12 Gramercy Park South
A judge’s house, an artists’ studio, and the Count’s hiding place.

A respectable address makes the news
In July 1922, a photograph of the red-brick and studio-windowed façade of 12 Gramercy Park South appeared on newspaper front pages as far away as the Pacific Northwest. Beneath headlines announcing the recovery of $100,000 in stolen Wall Street securities from the $2.4 million Leonard Street mail-truck robbery, reporters marveled that the loot had been stashed in an exclusive apartment house overlooking Gramercy Park, inside the rooms of an impeccably dressed tenant known to his neighbors as “The Count.”
The sensational contrast worked precisely because respectability had such deep roots at 12 Gramercy Park South. Built around 1847–1848 as the residence of Chief Justice Thomas Jackson Oakley of the New York Superior Court, the house on the southern walk subsequently sheltered a Gilded Age stockbroker’s debutante daughter, the boisterous 1910s studio of magazine illustrators Herb Roth and Ray Rohn, and a century of apartment life behind its rare Egyptian Revival doorway.
A house for the new square
Samuel B. Ruggles’s covenant and an 1847–1848 townhouse
The architectural character of the block containing 12 Gramercy Park South (also numbered 112 East 20th Street) had been set out in its founding deed. On December 17, 1831, when Samuel B. Ruggles and his wife, Mary Rosalie Ruggles, conveyed the ground of Gramercy Park to five trustees for the benefit of the surrounding building lots, the founding indenture stipulated that every lot facing the square be improved with substantial brick or stone residences at least three stories high.

Erected around 1847–1848 on a lot measuring 26 feet 8 inches wide by 92 feet deep, 12 Gramercy Park South rose as a four-story-and-basement townhouse in the late Greek Revival style, originally approached from the East 20th Street sidewalk by a high stone stoop leading to the parlor floor and crowned at the roofline by a bold bracketed and modillioned cornice.
Egyptian Revival palm-leaf capitals at the doorway
Pause on the sidewalk before the entrance of No. 12 today, and one of the most distinctive carved stone doorways on Gramercy Park comes into focus. Flanking the recessed black paneled double doors and their arching wrought-iron lantern bracket stand two deeply fluted limestone pilasters. Rather than terminating in conventional Greek Ionic scrolls or Corinthian acanthus leaves, their capitals flare outward with carved Egyptian Revival palm-frond ornament beneath a heavy, horizontally banded entablature and cavetto cornice.
When the townhouse was remodeled into studio apartments in the early twentieth century, the original doorway surround was moved from the old parlor threshold and reinstalled at street level—preserving a rare piece of antebellum architectural theater while opening the upper façade with expansive multi-paned studio windows looking north into the trees of Gramercy Park.

The judge’s address
Chief Justice Thomas Jackson Oakley and Matilda Cruger Oakley
The jurist who gave 12 Gramercy Park South its historic name brought one of early nineteenth-century America’s most distinguished legal careers to the square. Born in Dutchess County, New York, in 1783 and graduated from Yale College in 1801, Thomas Jackson Oakley (1783–1857) served two terms in the United States House of Representatives (1813–1815 and 1827–1828) and succeeded Martin Van Buren as Attorney General of the State of New York in 1819.
In February 1824, Oakley appeared opposite Daniel Webster as counsel for Aaron Ogden before Chief Justice John Marshall and the United States Supreme Court to argue Gibbons v. Ogden—the landmark constitutional case that established federal authority over interstate commerce and steamboat navigation. Appointed a judge of the Superior Court of the City of New York upon its creation in 1828, Oakley was elected Chief Justice of the Superior Court in October 1847, and made his home at 12 Gramercy Park South around 1847–1848 with his second wife, Matilda Caroline Cruger Oakley (1809–1891).
During his final decade on the bench, Chief Justice Oakley lived at 12 Gramercy Park South and presided over major civil cases (including the sensational 1851–1852 Edwin Forrest divorce trial) until his death at 12 Gramercy Park South on May 11, 1857, at the age of seventy-three.

