39 Gramercy Park North
Private rooms, public lives.

BETWEEN THE SQUARE AND THE AVENUE
Walk east along the north side of Gramercy Park and the quiet enclosure of nineteenth-century brownstones and prewar cooperatives meets the wide, sunlit corridor of Third Avenue. Anchoring the northwest corner of East 21st Street and Third Avenue, the seventeen-story red-brick tower of 39 Gramercy Park North marks the exact moment in the mid-1950s when the demolition of the Third Avenue Elevated Railway transformed the eastern edge of the neighborhood.
Completed in 1956–1957 on the footprint of seven nineteenth-century rowhouses and Third Avenue storefronts, the ninety-apartment building introduced postwar picture windows and cantilevered open-air balconies to the perimeter of the square—while retaining coveted key privileges to Gramercy Park and providing a new New York address for figures such as German-born refugee pediatrician Dr. Anny Elston, who rebuilt her medical career here after fleeing Nazi Berlin.
A corner between two New Yorks
Rowhouses toward the Park, tenements under the El
For more than a century after Samuel B. Ruggles laid out Gramercy Park in 1831, the eastern end of East 21st Street straddled two very different worlds. Toward the iron gates of the private garden stood quiet brick-and-brownstone residences; at the corner of Third Avenue stood lively neighborhood storefronts shadowed after 1878 by the iron trestles of the Third Avenue Elevated Railway.
On the 1903 Sanborn insurance map of Manhattan, the ground now occupied by 39 Gramercy Park North is still divided into seven narrow parcels: five four-story brick rowhouses stretching along the north curb at 147, 149, 151, 153, and 155 East 21st Street (just east of 39A Gramercy Park North at No. 145), meeting three- and four-story commercial buildings with corner storefronts at 260, 262, and 264 Third Avenue. Directly behind them along East 22nd Street stood the private carriage houses of Gilded Age families—including society yachtswoman Eloise L. Breese’s 1893 Flemish Revival carriage house at 150 East 22nd Street, designed by Sidney V. Stratton, whose stepped-gable brick façade still survives on the back of the block—while across East 21st Street to the south stood the neighborhood’s original Victorian Gramercy Park Hotel on the site of today’s 38 Gramercy Park East.
Those vanished East 21st Street rowhouses sheltered a lively succession of Gramercy trades and residents: in November 1873, Mark Twain’s wife, Olivia Langdon Clemens, commissioned her custom black silk and blue velvet gowns from court dressmaker Madame Fogarty at 149 East 21st Street, and by the late 1920s, when the houses had become lodging for young artists and writers, illustrator and Adventure magazine cover painter Duncan McMillan (1895–1943) lived at No. 151.
Gramercy Florists and the fall of the Third Avenue El
Photographs taken by street chronicler Percy Loomis Sperr for the New York Public Library in 1934 and 1936 capture the corner in vivid detail. At 260 Third Avenue, Sakas Brothers’ Gramercy Florists set potted evergreens out on the sidewalk beneath a striped canvas awning, flanked by radio repair shops, bakeries, and delicatessens while the Elevated tracks cast a lattice of shadows across the cobblestones.
The Sakas family had founded the Gramercy Park Flower Shop in 1904. Garmey’s account, drawing on the Sakas family archives, follows the business through the redevelopment: after the old corner building came down, the shop reopened in the corresponding corner space of the new apartment house.
That seventy-seven-year-old streetscape ended on May 12, 1955, when the last Manhattan train rumbled down the Third Avenue El. By February 1956, crews had dismantled the elevated ironwork, opening Third Avenue to the sky and triggering an immediate postwar building boom along the widened boulevard.




A new scale for the corner

Brick, glass, and balconies in the open air
One of the lost houses, 147 East 21st Street, stood on original Gramercy Park deed Lot 39. Garmey dates its demolition to 1955, just before the apartment development assembled the larger corner site.
No sooner had the El tracks come down in early 1956 than developers assembled the seven parcels at 147–159 East 21st Street and 260–264 Third Avenue (Manhattan Block 877, Lot 42) to erect a seventeen-story elevator apartment house. Completed in 1956–1957 with roughly ninety residences ranging from compact studios to three- and four-bedroom homes, the building traded historical stone ornament for the clean horizontal geometry of mid-century modernism.
