13 Gramercy Park South
The house that opened to the light.

Behind the broad windows
An Olympic polo champion’s silver trophies inspected after dinner by Ignacy Jan Paderewski. A turn-of-the-century book of verse printed on vellum. A British Arts-and-Crafts studio and little theatre bathed in northern light behind a wall of glass. Across nearly two centuries on the south walk of Gramercy Park, 13 Gramercy Park South has lived several distinct New York lives without ever surrendering its twenty-six-foot footprint.
Completed in 1847 as an Italianate brownstone for Long Island Rail Road treasurer and city alderman Moses Maynard Jr., the house sheltered successive single-family households before silk manufacturer and polo pioneer John Elliot Cowdin commissioned architect Adolph Mertin in 1916 to strip away the brownstone stoop and open the façade with sweeping studio windows—creating the sunlit rooms where Constance Smedley and Maxwell Armfield launched their Greenleaf Theatre Studio and where author and broadcaster John W. Vandercook later made his home.
A house in the first generation
Alderman Moses Maynard Jr. and an 1847 Italianate brownstone
When 13 Gramercy Park South (also numbered 114 East 20th Street) was completed in 1847, Samuel B. Ruggles’s sixteen-year-old private square had just begun to take on its mature residential form. Three years after the Trustees commenced the first formal landscaping of the fenced garden in 1844, the new residence rose four stories above a rusticated English basement on a lot measuring 26 feet 3 inches wide by 114 feet deep. Dressed in smooth brownstone in the early Italianate style and equipped from the outset with indoor running water from the newly opened Croton Aqueduct, the house was approached by a high brownstone stoop leading to tall parlor French doors that opened onto a wrought-iron balcony overlooking the Park. In the 1877 Frank Leslie’s Illustrated Newspaper engraving of a torchlight serenade for former governor Samuel J. Tilden next door at No. 15, No. 13 stands immediately to the right—sharing the tall narrow window bays, pedimented lintels, and deep bracketed cornice of its nineteenth-century neighbors.

The house’s first resident owner was Moses Maynard Jr. (c. 1808–1855), a prominent Whig merchant who served both as Secretary and Treasurer of the Long Island Rail Road and as New York City Alderman for the Eighteenth Ward. Civic business regularly crossed his Gramercy threshold: in May 1849, when the Common Council weighed widening Dey Street downtown, official municipal notices directed property owners to deliver their written objections directly to Alderman Maynard “at his house, No. 13 Gramercy Park.” Maynard lived here until his death on July 30, 1855. His funeral was held in the parlor.
The Willett burglary in stolen shoes and the Work household (1860–1892)
By 1860, 13 Gramercy Park South had become the family home of New York attorney Edward M. Willett (partner in the law firm of Willett & Greig) and his wife, Amelia Ann Stephens Willett—sister of the celebrated diplomat, explorer, and Columbia College alumnus John Lloyd Stephens, whose expeditions in Central America and Yucatán had introduced Maya civilization to the nineteenth-century reading public.
In December 1868, the Willetts’ house figured in one of Gramercy Park’s most memorable Gilded Age crime stories. On the night of December 9, 1868, a bold burglar named Thomas F. Barton slipped into 13 Gramercy Park South and made off with silverware, jewelry, and a comfortable pair of Edward Willett’s shoes. Six nights later, on December 15, Barton pushed his luck by breaking into the mansion of Democratic leader Samuel J. Tilden next door at 15 Gramercy Park South. Caught red-handed inside Tilden’s house and hauled before the magistrate, Barton was discovered to be wearing Edward Willett’s stolen shoes on his feet—evidence that helped send him to Sing Sing State Prison for seven years.