From family mansion to select apartments and the Adams purchase
Following Judge Oakley’s funeral at 12 Gramercy Park South, his widow Matilda Cruger Oakley retained ownership of the property for more than three decades. During the post–Civil War years, as neighboring houses along the south side adapted to new uses, No. 12 briefly accommodated annex classes for Henrietta B. Haines’s famed school for young ladies at No. 10, and by the mid-1870s was leased to Mrs. S. A. Curtis, who advertised handsomely furnished suites with private dining tables for families wintering in town. In 1889, two years before Matilda Oakley’s death, the townhouse was acquired by brush-manufacturing magnate John J. Adams (head of J. J. Adams & Co.), who leased the residence to families of New York society.
The Kendall years
William Beals Kendall and Katharine Kendall’s 1905 debut
At the turn of the twentieth century, 12 Gramercy Park South was the residence of prominent Wall Street stockbroker William Beals Kendall (born 1855), his wife, Kate Varnum Whitney Kendall, and their children, William Beals Kendall Jr., Katharine Varnum Kendall, and Marjorie S. Kendall. Kendall was a member of the New York Stock Exchange and the Union, Players, and Country Clubs.
On the afternoon and evening of December 27, 1905, the Kendalls threw open the drawing rooms of 12 Gramercy Park South to introduce their elder daughter, Katharine Varnum Kendall, to New York society. Beginning with a formal afternoon reception at No. 12 overlooking Gramercy Park, the debut celebration continued with a theater party at the Criterion Theatre on Broadway and concluded with a late-night supper and cotillion at Sherry’s on Fifth Avenue.
An October 1907 runaway wedding at St. Mary the Virgin
Less than two years after her debut, Katharine Kendall put 12 Gramercy Park South back into the society columns. On October 10, 1907, while her parents were away at their country house, Katharine married young Harvard man and Pittsburgh steel heir Archibald Marshall Denny at the Church of St. Mary the Virgin on West 46th Street, dispatching a telegram afterward to inform her parents.
Although front-page reporters from New York to Pittsburgh initially portrayed the ceremony as a forbidden elopement, William Beals Kendall issued a clarification in The New York Times three days later: the family approved of young Denny, who had left Harvard to enter the steel business in Pittsburgh, and had merely counselled the couple to wait another year before marrying.

Drawing boards and deadlines
Studio windows facing the northern light
In the early twentieth century, 12 Gramercy Park South underwent the architectural transformation that gave the five-story red-brick façade its modern studio profile. Removing the nineteenth-century brownstone stoop and resetting Judge Oakley’s Egyptian Revival doorway surround at street level, the builders opened adjoining bays of the upper façade into broad, multi-paned casement windows fronted by wrought-iron balconies—bringing northern light into rooms used by painters and illustrators. By February 1916, when brokers Pease & Elliman leased Miss G. Lyons Whitney’s furnished apartment in the building to J. Ross Tilford, No. 12 had become an established apartment address.
Herb Roth, Ray Rohn, and the Great Whisker Contest of 1916
Among the working artists who set up their drawing boards behind those tall north windows during the First World War era were two newspaper and magazine cartoonists: Herb Roth (1887–1953) and Ray Rohn (1888–1935). Born in San Francisco, Herb Roth had joined Joseph Pulitzer’s New York World as an editorial and Sunday supplement illustrator—contributing as well to Life, Judge, and later The New Yorker, and later collaborating with H. T. Webster on the beloved comic strip The Timid Soul (featuring Caspar Milquetoast). His roommate at 12 Gramercy Park South, Philadelphia-born Ray Rohn, was a prolific staff cartoonist for Judge, Puck, Collier’s, and The Saturday Evening Post.
In July 1916, Green Book Magazine published a two-part photographic glimpse into their circle: one snapshot showed Rohn at his tilted drawing table inside the studio sketching a young child model, while the companion portrait showed Roth lounging outdoors alongside poet and McClure’s editor Charles Hanson Towne and fellow illustrator Rea Irvin (who nine years later became the first art editor of The New Yorker and drew its monocled mascot, Eustace Tilley).
