Gramercy Park Block Association
Gramercy Stories

38 Gramercy Park

Seven dollars a week, a world of stories.

The former five-story red-brick building at 38 Gramercy Park, with copper bays and cornice, seen from the corner.
The former 38 Gramercy Park at the northeast corner of Gramercy Park East and East 21st Street following its 2007–2008 brick-and-copper reconstruction by Scott Henson Architect, with narrow five-story 37 Gramercy Park East (gray façade) and terra-cotta 36 Gramercy Park East immediately to the right.

HOTEL ROOMS AND CHANGING FAÇADES

In the winter of 1925–1926, seven dollars a week bought a twenty-three-year-old John Steinbeck a tiny top-floor walk-up room at the Parkwood Hotel at 38 Gramercy Park. Across more than a century and a half at the northeast corner of Gramercy Park East and East 21st Street, that building—and its slender five-story neighbor immediately to the south at 37 Gramercy Park East—lived through four distinct architectural identities.

Born in 1852–1853 as part of Oscar Stebbins’s Italianate brownstone row that became Sanderson’s Family Hotel and the Victorian Gramercy Park House, the corner structures were reclad in Neo-Tudor stucco and half-timbering in the 1920s, converted into cooperative apartments in 1986, and reconstructed in award-winning red brick and copper in 2007–2008, while No. 37 housed residences and the New York studio of architect and Rockefeller interior designer Theodor Carl Muller. Demolished together in 2025 for a unified corner development, the two buildings survive in archival photographs, architectural drawings, and Steinbeck’s early letters.

01
1852–1910 · THE FIRST HOTEL ON THE SQUARE

The hotel on the eastern edge

Sanderson’s Family Hotel and the Gramercy Park House

The eastern side of Gramercy Park was the last edge of Samuel B. Ruggles’s 1831 square to be built up, and from the beginning it welcomed travelers as well as permanent households. In 1852, real-estate speculator Oscar Stebbins acquired the vacant eastern blockfront between East 20th and East 21st Streets and erected a row of five-story Italianate brownstone residences. The following year, in 1853, those houses were joined internally to open Sanderson’s Family Hotel—soon known throughout New York as the Gramercy Park House, operated for decades by proprietor Curtis Judson.

For more than thirty years, the Gramercy Park House occupied the entire eastern frontage of the square, wrapping around the northeast corner along East 21st Street and welcoming guests ranging from Civil War generals Ulysses S. Grant and William Tecumseh Sherman to families summering or wintering beside the Park. When the red-brick Queen Anne cooperative at 34 Gramercy Park East rose on the southern half of the blockfront in 1883, the southern wing of the old hotel came down; when the white terra-cotta Gothic towers of 36 Gramercy Park East followed in 1908–1910, the middle section disappeared as well. Left standing at the northern end of the row were the five-story corner buildings at 37 and 38 Gramercy Park East, together with two adjoining East 21st Street annexes at 144 and 146 East 21st Street.

Reading the 1853 Italianate brownstones

An archival photograph taken shortly after the completion of 36 Gramercy Park East in 1910 preserves the original 1850s appearance of Nos. 37 and 38 side by side. Built of rusticated brownstone at the base with smooth ashlar above, both buildings featured paired round-arched Italianate windows set beneath bracketed lintels, ornate cast-iron Juliet balconies spanning the second-floor parlor windows, and deep modillioned cornices casting crisp shadows across the stone.

Black-and-white archival view of the earlier brownstone elevation, paired round-arched windows, balconies, and cornice.
37 and 38 Gramercy Park East photographed between 1910 and the early 1920s—still wearing their 1853 Italianate brownstone façades, paired round-arched windows, and cast-iron balconies beside the newly completed white terra-cotta bay of 36 Gramercy Park East at far right.
02
EARLY 1920S · THE NEO-TUDOR MAKEOVER

Three houses, one face

Stucco, half-timbering, and pitched gables

In the early 1920s, a new hotel operator united the corner brownstone at 38 Gramercy Park with its two narrow five-story neighbors along the south curb of East 21st Street (144 and 146 East 21st Street) into a single corner hotel and stripped away the nineteenth-century Italianate stonework in favor of a fashionable Neo-Tudor revival exterior.

