39A Gramercy Park North
An address for dissent.

A LETTER FROM GRAMERCY PARK
On June 8, 1953, a letter typed on plain stationery headed “NORMAN THOMAS · 39A Gramercy Park” arrived at the United States Department of State in Washington. Its sixty-eight-year-old author—Presbyterian minister, civil-liberties champion, and six-time Socialist Party candidate for President of the United States—wanted a direct answer to a pointed Cold War question: could a loyal American who happened to be a democratic socialist still be hired for a civil-service job?
The building from which Thomas mailed that challenge is easy to walk past on East 21st Street. Rising six stories in unadorned red brick on a twenty-six-foot lot just east of the Park’s northern gates, 39A Gramercy Park North is one of the smallest apartment houses on the block. Yet in the early 1950s, this quiet cooperative served as the study from which a longtime Gramercy neighbor defended Holocaust rescuer Varian Fry, confronted McCarthy-era loyalty investigators, and wrote his landmark defense of American dissent, The Test of Freedom.
A narrow place on the north side
Why there is a “39A” on Gramercy Park
Walk east along East 21st Street toward Third Avenue and the house numbers tell a story of changing scale. Because Gramercy Park’s perimeter addresses run clockwise from No. 1 on the west to No. 61 on the north, no whole number remained between expansive 39 Gramercy Park North (147–155 East 21st Street) to the east and the surviving 1853 Swendsen brownstone at 40 Gramercy Park North (143 East 21st Street) to the west. The slender twenty-six-foot lot wedged between them—known in city tax rolls as 145 East 21st Street—therefore took the fractional Park address 39A Gramercy Park North.
Throughout the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, 145 East 21st Street held a four-story brick-and-brownstone rowhouse matching its neighbors along the north side of the block. By August and October 1918, when the brokerage firm Pease & Elliman took over management of No. 145, the old townhouse had already been adapted into newly decorated furnished and unfurnished apartments overlooking the eastern end of the square.

Twenty-six feet of prewar brick and light
Around 1930—just as sixteen-story 44 Gramercy Park North rose a few doors to the west—the old rowhouse at 145 East 21st Street gave way to the present six-story elevator apartment building. Containing twenty-three apartments across a footprint twenty-six feet wide by roughly eighty-five feet deep, the building relies on clean proportions rather than historical ornament: warm red-brick piers frame wide multi-pane studio windows across the front, while a recessed entrance tucked at the western edge opens to the lobby and an exposed eastern party wall overlooks the gated alley beside No. 39.
A public voice, a Gramercy address

Three decades around Gramercy Park
When Norman Mattoon Thomas (1884–1968) moved into 39A Gramercy Park North after his sixth and final presidential campaign in 1948, he was not a newcomer to the neighborhood; he was moving across a square he had called home for nearly thirty years. An Ohio-born Presbyterian minister and 1905 Princeton valedictorian whose pastoral work in the immigrant tenements of East Harlem had turned him toward democratic socialism and pacifism, Thomas had married Frances Violet Stewart (1881–1947)—granddaughter of Wall Street financier and U.S. Sub-Treasury head John Aikman Stewart—in 1910.
During the 1920s and 1930s, Norman and Violet raised their children two blocks south of the Park in a townhouse at 206 East 18th Street, while in 1932 Violet decorated an old house at 71 Irving Place as a neighborhood tearoom and gathering place for young people of modest means. In the early 1940s, the couple lived on the south side of the square at 20 Gramercy Park South—in the same five-story building where writer and artist Ludwig Bemelmans painted his walls before publicist Benjamin Sonnenberg bought Nos. 19 and 20 in 1945—and at 71 Irving Place. After Violet died suddenly in August 1947, the widowed Thomas settled into an apartment at 39A Gramercy Park North—the address recorded beside his name in the Congressional Record in 1950 alongside his work as chairman of the Post War World Council, which he had founded to advocate for universal disarmament, decolonization, and democratic human rights.