Across its broad red-brick elevations and upper-story setbacks, bands of steel-casement picture windows alternate with stacks of projecting corner and front balconies. Framed by crisp white concrete floor slabs and dark metal railings, those outdoor platforms act as suspended porches in the sky—catching the southern sun over East 21st Street and giving residents private open-air views westward into the treetops of Gramercy Park.
Third Avenue scale with a Gramercy Park key
Crucially, because the assembled site incorporated the East 21st Street rowhouse lots extending westward toward the square, the new corner building inherited deeded privileges to Gramercy Park. By placing its primary residential entrance under a marquee on quiet, tree-lined East 21st Street rather than on busy Third Avenue, 39 Gramercy Park North gave its residents the best of both worlds: postwar apartment layouts and open balconies paired with a key to Manhattan’s only private park.
A doctor’s address, a life rebuilt
From Weimar Berlin to Stuyvesant Square and Gramercy Park
Among the professionals who established an address at 39 Gramercy Park North in its early years was pediatrician Dr. Anny Elston (1895–1975), whose life traced the resilience of European refugee physicians in mid-century New York. Born Anni Halpert in Gera, Germany, on March 21, 1895, she studied medicine at the universities of Heidelberg, Munich, and Jena, earning her medical degree in 1920 and opening a pediatric practice on Trautenaustraße in Berlin-Wilmersdorf while serving in municipal infant-welfare clinics.
After the Nazi regime stripped Jewish physicians of their national health-insurance panel status in 1933 and revoked their medical licenses altogether in 1938, she fled to England in 1939 and reached the United States in March 1941. Adopting the name Anny Elston and passing her New York medical licensing examinations in 1942, she rebuilt her career six blocks south of Gramercy Park at the historic New York Infirmary for Women and Children on Stuyvesant Square—the hospital founded in 1857 by pioneering woman physician Elizabeth Blackwell.
Three decades of care in the neighborhood
Elected in 1949 to the Rudolf Virchow Medical Society in the City of New York, Dr. Elston recorded her professional address at 39 Gramercy Park North in the society’s proceedings and medical directories through the early 1960s, while her personal papers—now preserved at Drexel University’s Legacy Center for Women in Medicine—document nearly three decades of teaching and clinical service at the New York Infirmary from 1957 onward. Even after retiring from private practice at seventy-five, she continued treating children in New York public welfare clinics and attended the International Congress of Pediatrics in Buenos Aires in 1974, a year before her death in New York at eighty.
A cooperative life beside the square
From rental house to full-service cooperative
After operating for just over a decade as a postwar rental building, 39 Gramercy Park North converted to cooperative ownership in 1969 under 39 Tenants Corp. At pedestrian level along East 21st Street, a deep marquee, polished stone cladding, leaded-glass entrance doors, and landscaped iron-fenced planters create a quiet residential threshold stepped back from the activity of Third Avenue around the corner.
The eastern gateway to Gramercy Park North
On the New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission’s 1966 map of the Gramercy Park Historic District, the boundary line runs along the northern edge of the Park fence and turns south before reaching this postwar corner, while the broader 1980 National Register of Historic Places district encompasses the surrounding blocks from Park Avenue South to Third Avenue. Standing at the eastern gateway to Gramercy Park North, No. 39 records the mid-century chapter when the fall of the Third Avenue El brought light, balconies, and a new generation of households to the edge of the square.
← Return to the Buildings & Monuments map
Residents of Note
The People of Gramercy- Anny Elston, M.D. (Anni Edelstein-Halpert)German-born pediatrician (1895–1975) who fled Nazi Berlin in 1939, served on the staff of the New York Infirmary for Women and Children on nearby Stuyvesant Square, and maintained her professional address at 39 Gramercy Park North
Building at a glance
East 21st Street at Third Avenue · Built 1956–57
The building record
- Address
- 39 Gramercy Park North · 147–159 East 21st Street / 260–264 Third Avenue
- Location
- Northwest corner of Third Avenue and East 21st Street
- Property identifiers
- Manhattan Block 877, Lot 42
- Built
- 1956–1957 (following the 1955–1956 demolition of the Third Avenue Elevated Railway) The earlier house at 147 East 21st Street, on original deed Lot 39, was demolished in 1955.