In March 1916, Cartoons Magazine reported under the headline “The Great Whisker Contest Is On” that roommates Roth and Rohn had entered into a solemn $50 wager—with syndicated Broadway columnist O. O. McIntyre holding the stakes—swearing not to shave their faces until one of them was arrested by the police on suspicion of being an anarchist or bomb-thrower, and taking their increasingly conspicuous beards into restaurants and theaters.
The Count of Gramercy Park
Gerald Chapman, “Dutch” Anderson, and the $2.4 million heist
In 1922, 12 Gramercy Park South became an unexpected setting in a federal mail-robbery investigation. On the night of October 24, 1921, at Broadway and Leonard Street in Lower Manhattan, notorious “Gentleman Bandit” Gerald Chapman (1887–1926) and his Danish-born partner George “Dutch” Anderson ambushed a United States Mail truck at gunpoint, escaping with $2.4 million in negotiable bonds, currency, and registered securities in the largest mail robbery in U.S. history up to that time.
The investigation led postal inspectors to Chapman and Anderson, who were arrested in New York on July 3, 1922. The case also reached Edward J. Bryce, a tenant at 12 Gramercy Park South whose polished appearance and manner had earned him the neighborhood name “The Count.”
$100,000 in stolen loot behind the studio windows (July 1922)
When federal postal inspectors raided Bryce’s apartment at 12 Gramercy Park South in the first week of July 1922, they uncovered $100,000 of the stolen Leonard Street mail securities concealed inside the rooms. As wire-service photographs of 12 Gramercy Park South were syndicated to newspapers across the nation—including the front page of Oregon’s Eugene Daily Guard on July 11, 1922—readers could see the flower-filled wrought-iron balconies, broad studio windows, and Egyptian Revival doorway of the quiet Gramercy apartment house where “The Count” had hidden a fortune in stolen bonds. Chapman and Anderson were convicted the following month and sentenced to twenty-five years in Atlanta Federal Penitentiary.

A place in the row
Protected within the 1966 Gramercy Park Historic District
On September 20, 1966, the New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission designated the Gramercy Park Historic District (LP-0251, followed by listing on the National Register of Historic Places in 1980), protecting 12 Gramercy Park South as an essential link in the nineteenth- and early twentieth-century residential fabric along the south edge of the square.
Reading three eras in one elevation today
Maintained today as a five-story, ten-unit residential cooperative between the Anglo-Italianate Grant–Barlow House at 11 Gramercy Park South and the neighboring Maynard–Cowdin House at 13 Gramercy Park South, No. 12 invites any passerby on the southern sidewalk to read nearly two centuries of history at a glance. At the ground floor, the fluted limestone pilasters and Egyptian Revival palm-leaf capitals of the doorway recall Chief Justice Thomas J. Oakley’s 1848 threshold; above them, the broad multi-paned studio windows and iron balconies evoke the studios where Herb Roth and Ray Rohn met their magazine deadlines—and where postal inspectors once knocked on the door of “The Count.”