The candidate whose losing platforms became law
Across six consecutive presidential campaigns between 1928 and 1948 as the standard-bearer of the Socialist Party, Thomas never carried a state, yet he became one of the most respected moral voices in American politics. As his grandson, biographer and journalist Evan Thomas, later observed, the proposals Norman Thomas championed from the campaign stump in the 1920s and early 1930s—a five-day workweek, a federal minimum wage, unemployment insurance, Social Security for the elderly, public housing, and the abolition of child labor—were initially dismissed as radical, only to be enacted into law during the New Deal.
Equally defining was his lifelong commitment to civil liberties regardless of who held power. A co-founder of the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) and the League for Industrial Democracy, Thomas helped organize the Southern Tenant Farmers’ Union for Black and white sharecroppers in the 1930s, stood virtually alone among national political leaders in denouncing the wartime internment of Japanese Americans in 1942, and opposed Soviet totalitarianism and domestic McCarthyism with equal vigor.
A letter for a rescuer
From the Emergency Rescue Committee to a loyalty probe
From his desk at 39A Gramercy Park, Thomas used his moral authority to shield citizens caught in the crossfire of Cold War suspicion. On October 12, 1951, he wrote a formal letter from 39A Gramercy Park to Army counterintelligence officer Colonel Victor W. Phelps to refute an allegation that journalist and editor Varian Fry (1907–1967) had been a member of the Communist Party.
No one in America was better qualified to vouch for Fry’s record. Eleven years earlier, in June 1940—immediately after the fall of France left thousands of German, Austrian, and European anti-fascist intellectuals, writers, and artists trapped in Vichy France under the "surrender on demand" clause of the Franco-German armistice—Norman Thomas had joined Reinhold Niebuhr, Frank Kingdon, and Eleanor Roosevelt in founding the Emergency Rescue Committee. It was that committee that dispatched the thirty-two-year-old Harvard classicist Varian Fry to Marseille with $3,000 taped to his leg and a list of two hundred endangered cultural figures.
Standing up for the man who saved two thousand lives
Working out of the Hôtel Splendide and the Villa Air-Bel in Marseille for thirteen months in 1940–1941 before Vichy police expelled him, Fry and his small team forged identity papers, charted clandestine mountain footpaths over the Pyrenees, and rescued roughly two thousand people from the Gestapo—among them Marc Chagall, Hannah Arendt, Max Ernst, André Breton, Jacques Lipchitz, Franz Werfel, and Heinrich Mann.
Yet a decade later, at the height of the Second Red Scare in 1951, Fry’s wartime associations with European anti-fascist resistance groups triggered a federal security investigation when he was considered for government consulting work. Writing from 39A Gramercy Park, Thomas—who knew both Fry’s anti-Communist convictions and his heroic service in Marseille firsthand—put his name cleanly on the record to defend the rescuer.
The question sent to Washington
A pointed inquiry to Scott McLeod
Two years later, Thomas aimed a letter from 39A Gramercy Park straight at the nerve center of the Eisenhower administration’s loyalty-security program. On June 8, 1953, writing under the letterhead “NORMAN THOMAS · 39A Gramercy Park, New York 10, N.Y.,” he addressed R. W. Scott McLeod—the newly installed administrator of the State Department’s Bureau of Security and Consular Affairs and a close ally of Senator Joseph McCarthy.
Thomas posed a practical question on behalf of the young university graduates who regularly sought his counsel about entering public service: did the federal government draw a distinction between a revolutionary Communist conspirator and a democratic Socialist? Acknowledging that any administration had the right to fill top policy-making posts with officials who shared its economic philosophy, Thomas asked whether a qualified young democratic socialist applying for an ordinary civil-service post would be barred or blacklisted on ideological grounds.