After nearly a quarter century on the square, Edward and Amelia Willett sold 13 Gramercy Park South in April 1884—expressly conveying the house “with right to use Park”—for $50,000 to Emma Marbury Work, elder sister of literary and theatrical agent Elisabeth Marbury and wife of Wall Street stockbroker Frank Work Jr. The deed named Emma as the buyer, subject to a $20,000 mortgage. Following the 1891 failure of Work’s brokerage firm, Work, O’Keeffe & Co., the Works sold 13 Gramercy Park South on July 9, 1892, for $70,000 to silk manufacturer John Elliot Cowdin.

Polo trophies, poetry, and Paderewski
John Elliot Cowdin, Olympic polo, and Paderewski’s pun
With the arrival of thirty-four-year-old John Elliot Cowdin (1858–1941) and his wife, Gertrude Cheever Cowdin (1862–1908), in the summer of 1892, 13 Gramercy Park South became a crossroads of commerce, international sport, music, and letters. The son of prominent silk merchant and New York Assemblyman Elliot Christopher Cowdin, John Elliot Cowdin had graduated from Harvard in 1879 and was a senior partner in Johnson, Cowdin & Co., one of America’s largest manufacturers of silk ribbons, with offices on Spring Street and mills in Paterson, New Jersey. Outside business hours, he was one of the founding giants of American polo: a ten-goal player at the Rockaway Hunting Club and Meadow Brook, he helped win the inaugural U.S. Open Polo Championship and competed at the 1900 Paris Olympic Games. A member as well of The Players nearby at No. 16, he and Gertrude hosted lavish musical and society dinners in the dining room of No. 13.
Symphony conductor Walter Damrosch—who dined at 13 Gramercy Park South with his wife Margaret Blaine Damrosch, across-the-Park neighbor Henry W. Poor (of One Lexington Avenue), and the legendary Polish pianist Ignacy Jan Paderewski—left a charming memoir of the Cowdins’ table in My Musical Life. After dinner, as the gentlemen gathered around the sideboard to admire the array of silver cups Cowdin had won on the polo field, Damrosch remarked: “How differently two men achieve greatness! Mr. Cowdin wins his prizes by playing polo, and you, Mr. Paderewski, win yours by playing solo.” Without missing a beat, Paderewski replied: “Notice how near akin we are after all—for Mr. Cowdin is a dear old soul who plays polo, while I am a dear old Pole who plays solo!”
Gertrude Cheever Cowdin’s vellum presswork and a notable generation
While her husband collected silver trophies on horseback, Gertrude Cheever Cowdin pursued the quiet art of fine printing and book collecting. In 1900, she collaborated with master Maine printer Thomas Bird Mosher to privately co-publish George Parsons Lathrop’s poem The Casket of Opals in an exquisite limited edition of just fifteen copies printed on pure vellum and bound in flexible vellum wrappers with brown silk ties. A surviving presentation copy inscribed to bibliographer Frederic Lacy preserves her handwritten letter on 13 Gramercy Park stationery, thanking him for cataloging her personal library.
Inside 13 Gramercy Park South, John and Gertrude Cowdin raised three children who left their own marks on early twentieth-century history. Their daughter, Ethel Cowdin, made her society debut at a large afternoon reception at No. 13 on December 14, 1905, and was married in the parlor to Charles Morgan Jr. in March 1910. Their elder son, Elliot Christopher Cowdin II (1886–1933), enlisted in the French air service in World War I, became one of the seven founding American pilots of the legendary Lafayette Escadrille in April 1916, and was the first American aviator awarded France’s Médaille Militaire after shooting down a German plane over Verdun. Their younger son, John Cheever Cowdin (1889–1960), became an eight-goal international polo star and Hollywood financier who served for a decade as chairman of Universal Pictures—immortalized affectionately by Groucho Marx as the lawyer “J. Cheever Loophole” in the 1939 comedy At the Circus.
The brownstone opens to the light
A wall of studio glass beside the National Arts Club
Following Gertrude Cheever Cowdin’s death in Paris in May 1908—her body was brought home aboard the liner La Touraine for a funeral in the parlor of 13 Gramercy Park South—and John Elliot Cowdin’s remarriage in June 1912 to Madeleine Knowlton, Cowdin retained the property he had owned since 1892. In January 1916, he commissioned the conversion of the twenty-room single-family house into studio apartments.
