Gramercy Park Block Association
Gramercy Stories

31 Gramercy Park South

A brownstone that once housed a city department.

The brownstone façade of 31 Gramercy Park South, with broad upper windows, a cornice, and a green entrance canopy.
31 Gramercy Park South (148 East 20th Street), built in 1852 and standing detached between the gated side yard of the 1859 Quaker Meeting House at right (west) and the courtyard of 32 Gramercy Park South at left (east).

THE WORKING LIFE OF A BROWNSTONE

Behind the calm brownstone façade of 31 Gramercy Park South lies one of the most unexpected institutional and artistic résumés on the square. At the turn of the twentieth century, New York City’s Department of Correction ran the municipal prison system—from the Tombs downtown to the penitentiary on Blackwell’s Island—out of the former parlors of this twenty-five-foot house. A speculative builder announced plans in 1900 to tear it down for an eight-story apartment house, only for the 1852 walls to survive and reinvent themselves by 1919 as a five-story house of skylit studio apartments.

Standing near the southeastern corner of Gramercy Park between the 1859 Friends Meeting House to the west and the postwar tower of 32 Gramercy Park South to the east, No. 31—also numbered 148 East 20th Street—is the only freestanding townhouse on the square, with open light courts along both side walls and the eastern boundary line of the Gramercy Park Historic District running directly along its lot line.

Explore the history

From offices to apartments

1852–1894 · AN UNATTACHED BROWNSTONE

A house beside the Park

An 1852 Italianate dwelling with light on four sides

Built in 1852 during the decade when the southern and eastern edges of Samuel B. Ruggles’s private square were filling in with brick-and-brownstone residences, 31 Gramercy Park South rose on a twenty-five-by-one-hundred-and-nine-foot lot (Manhattan Block 875, Lot 48) one hundred feet west of Third Avenue. Originally erected as a four-story Italianate residence above a raised English basement, the house still displays the hallmark proportions of its 1850s origins: three bays of tall parlor windows on the second floor, projecting bracketed window lintels on the third and fourth stories, and a bold modillioned roof cornice against the sky.

Walk past the green entrance canopy today and an unusual feature sets No. 31 apart from every other townhouse around the Park: it stands completely detached on both sides. Because the Religious Society of Friends built its 1859 Meeting House immediately to the west at 28 Gramercy Park South (home since 1975 to Brotherhood Synagogue) with a wide gated side yard, and the 1956 apartment house at 32 Gramercy Park South placed a recessed driveway along its western edge, No. 31 became a freestanding townhouse illuminated by natural light on all four exposures.

The Otto and Slater households

In the second half of the nineteenth century, the four-story stone-front house was the longtime residence of New York merchant Jacob A. Otto. Following his death, his brother and executor William Tod Otto (1816–1905)—who had served in Washington as President Abraham Lincoln’s Assistant Secretary of the Interior and from 1875 to 1883 as Reporter of Decisions of the Supreme Court of the United States—sold 31 Gramercy Park on January 5, 1885, to Theodore C. Schell for $32,500. By the early 1890s, title had passed to James Slater (1846–1919), head of the celebrated New York boot and shoe firm J. & J. Slater, purveyors to Gilded Age society.

1894–1899 · DUAL ADDRESSES & MUNICIPAL OFFICES

A Park address, a public office

Deeded rights in the square

A mortgage recorded in the Real Estate Record and Builders’ Guide on May 19, 1894, captures the property’s dual identity on the cusp of its municipal era. Borrowing $20,000 at four-and-a-half percent interest from Henry Burden—trustee of the estate of the Scottish-born Troy ironmaster and horseshoe-machine inventor Henry Burden—James Slater mortgaged “20th st, No 148, s s, 100 w 3d av, 25x109, with rights in park or square, also known as No 31 Gramercy Park.” That explicit legal clause confirmed that even though the lot sat just east of the Park’s southern iron fence, it carried full deeded rights to the private square.

Detail of the 1903 Sanborn map identifying Department of Corrections offices at 148 East 20th Street, beside the Friends meeting house.
1903 Sanborn map (Vol. 2, Plate 46), showing 148 East 20th Street labeled “DEPT. OF CORRECTIONS” beside the Friends Meeting House.
The May 1894 mortgage entry naming both 148 East 20th Street and 31 Gramercy Park.
Real Estate Record and Builders’ Guide (May 19, 1894, p. 809), recording James Slater’s $20,000 mortgage on 148 East 20th Street, “with rights in park or square.”

Headquarters of the Department of Correction

Two years after Slater’s mortgage, a major reorganization of city government brought municipal administration to the doorstep of Gramercy Park. On January 1, 1896, state legislation divided New York’s overburdened Department of Public Charities and Correction into two separate departments. While the Department of Public Charities kept its offices at the foot of East 26th Street and on Fourth Avenue, the newly created Department of Correction leased 148 East 20th Street (31 Gramercy Park South) as its central Manhattan headquarters.