Published in the Foreign Service Journal
McLeod’s reply of July 14, 1953, revealed the ambiguity at the heart of the loyalty program: while standard Civil Service Commission forms did not ask applicants to state an ordinary party affiliation beyond specific security questions regarding subversive organizations, McLeod stated candidly that for any position exercising policy judgment, he personally would never knowingly approve the appointment of a socialist. Determined that the exchange should be read by the diplomats and civil servants whose careers hung in the balance, Thomas saw to it that the letters were published in the September 1953 issue of the Foreign Service Journal.
The test of freedom
Writing The Test of Freedom from Gramercy Park
Thomas had a second purpose in pressing McLeod on the record: as he informed the State Department, he was writing a book on the state of civil liberties in America for W. W. Norton & Company and intended to quote the administration’s exact policy. Published in the spring of 1954 while Thomas was listed in Who’s Who in America at 39A Gramercy Park, The Test of Freedom: The State of Liberty Under the Twin Attacks Called Communism and McCarthyism argued that Jeffersonian liberty faced a dual peril—totalitarian communism abroad and the climate of fear that equated democratic heresy with conspiracy at home. Drawing directly on the civil-service questions he had raised with the State Department, Thomas warned that loyalty boards and ideological litmus tests were driving independent minds out of the Foreign Service, universities, and public life.
Dissent versus conspiracy in the FBI’s files
Inside J. Edgar Hoover’s Federal Bureau of Investigation, officials promptly read and summarized the volume in a June 14, 1954 internal memorandum—noting Thomas’s residence at 39A Gramercy Park, his sharp critique of using secret investigative files to set political policy, and his insistence that a free society is measured by how steadfastly it protects the Bill of Rights for unpopular minorities.
The address remains
A voice that never retired
Even into his eighties, Thomas remained an irrepressible public conscience. He spoke from the platform of the 1963 March on Washington alongside Martin Luther King Jr. and A. Philip Randolph, and in a 1964 Book and Author Luncheon recorded by WNYC, listeners can still hear his resonant voice pressing Americans to confront poverty, war, and racial injustice. When civil-rights and labor leaders gathered at the Hotel Astor in November 1964 to celebrate his eightieth birthday—where Dr. King hailed him as the “conscience of America”—Thomas was presented with a $17,500 tribute check and immediately gave the entire sum away to civil-rights and peace organizations before his death in December 1968 at eighty-four.
A twenty-six-foot cooperative on the north side
Today, 39A Gramercy Park North remains an intimate twenty-three-unit elevator cooperative on the north side of East 21st Street, included within the broader Gramercy Park Historic District listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1980. Beside the grand hotels and sixteen-story towers of the square, its twenty-six feet of red brick and wide studio windows preserve the human scale of a working New York block—and the upper-floor study where an American dissenter insisted that the government answer its citizens in writing.
← Return to the map and building histories
Residents of Note
The People of Gramercy- Norman ThomasMinister, author, civil-liberties leader, and six-time Socialist Party candidate for President of the United States; lived and worked at 39A Gramercy Park North in the late 1940s and 1950s following earlier Gramercy residences at 206 East 18th Street, 20 Gramercy Park South, and 71 Irving Place
Building at a glance
145 East 21st Street · c. 1930
The building record
- Address
- 39A Gramercy Park North · 145 East 21st Street
- Location
- North side of East 21st Street, between 40 Gramercy Park North (west) and 39 Gramercy Park North (east)
- Built
- c. 1930 (replacing an earlier nineteenth-century rowhouse at 145 East 21st Street)
- Form & Style
- Six-story prewar red-brick elevator apartment house
- Frontage
- 26 feet (Manhattan Block 877, Lot 35)
- Ownership
- Residential cooperative (23 apartments)
- Historic resident
- Norman Mattoon Thomas (1884–1968)
Over time
The earlier rowhouse at 145 East 21st Street
A four-story brick-and-brownstone townhouse occupies the twenty-six-foot lot between Nos. 143 and 147 East 21st Street; by 1918, managed by Pease & Elliman, it is adapted into apartments overlooking the square.