To design the conversion (filed as Plan No. 142 in January 1916), Cowdin commissioned Berlin-born, Cooper Union–educated architect Adolph Mertin (1875–1963), who the following year also designed the studio conversion and street-level Ionic portico of 1 Gramercy Park West across the square. Mertin’s design was a bold modernist departure from the dark Victorian masonry next door at the National Arts Club. Stripping away the 1847 brownstone façade, the high stoop, and the heavy bracketed cornice, Mertin raised the roof tier, installed an elevator, and refaced the five-story front in smooth, pale cream stucco that acts as a sunlit frame around vast expanses of glass. Across the upper four stories, much of the façade is occupied by broad multi-pane tripartite studio casements fronted by slender wrought-iron Juliet balconies, paired in the narrower adjoining bay with tall tripartite sash windows—filling the upper floors with northern light and unobstructed views of Gramercy Park.
The sculpted putto over the threshold and the first apartment tenants
At street level, Mertin balanced the spare geometry of the upper studio windows with a Neo-Renaissance flourish above the lowered English-basement doorway. Recessed within a broad, round-arched molding decorated with scrolling acanthus foliage and flanked by wrought-iron coaching lanterns, a circular oculus opens directly above the black paneled front door—housing a three-dimensional white sculpture of a seated child (putto) absorbed in an open book.
By July 1916, real-estate brokers Pease & Elliman were advertising the nearly completed apartments—arranged as three-room-and-bath suites with modern kitchenettes renting for $1,700 a year. Fittingly, one of the very first tenants to move into the remodeled building in 1917 was the owner’s decorated aviator son, Elliot C. Cowdin II, newly returned from flying with the Lafayette Escadrille in France. Other initial residents included Hendrick Suydam and sugar refiner Henry Lee Hobart and his wife, Marie Elizabeth Jefferys Hobart (1860–1928), the pioneering Episcopal playwright whose St. Agnes Mystery Plays were staged across the United States.

A little theatre behind the windows
Constance Smedley, Maxwell Armfield, and the Greenleaf Players
Mertin’s newly installed studio windows immediately attracted two of Britain’s most imaginative proponents of the Arts and Crafts movement. In October 1916, a lease at 13 Gramercy Park South was taken by English tempera painter, illustrator, and stage designer Maxwell Armfield (1881–1972) and his wife, dramatist, novelist, and women’s club pioneer Constance Smedley (1876–1941), who had founded the International Lyceum Club in London in 1904 for professional women in the arts and sciences.
Inside their apartment at 13 Gramercy Park South, the couple established the American headquarters of their experimental performance company and school, the Greenleaf Theatre Studio and Greenleaf Players. A surviving four-page illustrated prospectus preserved in the Smithsonian’s Archives of American Art—adorned on its cover with a classical dancing figure and giving the studio’s address as 13 Gramercy Park—invited New York students and performers to courses in rhythmic movement, poetic diction, stage design, costume color harmony, and modern “minstrelsy,” uniting visual art, music, and drama in an intimate domestic theatre.
Painting Manhattan and Gramercy Park from the studio casements
Archival photographs of the couple’s studio at 13 Gramercy Park South—studied by art historian Grace Brockington in British Art Studies—show how Mertin’s architecture served their dual life as painters and theatre makers. In the main room, Windsor chairs, a round worktable, and a brick fireplace were arranged on parquet floors that could be cleared for rehearsals and intimate performances, while along the northern wall, Mertin’s multi-pane studio windows framed the winter branches of Gramercy Park.