Residents of Note
The People of Gramercy- Katharine Varnum Kendall DennyGilded Age debutante and daughter of William Beals and Kate Varnum Whitney Kendall; celebrated her December 1905 society debut at 12 Gramercy Park South and made national headlines with her October 1907 marriage to Archibald Marshall Denny
- William Beals KendallWall Street stockbroker, member of the New York Stock Exchange, and clubman (born 1855); resided at 12 Gramercy Park South with his family around 1899–1907
- Matilda Caroline Cruger OakleyMember of the prominent New York Cruger family and wife of Chief Justice Thomas J. Oakley (1809–1891); mistress of 12 Gramercy Park South from 1848 and owner of the house for more than three decades after her husband’s death
- Chief Justice Thomas Jackson OakleyU.S. Congressman, Attorney General of New York, Supreme Court advocate in Gibbons v. Ogden (1824), and Chief Judge of the New York Superior Court (1783–1857); first resident of 12 Gramercy Park South from 1847–1848 until his death here in May 1857
- Ray RohnMagazine and newspaper illustrator for Judge, Puck, Collier’s, and The Saturday Evening Post (1888–1935); shared a studio apartment at 12 Gramercy Park South with Herb Roth during the 1910s
- Herb RothCelebrated cartoonist and illustrator for Pulitzer’s New York World, Life, Judge, and The New Yorker, and collaborator with H. T. Webster on The Timid Soul (1887–1953); shared a studio at 12 Gramercy Park South with Ray Rohn in the 1910s
Building at a glance
The Chief Justice Thomas J. Oakley House · Built c. 1847–1848
The building record
- Address
- 12 Gramercy Park South (also 112 East 20th Street; Manhattan Block 875, Lot 74)
- Historic names
- The Chief Justice Thomas J. Oakley House
- Built
- c. 1847–1848 (for Chief Justice Thomas Jackson Oakley and Matilda Caroline Cruger Oakley)
- Original architect
- Unknown
- Architecture
- Five-story red-brick and stone residence (26 ft. 8 in. × 92 ft. lot) combining an 1847–1848 late Greek Revival and Egyptian Revival pilastered limestone entrance surround (relocated to street level) with early twentieth-century double-width studio casement windows, wrought-iron balconies, and a bracketed cornice
- Present use
- Ten-unit residential cooperative
- Historical associations
- Chief Justice Thomas J. Oakley & Matilda Cruger Oakley · William Beals Kendall & Katharine Kendall Denny · Cartoonists Herb Roth & Ray Rohn (1910s) · Edward J. Bryce (“The Count,” 1922 mail-robbery raid)
- Park access & landmark status
- Deeded key privileges to Gramercy Park; within the 1966 NYC Gramercy Park Historic District (LP-0251) and 1980 National Register of Historic Places district
Over time
The Chief Justice Thomas J. Oakley House is built
Newly elected Chief Justice of the New York Superior Court Thomas Jackson Oakley (1783–1857) and his wife Matilda Caroline Cruger Oakley establish their home in the new townhouse at 12 Gramercy Park South.
Death of Chief Justice Oakley
After nearly three decades on the Superior Court bench, Chief Justice Oakley dies at 12 Gramercy Park South at age seventy-three; his funeral is held in the house, and his widow Matilda retains ownership until 1889.
Select boarding suites and the Adams purchase
By 1875, Mrs. S. A. Curtis advertises furnished family rooms with private tables at No. 12; in 1889, brush-manufacturing magnate John J. Adams purchases the house from the Oakley family.
The William Beals Kendall household
Stockbroker William Beals Kendall and Kate Varnum Whitney Kendall occupy No. 12, hosting daughter Katharine Varnum Kendall’s society debut reception on December 27, 1905, prior to her October 1907 marriage to Archibald Marshall Denny.
Studio conversion and cartoonists Herb Roth & Ray Rohn
Remodeled into apartments with broad north-facing studio windows and a lowered Egyptian Revival entrance, No. 12 becomes the studio of illustrators Herb Roth and Ray Rohn—site of their March 1916 “Great Whisker Contest” and July 1916 Green Book Magazine profile.
“The Count” and the Leonard Street mail-robbery raid
Investigating Gerald Chapman and “Dutch” Anderson’s $2.4 million Broadway mail-truck heist, federal postal inspectors raid the apartment of Edward J. Bryce (“The Count”) at 12 Gramercy Park South and recover $100,000 in stolen securities.
Gramercy Park Historic District and cooperative
Protected within the Gramercy Park Historic District since September 20, 1966, 12 Gramercy Park South is maintained today as a ten-unit residential cooperative.
One address, many lives
- c. 1847–1848 · Chief Justice Thomas J. Oakley’s house rises
- 1848–1857 · Chief Judge of the New York Superior Court
- 1875–1889 · Select boarding rooms & changing households
- 1905 & 1907 · Katharine Kendall’s society debut & elopement
- 1916–1917 · Cartoonists Herb Roth & Ray Rohn’s studio
- July 1922 · “The Count” & $100,000 in stolen mail loot
- Sept. 1966 · Gramercy Park Historic District designation
Sources cited
- The plan for Gramercy Park. Samuel B. and Mary Ruggles, indenture to the trustees of Gramercy Park, December 17, 1831. Original deed, reproduced by GPBA; provisions for the surrounding building lots.