Photographs taken in the 1930s by Percy Loomis Sperr and in the early 1940s by New York City tax assessors show the transformation clearly. Above a parged ground-floor base, the upper stories were resurfaced in rough stucco, dark decorative half-timbering, multi-pane casement windows, copper bay windows, and steeply pitched faux-slate gables along the roofline—turning three mid-nineteenth-century buildings into the picturesque residential hotel known in the 1920s as the Parkwood Hotel.

Historic photograph of the Tudor-style corner building at 38 Gramercy Park, with gables, timberwork and the narrow neighboring house beside it.
38 Gramercy Park in its 1920s Neo-Tudor stucco and half-timbered guise as the Parkwood Hotel (left), alongside the remodeled 1927 façade of 37 Gramercy Park East (center) and 36 Gramercy Park East (right), photographed by Percy Loomis Sperr in the 1930s.
Black-and-white tax photograph of 38 Gramercy Park with stucco walls, dark timber trim, and the elevated railway in the distance.
Early-1940s municipal tax photograph looking east along East 21st Street toward the Third Avenue Elevated Railway, showing the three joined structures that formed 38 Gramercy Park (144–146 East 21st Street).
03
1925–1926 · JOHN STEINBECK AT NO. 38

Seven dollars a week

Six flights up at the Parkwood Hotel

In November 1925, twenty-three-year-old John Steinbeck (1902–1968) arrived in New York Harbor from California aboard the freighter Katrina, carrying a hundred dollars in his pocket and dreams of becoming a writer, years before Cup of Gold (1929), Of Mice and Men (1937), or The Grapes of Wrath (1939). As he later recounted in his classic 1953 essay “The Making of a New Yorker,” he first stayed with his sister in Brooklyn while pushing wheelbarrows of concrete on the construction of the new Madison Square Garden, before landing a $25-a-week reporting job at William Randolph Hearst’s New York American through his Stanford uncle, Joe Hamilton.

Drawn to Gramercy Park by a young actress and dancer named Mary Ardath who lived nearby, Steinbeck rented a tiny room at the Parkwood Hotel at 38 Gramercy Park for seven dollars a week, “six walk-up flights above the street.” Looking out across the narrow airshaft from his upper window, he spotted one-eyed book illustrator Mahlon Blaine (1894–1969) working at a drawing board in another room of the hotel. The two became fast friends: Blaine took the provincial Californian under his wing and carried batches of Steinbeck’s short stories around to New York book publishers. On spring mornings, lacking a key to the private square across the street, Steinbeck paced the sidewalk outside the tall iron railings of Gramercy Park, watching nursemaids and children beneath the trees from the outer side of the fence.

“38 Gramercy Park” in his own hand

Steinbeck’s stay at the corner is anchored not only in memory, but in his surviving correspondence: a letter penned in June 1926 to Ruth Carpenter Sheffield, wife of his Stanford classmate Carlton Sheffield, and published in Steinbeck: A Life in Letters, bears the return heading “38 Gramercy Park, New York.”

Soon after that letter was mailed, Steinbeck’s first New York chapter unraveled. Fired from the New York American because he felt too much sympathy for his subjects to meet aggressive tabloid standards, turned down by book publishers for his collection of stories, and left heartbroken when Mary Ardath departed for California, he survived on canned sardines and stolen library books in his sixth-floor room before working his way back to San Francisco as a deckhand—calling his months on Gramercy Park the crucible that taught him both the terror and the magic of New York.

04
1927–1970S · THE NEIGHBOR AT NO. 37

The narrow neighbor at No. 37

A twenty-foot townhouse becomes apartments

Immediately south of No. 38, wedged between the corner hotel and the twelve-story terra-cotta castle of 36 Gramercy Park East, stood 37 Gramercy Park East (Manhattan Block 876, Lot 25). Originally erected in 1852–1853 as a twenty-foot-wide Italianate brownstone within the Sanderson’s Family Hotel row, No. 37 remained a separate property when its corner neighbor was reclad in Neo-Tudor style. In 1927, No. 37 received a streamline modernization of its own: its brownstone arches and stoop were replaced by a smooth stucco-and-limestone façade with twin ground-floor arches, steel casement windows, and six floor-through and duplex apartments overlooking the Park.

Theodor Carl Muller’s design studio

During the post–World War II decades, 37 Gramercy Park East housed the New York architectural and interior-design studio of Theodor Carl Muller (1899–1993). Trained in architecture at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and a former architecture instructor at Columbia University, Muller had honed his eye alongside legendary decorator Dorothy Draper before serving as national president of the American Institute of Decorators (AID) and chairman of the National Council on the Arts and Government.