In the foreground of the studio photograph stands a tall wooden easel holding one of Armfield’s tempera paintings of New York’s soaring skyscrapers. Smedley researched international folk tales at the New York Public Library for her children’s books, while Armfield painted the city—including his architectural canvas Gramercy Park, with its iron fence, trees, and townhouses seen from above. In the spring of 1918, the couple traveled west to California, where they continued teaching and making art.
A changed house in a protected square
Explorer and broadcaster John W. Vandercook between the wars
Throughout the 1920s and 1930s, the sunlit apartments behind Mertin’s windows continued to draw writers and actors. Among the most colorful interwar residents of 13 Gramercy Park South was London-born American author, tropical explorer, and radio journalist John Womack Vandercook (1902–1963), the son of United Press Associations co-founder and first president John Filkins Vandercook. Having trekked through the rainforests of Suriname, Liberia, New Guinea, and Fiji, young Vandercook lived at 13 Gramercy Park South during the late 1920s when he published his acclaimed study of Suriname’s Maroon communities, Tom-Tom (1926), and his international best-seller Black Majesty: The Life of Christophe, King of Haiti (1928)—returning to reside at No. 13 again in 1938 with his bride, Jane Perry Vandercook, as he became one of NBC Radio’s signature wartime news commentators.
Landmark designation (1966) and the cooperative today
On September 20, 1966, the New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission designated the Gramercy Park Historic District (LP-0251, followed by listing on the National Register of Historic Places in 1980). In their designation report, the commissioners specifically highlighted how nineteenth-century townhouses like 13 Gramercy Park South that had been sensitively remodeled during the early twentieth-century studio movement contributed to the architectural vitality and human scale of the square.
Converted to cooperative ownership in 1985 and reconfigured in 1995 into seven spacious residences, 13 Gramercy Park South remains a striking visual bridge along the southern walk: flanked by the russet brownstone gothic bays of the National Arts Club at Nos. 14–15 and the red-brick Oakley House at 12 Gramercy Park South, its pale stucco wall, sweeping studio casements, and quiet reading putto above the door celebrate the year an 1847 townhouse opened itself to the northern light.
Residents of Note
The People of Gramercy- Maxwell ArmfieldEnglish Arts-and-Crafts tempera painter, illustrator, and stage designer (1881–1972); lived, painted, and co-directed the Greenleaf Theatre Studio at 13 Gramercy Park South with Constance Smedley from 1916 to 1918
- Elliot Christopher Cowdin IIWorld War I combat aviator, one of the seven founding American pilots of the Lafayette Escadrille, and the first American pilot awarded France’s Médaille Militaire (1886–1933); grew up at 13 Gramercy Park South and occupied one of its newly remodeled apartments in 1917
- Gertrude Cheever CowdinBibliophile, fine-press patron, and co-publisher with Thomas Bird Mosher of George Parsons Lathrop’s vellum edition of The Casket of Opals (1862–1908); mistress of 13 Gramercy Park South from 1892 until her death in 1908
- John Cheever CowdinInternational eight-goal polo star, financier, and chairman of Universal Pictures from 1936 to 1946 (1889–1960); grew up at 13 Gramercy Park South
- John Elliot CowdinHarvard-educated silk-ribbon manufacturer (Johnson, Cowdin & Co.), ten-goal American polo pioneer, 1900 Olympic medalist, and member of The Players (1858–1941); owned 13 Gramercy Park South from 1892 to the 1920s and commissioned its 1916 studio conversion
- Moses Maynard Jr.New York City Alderman for the Eighteenth Ward and Secretary and Treasurer of the Long Island Rail Road (c. 1808–1855); first resident owner of 13 Gramercy Park South from its completion in 1847 until his death here in July 1855
- Adolph MertinBerlin-born, Cooper Union–trained New York architect (1875–1963); designed the 1916 studio-apartment transformation and sculpted Neo-Renaissance entrance of 13 Gramercy Park South as well as the 1917 conversion of 1 Gramercy Park West
- Constance SmedleyBritish dramatist, novelist, founder of the International Lyceum Club, and co-director of the Greenleaf Theatre Studio at 13 Gramercy Park South from 1916 to 1918 (1876–1941)
- John Womack VandercookBest-selling author of Black Majesty and Tom-Tom, tropical explorer, and NBC radio news commentator (1902–1963); lived at 13 Gramercy Park South in the late 1920s and again in 1938
Building at a glance
The Maynard–Cowdin House · Built 1847 · Remodeled by Adolph Mertin, 1916
The building record
- Address
- 13 Gramercy Park South (also 114 East 20th Street; Manhattan Block 875, Lot 73)
- Historic names
- The Moses Maynard Jr. House (1847) · The John Elliot Cowdin House (1892–1916)
- Built
- 1847 (for Alderman and Long Island Rail Road treasurer Moses Maynard Jr.)