The six-story apartment house rises
The present six-story red-brick elevator building containing twenty-three apartments is completed at 145 East 21st Street, taking the fractional Park address 39A Gramercy Park North.
Norman Thomas moves to 39A
Following the death of his wife Frances Violet Stewart Thomas in 1947 and his sixth and final presidential campaign in 1948, longtime Gramercy resident Norman Thomas moves into 39A Gramercy Park North.
Defending Varian Fry
Writing from 39A Gramercy Park, Thomas—who had helped found the Emergency Rescue Committee in 1940—vouches for Holocaust rescuer Varian Fry against Cold War loyalty allegations.
Challenging the State Department
Thomas writes from 39A Gramercy Park to State Department security chief R. W. Scott McLeod questioning whether democratic socialists are barred from civil-service employment; their exchange is published in the Foreign Service Journal.
The Test of Freedom
W. W. Norton publishes Thomas’s book The Test of Freedom: The State of Liberty Under the Twin Attacks Called Communism and McCarthyism, researched and written during his residence at 39A Gramercy Park.
An address through time
Sources cited
- Record and Guide. October 19, 1918, p. 467. Management notice for 145 East 21st Street.
- New York City Department of Finance, J-51 benefits report. FY 2015/16, Manhattan, printed p. 7: block 877, lot 35; 1930 year built and 23 residential units.
- New York City Department of Finance, property assessment. 39A Gramercy Park North, block 877, lot 35; six stories, frontage, alternate address, and cooperative classification.
- Sanborn Map Company, Insurance Maps of Manhattan, vol. 2, plate 46. 1903. New York Public Library, via Wikimedia Commons.
- Congressional Record, House. 1950, p. 13097. Post War World Council reporting naming Thomas at 39A.
- FBI, Norman Thomas correlation summary. National Archives and Records Administration (NARA), released Federal Bureau of Investigation file on Norman Mattoon Thomas (page 143), summarizing Thomas’s October 12, 1951 letter from 39A Gramercy Park concerning Varian Fry.
- United States Holocaust Memorial Museum, “Varian Fry”. Holocaust Encyclopedia. Fry’s rescue work in France, 1940–41.
- FBI, Norman Thomas headquarters file, part 1. National Archives and Records Administration (NARA), released Federal Bureau of Investigation Headquarters File on Norman Mattoon Thomas. Thomas–McLeod correspondence, June 8 and July 14, 1953.
- Foreign Service Journal. September 1953. “McLeod–Thomas Correspondence.”
- FBI, Norman Thomas headquarters file, part 2. National Archives and Records Administration (NARA), released Federal Bureau of Investigation Headquarters File on Norman Mattoon Thomas. Memorandum to Mr. Nichols, June 14, 1954, reviewing The Test of Freedom and citing Thomas’s address.
- Evan Thomas, “#24: Norman Thomas 1905”. Princeton Alumni Weekly. Political career and reform platform.
- The Martin Luther King, Jr. Research and Education Institute, “Thomas, Norman Mattoon”. Stanford University. Biography and civil-rights work.
- Philip Quarles, “Norman Thomas”. WNYC, April 27, 2017. Archival 1964 luncheon recording; portrait credited to AP.
Photo credits for this page
- Exterior view of 39A Gramercy Park North (145 East 21st Street): Gramercy Park Block Association archive / CityRealty.
- Detail of Block 877 showing 145 East 21st Street: Insurance Maps of the City of New York, Borough of Manhattan, Vol. 2, Plate 46 (Sanborn Map Company, 1903); The New York Public Library, Map Division.
- Portrait of Norman Mattoon Thomas: Associated Press / WNYC New York Public Radio archive.
- Letterhead of Norman Thomas at 39A Gramercy Park to Hon. Scott McLeod, June 8, 1953: National Archives and Records Administration.