- The house and its alterations. Tom Miller, “The Thomas J. Oakley House—12 Gramercy Park,” Daytonian in Manhattan, April 17, 2020. Building chronology, boarding notices, entrance alterations, and exterior photographs.
- Thomas J. Oakley. Historical Society of the New York Courts, biographical profile. Legal career, attorney generalship, and service on the Superior Court.
- Oakley’s address in 1857. Trow’s New-York City Directory, for the year ending May 1, 1857, p. 624. Thomas J. Oakley’s home and judicial office addresses. Columbia University Libraries / Durst Collection, via Internet Archive.
- The Kendall household. Social Register, New York 1900, issued November 1899, p. 233. W. Beals Kendall and family at 12 Gramercy Park.
- The debut and marriage. Sue Morris, “The Pittsburgh Society Scandal of Katharine Kendall,” The Historical Dilettante, December 2022. Contemporary newspaper reports, including the New York Times correction of October 13, 1907.
- Apartment use by 1916. Real Estate Record and Builders’ Guide, February 19, 1916, p. 297. Pease & Elliman’s furnished-apartment lease at No. 12. Columbia University Libraries.
- Ray Rohn. Alex Jay, “Ink-Slinger Profiles: Ray Rohn,” Stripper’s Guide, January 31, 2018. Biographical research and transcription of Rohn’s 1917 draft-registration address.
- The artists at work and play. Cartoons Magazine, March 1916, “The Great Whisker Contest Is On,” reproduced by Stripper’s Guide, March 20, 2020. Roth, Rohn, and their beard-growing wager.
- Herb Roth’s wider career. Harry Ransom Center, University of Texas at Austin, Herb Roth biography in the Greenwich Village Bookshop Door project.
- The house in the 1922 news. Eugene Daily Guard, July 11, 1922, p. 1. Photograph of No. 12 and caption identifying Edward Bryce’s apartment and the recovered securities. Historic Oregon Newspapers, University of Oregon Libraries.
- The mail robbery investigation. United States Postal Inspection Service, “Gerald Chapman & Dutch Anderson.” Official account of the October 24, 1921 robbery, July 1922 arrests, and August convictions.
- The historic district. New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission, Gramercy Park Historic District Designation Report, LP-0251, September 20, 1966. District boundaries and architectural significance.
- The artists photographed. Green Book Magazine, July 1916. Studio snapshot of Ray Rohn and group portrait of Herb Roth, Charles Hanson Towne, and Rea Irvin. Digitized volume via HathiTrust.
- Municipal property and cooperative records. New York City Department of City Planning & Department of Finance, Manhattan Block 875, Lot 74 (12 Gramercy Park South / 112 East 20th Street).
Photo credits for this page
- Exterior view of 12 Gramercy Park South: Gramercy Park Block Association archive.
- July 1916 studio photographs of Ray Rohn, Herb Roth, Charles Hanson Towne, and Rea Irvin: Green Book Magazine (July 1916); digitized via HathiTrust / Stripper’s Guide.
- Egyptian Revival limestone entrance surround at 12 Gramercy Park South: Photograph by Tom Miller (2020), Daytonian in Manhattan.
- Portrait of Chief Justice Thomas Jackson Oakley (1783–1857): James Grant Wilson, ed., The Memorial History of the City of New York (New York History Company, 1893).
- Torchlight serenade for Governor Samuel J. Tilden along Gramercy Park South (1877 wood engraving): Frank Leslie’s Illustrated Newspaper (1877); Irma and Paul Milstein Division, The New York Public Library.
- Front-page newspaper feature on 12 Gramercy Park South and the mail-robbery investigation (July 11, 1922): The Eugene Daily Guard, July 11, 1922, page 1; Historic Oregon Newspapers, University of Oregon Libraries.