- Original architect
- Unknown
- 1916 studio conversion
- Architect Adolph Mertin (1875–1963), Plan No. 142 (filed January 1916 for owner John Elliot Cowdin)
- Architecture
- Five-story residence (26 ft. 3 in. × 114 ft. lot) originally built as a four-story-and-basement Italianate brownstone; remodeled in 1916 with a pale stucco façade, monumental multi-pane studio casement windows, wrought-iron Juliet balconies, and a round-arched Neo-Renaissance entrance framing a sculpted putto reading a book
- Present use
- Seven-unit residential cooperative (converted to a cooperative in 1985; reconfigured into seven residences in 1995)
- Historical associations
- Moses Maynard Jr. · Edward M. & Amelia Stephens Willett · Frank Work Jr. & Emma Marbury Work · John Elliot & Gertrude Cheever Cowdin · Elliot C. Cowdin II & J. Cheever Cowdin · Constance Smedley & Maxwell Armfield (Greenleaf Theatre Studio) · John W. Vandercook
- Park access & landmark status
- Deeded key privileges to Gramercy Park; within the 1966 NYC Gramercy Park Historic District (LP-0251) and 1980 National Register of Historic Places district
Over time
The Moses Maynard Jr. brownstone
Built in 1847 with a four-story Italianate brownstone front, high stoop, and Croton running water, 13 Gramercy Park South serves as the residence of 18th Ward Alderman and Long Island Rail Road treasurer Moses Maynard Jr. until his death here on July 30, 1855.
The Edward M. Willett household and the stolen-shoes burglary
Attorney Edward M. Willett and Amelia Ann Stephens Willett (sister of Maya explorer John Lloyd Stephens) make No. 13 their home; in December 1868, burglar Thomas F. Barton steals Willett’s shoes from No. 13 and is caught six nights later wearing them inside Samuel J. Tilden’s house next door.
Frank Work Jr. and Emma Marbury Work
Willett conveys 13 Gramercy Park South (“with right to use Park”) for $50,000 to Emma Marbury Work, wife of stockbroker Frank Work Jr. The Works reside here until selling the house to John Elliot Cowdin for $70,000 in July 1892.
John Elliot and Gertrude Cheever Cowdin
Silk-ribbon manufacturer and polo player John Elliot Cowdin and bibliophile Gertrude Cheever Cowdin host musical dinners with Walter Damrosch and Ignacy Jan Paderewski and raise aviator Elliot C. Cowdin II and polo star J. Cheever Cowdin. Gertrude co-publishes a vellum edition of The Casket of Opals with Thomas Bird Mosher in 1900; after her death in 1908, John retains the house until its studio conversion.
Adolph Mertin’s studio-apartment conversion
Commissioned by John Elliot Cowdin, architect Adolph Mertin removes the 1847 brownstone stoop, installs an elevator and raised fifth story, and reclads the front with pale stucco, multi-pane studio casements, and a sculpted reading putto over the street-level entrance.
Constance Smedley and Maxwell Armfield’s Greenleaf Studio
British painter Maxwell Armfield and dramatist Constance Smedley lease a studio apartment at No. 13, operating their experimental Greenleaf Theatre Studio and painting views of Manhattan and Gramercy Park.