- Form & Style
- Seventeen-story postwar red-brick apartment house with cantilevered balconies
- Cooperative conversion
- 1969 (39 Tenants Corp.; approx. 90 residential units)
- Park access
- Deeded key privileges to Gramercy Park
- Historic districts
- Within the 1980 National Register of Historic Places district; outside the 1966 NYC Landmarks boundary
Over time
Seven rowhouses and corner shops
Four-story brick rowhouses at 147–155 East 21st Street—including Madame Fogarty’s dressmaking salon at No. 149, patronized by Mark Twain’s wife Olivia Clemens in 1873—and commercial tenements at 260–264 Third Avenue occupy the corner, shadowed after 1878 by the Third Avenue Elevated Railway.
Gramercy Florists under the El
Photographer Percy Loomis Sperr documents Sakas Brothers’ Gramercy Florists at the northwest corner of Third Avenue and East 21st Street beneath the elevated tracks.
The Third Avenue El comes down
Manhattan service on the Third Avenue Elevated ends on May 12, 1955, and demolition of the iron structure is completed the following February, sparking a postwar building boom along the avenue.
39 Gramercy Park North rises
The seven corner lots are assembled for a seventeen-story, ninety-unit red-brick apartment building featuring recessed and corner balconies and key privileges to Gramercy Park.
Dr. Anny Elston’s medical practice
Refugee Berlin pediatrician Dr. Anny Elston (1895–1975), a physician at the nearby New York Infirmary on Stuyvesant Square and member of the Rudolf Virchow Medical Society, maintains her office address at 39 Gramercy Park North.
Cooperative conversion
The building converts to cooperative ownership under 39 Tenants Corp.
An address through time
Sources cited
- New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission. Gramercy Park Historic District Designation Report (LP-0251, 1966) and Official District Boundary Map (2019).
- Sanborn Map Company. Insurance Maps of the City of New York, Borough of Manhattan, Vol. 2, Plate 46 (1903); The New York Public Library, Map Division.
- Percy Loomis Sperr. Photographic views of Third Avenue and East 21st Street, May 21, 1934, and October 2, 1936 (Images 708023F and 711570F). The New York Public Library, Irma and Paul Milstein Division of United States History, Local History and Genealogy.
- Lawrence Stelter. “The Rise and Decline of New York City’s Third Avenue Elevated Train Line.” Gotham Center for New York City History, March 8, 2008.
- New York City Department of Finance. Property tax assessment and ACRIS records for Manhattan Block 877, Lot 42 (39 Gramercy Park North / 260 Third Avenue; 39 Tenants Corp.).
- Carter Horsley. “39 Gramercy Park North: Architectural Review.” CityRealty.
- Charité – Universitätsmedizin Berlin, Institute for the History of Medicine and Ethics in Medicine. “Anni Edelstein-Halpert, née Halpert (Anny Elston, 1895–1975),” Ärztinnen im Kaiserreich database (ID AEIK00802).
- Proceedings of the Rudolf Virchow Medical Society in the City of New York, Vol. XIX (Basel / New York: S. Karger, 1962), membership roster listing Anny Elston, M.D., at 39 Gramercy Park.
- Drexel University College of Medicine, Legacy Center Archives and Special Collections on Women in Medicine. Anny Elston Papers, 1957–1986 (Collection 1994.X.11).
- Sakas Brothers Archives, as cited in Garmey, for the Gramercy Park Flower Shop and its return to the redeveloped corner.
- Stephen Garmey, Gramercy Park (1984), pp. 112, 148–150, 171–172, 176–177, especially pp. 176–177 for the corner redevelopment, original Lot 39, and the Sakas family’s shop.
Photo credits for this page
- Exterior and East 21st Street entrance views of 39 Gramercy Park North: Gramercy Park Block Association archive.
- Third Avenue and East 21st Street showing Sakas Brothers’ Gramercy Florists and the Third Avenue Elevated Railway (October 2, 1936, Image 708023F; and 1930s view looking west into East 21st Street, Image 711570F): Photographs by Percy Loomis Sperr; The New York Public Library, Irma and Paul Milstein Division of United States History, Local History and Genealogy.
- Earlier rowhouses at 147–159 East 21st Street from beneath the Third Avenue Elevated Railway: Historical street view via Vestiges of New York.
- Detail of Block 877 showing 147–159 East 21st Street and 260–264 Third Avenue: Insurance Maps of the City of New York, Borough of Manhattan, Vol. 2, Plate 46 (Sanborn Map Company, 1903); The New York Public Library, Map Division.