From his office at 37 Gramercy Park, Muller directed high-profile residential and resort commissions across the country—most notably his twenty-year collaboration (1955–1975) with conservationists Laurance S. Rockefeller and Mary French Rockefeller at their Woodstock, Vermont estate (today preserved as the Marsh-Billings-Rockefeller National Historical Park) and at Caneel Bay in the Virgin Islands, where his custom furniture drawings, lighting designs, and fabric samples from 37 Gramercy Park are now preserved in the National Park Service archives.

05
1986–2012 · COOPERATIVE & RESTORATION

The façade remade

From residential hotel to thirty-six-unit cooperative

In 1986, after more than sixty years as a residential hotel and apartment house, 38 Gramercy Park converted into a thirty-six-unit residential cooperative. Within its five-story walk-up and elevator envelope, the former hotel rooms were adapted into compact studio and one-bedroom homes—many retaining wood-burning fireplaces, parquet floors, and views across the iron fence into Gramercy Park.

Close view of copper-clad projecting window bays against the red-brick façade.
Detail of the copper-clad projecting bay window and hand-laid red brickwork along the East 21st Street flank of 38 Gramercy Park, which earned a Brick Industry Association Gold Award in 2012.

Scott Henson’s 2007–2008 brick-and-copper reconstruction

By 2007, eighty-five years of New York weather had severely deteriorated the 1920s Neo-Tudor stucco and wood-timber cladding on No. 38. Retained by the cooperative board, preservation architect Scott Henson (Henson Architecture) found the stucco exterior beyond repair and designed a complete façade reconstruction inspired by archival photographs of the building’s nineteenth-century origins and the surrounding Gramercy streetscape.

Completed in 2008, the restoration replaced the crumbling stucco with hand-laid deep red brick set in ultra-narrow mortar joints, brownstone-toned window lintels and belt courses, a bracketed cornice, and two-story projecting copper bay windows along East 21st Street. Celebrated for reuniting the three underlying nineteenth-century structures into a warm, cohesive corner elevation, the project won the Brick Industry Association’s Gold Award in 2012.

06
2025 ONWARD · THE NEXT CHAPTER ON THE CORNER

The corner changes again

Outside the 1966 historic district boundary

Like the north-side buildings across East 21st Street, both 37 Gramercy Park East and 38 Gramercy Park stood just outside the boundary of the city’s 1966 Gramercy Park Historic District and its 1988 extension (which ended immediately to the south at 36 Gramercy Park East), while lying within the broader 1980 National Register of Historic Places district.

In 2024–2025, developers Legion Investment Group and Gindi Capital acquired the six-unit building at No. 37 and the thirty-six-unit cooperative at No. 38, combining them with adjoining parcels extending east to Third Avenue. Following the completion of demolition in November 2025, construction began on a new residential building designed by Roman and Williams—opening a fourth architectural chapter on the corner where Sanderson’s Family Hotel first welcomed guests to Gramercy Park in 1853.

  • Mahlon BlaineBook and magazine illustrator (1894–1969); lived at the Parkwood Hotel at 38 Gramercy Park in 1925–1926, where he befriended young John Steinbeck across the airshaft
  • Curtis JudsonNineteenth-century hotelier; longtime proprietor of the Gramercy Park House (formerly Sanderson’s Family Hotel) on the site
  • Theodor Carl MullerArchitect, industrial designer, and national president of the American Institute of Decorators (1899–1993); maintained his design office at 37 Gramercy Park East
  • John SteinbeckNobel and Pulitzer Prize–winning novelist (1902–1968); lived in a $7-a-week sixth-floor room at the Parkwood Hotel at 38 Gramercy Park in 1925–1926 during his first months in New York
Building at a glance

The former Sanderson / Parkwood hotel building
With the history of 37 Gramercy Park East
1852–1853 origins–2025