Author and broadcaster John W. Vandercook
Explorer, NBC radio commentator, and best-selling author of Black Majesty (1928) John Womack Vandercook makes his New York home at 13 Gramercy Park South.
Historic District protection and seven-unit cooperative
Designated within the Gramercy Park Historic District on September 20, 1966, the building converts to a residential cooperative in 1985 and is reconfigured into seven cooperative residences in 1995.
No. 13 through the years
- 1847 · Moses Maynard Jr.’s Italianate brownstone rises
- 1868 & 1884 · The Willett shoe burglary & the Work purchase
- 1892–1915 · Polo champion John Elliot Cowdin & Paderewski
- Jan.–July 1916 · Architect Adolph Mertin’s studio façade
- 1916–1918 · Constance Smedley & Maxwell Armfield’s Greenleaf Studio
- 1920s–1938 · Author & broadcaster John W. Vandercook
- 1966 & 1985 · Historic District protection & cooperative
Sources cited
- New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission. Gramercy Park Historic District designation report, LP-0251, September 20, 1966.
- Tom Miller. “The Unrecognizable 1847 Moses Maynard, Jr. House—13 Gramercy Park So.” Daytonian in Manhattan, January 24, 2020. Early house, Maynard household, and architectural history.
- Real Estate Record and Builders’ Guide, April 5, 1884, p. 349. Willett–Work conveyance.
- Biographical Directory of the State of New York, 1900, p. 86. John Elliot Cowdin entry.
- Walter Damrosch. My Musical Life, chapter XI, pp. 147–148. Dinner at the Cowdins’ Gramercy Park home; electronic edition, Project Gutenberg.
- Philip R. Bishop, The Mosher Press, Bishop Collection. The Casket of Opals (1900), Gertrude Cowdin’s presentation copy and letter.
- Real Estate Record and Builders’ Guide, January 22, 1916, p. 156. Adolph Mertin alteration filing, Plan No. 142.
- Real Estate Record and Builders’ Guide, July 1, 1916, p. 21. Pease & Elliman announcement of the apartment conversion.
- Real Estate Record and Builders’ Guide, October 14, 1916, p. 540. Rental to Maxwell Armfield.
- Archives of American Art, Smithsonian Institution. Greenleaf Theatre brochure, circa 1918, collection AAA.greethea.
- Grace Brockington. “Beyond London & the War,” Theatres of War, British Art Studies, issue 11, March 2019. Greenleaf Players and studio photographs.
- The New York Times (July 31, 1855, obituary of Moses Maynard Jr. at 13 Gramercy Park; December 17, 1868, burglary of Edward M. Willett’s and Samuel J. Tilden’s residences) and The Evening Telegram (July 9, 1892, sale of 13 Gramercy Park by Frank Work Jr. to John E. Cowdin for $70,000).
- New York City Department of City Planning & Department of Finance. Municipal property and cooperative records for 13 Gramercy Park South / 114 East 20th Street (Manhattan Block 875, Lot 73).
Photo credits for this page
- Exterior view of 13 Gramercy Park South (114 East 20th Street): Photograph by Tom Miller (2020), Daytonian in Manhattan.
- Maxwell Armfield and Constance Smedley’s Greenleaf Studio at 13 Gramercy Park South (c. 1916–1918): Reproduced in Grace Brockington, “Beyond London & the War,” British Art Studies, Issue 11 (March 2019), Figure 9.
- Torchlight serenade for Governor Samuel J. Tilden showing 13 Gramercy Park South at right (October 1877 wood engraving): Frank Leslie’s Illustrated Newspaper (1877); Irma and Paul Milstein Division, The New York Public Library.
- Detail of Adolph Mertin’s 1916 arched entrance and sculpted figure at 13 Gramercy Park South: Photograph by Tom Miller (2020), Daytonian in Manhattan.