide · November 14, 1914.
- Berenice Abbott · The New York Public Library · 1935.
- Arlene Harrison · July 16, 2013.
- Gramercy Park Block Association · July 2013.
- Landmarks Preservation Commission · August 13, 2013.
- Landmarks Preservation Commission · August 12, 2014.
- Trustees of Gramercy Park · October 6, 2011.
- Observer · October 2011.
- GPBA · Calder archive.
- Billy Wilson · September 22, 2022.
Photo credits for this page
- Reconstructed cast-iron porch at 5 Gramercy Park West alongside 4 Gramercy Park West (September 22, 2022): Photograph by Billy Wilson, via Wikimedia Commons / Flickr (CC BY-NC 2.0).
- 5, 4, and 3 Gramercy Park West prior to the porch reconstruction (July 2013): Photograph by Alex Nguyen, Gramercy Park Block Association archive.
- Gramercy Park West, Nos. 3–5 (November 27, 1935): Photograph by Berenice Abbott, Changing New York (Federal Art Project / WPA); The New York Public Library, Miriam and Ira D. Wallach Division of Art, Prints and Photographs (Image ID 482721).