The building record

Principal address
38 Gramercy Park East (also known as 38 Gramercy Park and 144–146 East 21st Street)
Neighbor included
37 Gramercy Park East, immediately south of No. 38 (Block 876, Lot 25)
No. 38 origins
1852–1853 Italianate brownstones built by Oscar Stebbins and joined as Sanderson’s Family Hotel (later the Gramercy Park House)
No. 37 chronology
1852–1853 Italianate brownstone; remodeled into six apartments in 1927; Theodor Carl Muller’s design studio in the 1950s–1970s
Original architect
Unknown (built for developer Oscar Stebbins, 1852–1853)
No. 38 architectural phases
Italianate brownstone (1853); Neo-Tudor stucco and half-timbering (early 1920s); red-brick and copper reconstruction (2007–2008)
Reconstruction architect
Scott Henson Architect (Henson Architecture), 2007–2008 reconstruction of No. 38
Later residential use
No. 38: 36-unit residential cooperative (converted 1986). No. 37: 6 residential apartments (remodeled 1927)
Notable associations
No. 38: John Steinbeck and Mahlon Blaine (Parkwood Hotel, 1925–1926). No. 37: Theodor Carl Muller’s architectural and interior-design studio
Historic districts
Within the 1980 National Register of Historic Places district; outside the 1966 NYC Landmarks boundary and its 1988 extension
Status
Both former buildings demolished in 2025 as part of the corner redevelopment at 38 Gramercy Park East

Over time

1852–1853

Sanderson’s Family Hotel opens

Speculator Oscar Stebbins builds a row of five-story Italianate brownstones along the eastern blockfront of Gramercy Park; in 1853 they are joined as Sanderson’s Family Hotel, soon known as the Gramercy Park House under proprietor Curtis Judson.

1883–1910

The northern corner survives

As 34 Gramercy Park East (1883) and 36 Gramercy Park East (1908–1910) replace the southern and central sections of the hotel row, Nos. 37 and 38 Gramercy Park (with 144–146 East 21st Street) remain standing at the northeast corner.

Early 1920s

The Neo-Tudor Parkwood Hotel

A hotelier unites No. 38 with 144 and 146 East 21st Street and reclads the exterior in Neo-Tudor stucco, half-timbering, and pitched gables as the Parkwood Hotel.

1925–1926

John Steinbeck’s $7-a-week room

Twenty-three-year-old John Steinbeck rents a sixth-floor walk-up room at the Parkwood Hotel at 38 Gramercy Park while working as a construction laborer and New York American reporter, befriending fellow resident and illustrator Mahlon Blaine.

1927

37 Gramercy Park East is remodeled

Neighboring five-story 37 Gramercy Park East is modernized with a smooth stucco-and-limestone façade and reconfigured into six residential apartments.

1955–1975

Theodor Carl Muller at No. 37

Architect and former American Institute of Decorators president Theodor C. Muller operates his design studio at 37 Gramercy Park East, directing interior designs for Laurance and Mary French Rockefeller’s Vermont estate.

1986

Conversion to a cooperative

38 Gramercy Park converts from a residential hotel/apartment building into a thirty-six-unit residential cooperative.

2007–2012

Brick-and-copper façade reconstruction

Scott Henson Architect replaces No. 38’s failing stucco exterior with hand-laid red brick, brownstone-toned trim, and copper bays, earning a 2012 Brick Industry Association Gold Award.

2025

Corner assemblage and redevelopment

Following the acquisition of 37 and 38 Gramercy Park alongside adjoining Third Avenue parcels, both buildings are demolished in 2025 for a new residential development designed by Roman and Williams.

A corner through time

  1. 1852–1853 · Sanderson’s Family Hotel
  2. Early 1920s · The Neo-Tudor Parkwood Hotel
  3. 1925–1926 · John Steinbeck’s $7 room
  4. 1927–1957 · Neighboring No. 37 & Theodor Muller
  5. 1986–2012 · Cooperative & brick-and-copper restoration
  6. 2025 · Two sites, one redevelopment
Sources cited
Photo credits for this page
  • 38 Gramercy Park after its 2007–2008 reconstruction, and detail of copper-clad projecting bays: Photographs © Jack Kucy, via Henson Architecture.
  • 37 and 38 Gramercy Park East in their 1853 Italianate brownstone guise (c. 1910–1920): Historical photograph courtesy of Henson Architecture archive.
  • 38 Gramercy Park in its Neo-Tudor guise alongside 37 and 36 Gramercy Park East, 1930s: Photograph by Percy Loomis Sperr; The New York Public Library, Irma and Paul Milstein Division of United States History, Local History and Genealogy (Image 720038F).
  • Municipal tax photograph of 38 Gramercy Park (144–146 East 21st Street), c. 1940: New York City Department of Records and Information Services (DORIS), Municipal Archives, via Henson Architecture.