Under Commissioners Robert J. Wright, Francis J. Lantry (appointed by Mayor Robert A. Van Wyck in January 1898), and Thomas W. Hynes (appointed by reform Mayor Seth Low in 1902), the brownstone’s former parlors and upper rooms served as the nerve center for the city’s penal system. In The City Record and engineering journals of 1899–1904, Commissioner Lantry advertised from 148 East 20th Street for bids ranging from coal, flour, and telephone lines to new construction at the City Prison (the “Tombs” on Centre Street), the District Prisons, and the Penitentiary and Workhouse on Blackwell’s Island (today’s Roosevelt Island). As Karl Baedeker’s handbook The United States informed travelers to New York, any visitor wishing a permit to inspect the Tombs or take the East 26th Street ferry to Blackwell’s Island had to apply in person to the Commissioner of Correction at 148 East 20th Street.

1900–1909 · EIGHT STORIES ON PAPER

Eight stories on paper

Jacob Lissner’s unbuilt apartment tower

At the height of the turn-of-the-century apartment boom around Gramercy Park—just as ten-story 24 Gramercy Park South rose a few doors west—No. 31 nearly vanished from the streetscape. On November 10, 1900, the Real Estate Record and Builders’ Guide reported that James Slater had sold the four-story dwelling at 31 Gramercy Park to real-estate operator Jacob L. Lissner, “who will build an 8-sty apartment.”

The November 1900 sale notice announcing an eight-story apartment building at 31 Gramercy Park.
Real Estate Record and Builders’ Guide (November 10, 1900, p. 658), reporting James Slater’s sale of No. 31 to Jacob L. Lissner, “who will build an 8-sty apartment.”

The city stays on at No. 148

Despite Lissner’s announcement, the eight-story elevator building was never built. Instead, the City of New York renewed its lease on the four-story brownstone, which continued to serve throughout the 1900s as the headquarters of the Department of Correction. On the 1903 Sanborn insurance map of Manhattan, the twenty-five-foot house at 148 East 20th Street is prominently labeled “DEPT. OF CORRECTIONS,” standing between the Quaker Meeting House to the west and the rowhouses extending toward Third Avenue to the east.

1919–1930S · THE STUDIO YEARS

The studio years

Reconfigured into a five-story studio building

After the Department of Correction relocated its administrative offices downtown to the new Municipal Building at Chambers and Centre Streets, the old brownstone at 31 Gramercy Park underwent a residential renaissance. Acquired by the Murchison Realty Company—the real-estate arm associated with Beaux-Arts architect Kenneth M. Murchison—the four-story dwelling was remodeled into a five-story building of artists’ and residential studios. The high exterior stoop was removed in favor of a street-level entrance beneath the parlor floor, the tall second-floor openings were fitted with multi-pane studio casements, and the top story was opened up with wide studio windows and a vaulted sixteen-foot skylit atelier ceiling. On August 16, 1919, brokers Innes & Center announced the sale of “31 Gramercy Park, a 5-sty studio apartment structure,” from the Murchison Realty Company to the Rouglandes Realty Corporation.

The August 1919 sale notice describing No. 31 as a five-story studio apartment structure.
Real Estate Record and Builders’ Guide (August 16, 1919, p. 209), recording the sale of “31 Gramercy Park, a 5-sty studio apartment structure.”

Etcher and educator Abbo Ostrowsky at No. 31

The newly created studios quickly drew working artists and professionals to the block. Throughout the late 1920s and 1930s, 31 Gramercy Park South was the studio and residence of Ukrainian-born painter, master etcher, and educator Abbo Ostrowsky (1889–1975). Having studied at the Imperial Art School in Odessa before immigrating to New York in 1908, Ostrowsky had founded the Educational Alliance Art School on East Broadway in 1914—directing the famed settlement-house academy for more than four decades and training a generation of American modernists that included Mark Rothko, Louise Nevelson, Chaim Gross, Ben Shahn, Adolph Gottlieb, and Barnett Newman.

From his studio at 31 Gramercy Park—the address recorded in Fine Prints of the Year (1930) alongside his celebrated architectural and harbor etchings such as Cobblestone Stairway, Brittany (1929), Douarnenez Port, and Croton-on-Hudson (works now in the collections of the Smithsonian American Art Museum, the Metropolitan Museum of Art, and the Bibliothèque Nationale in Paris)—Ostrowsky balanced his own printmaking with his mission of bringing rigorous fine-arts education to immigrant working-class students. During the same interwar decades, the New York Medical Directory also recorded the afternoon surgical practice of gynecologist and New York City Children’s Hospital attending surgeon Dr. Claude Augustine Frink (1876–1949) on the lower floor of 31 Gramercy Park.

1966 · THE LANDMARK BOUNDARY

A line beside the house

Marking the eastern edge of the Historic District

When the New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission designated the Gramercy Park Historic District on September 20, 1966 (LP-0251), 31 Gramercy Park South played a defining geographical role in the landmark report: the commission drew the southeastern boundary line of the historic district directly along the eastern lot line of 148 East 20th Street.

Stand in front of the house today and that administrative line on paper has an immediate physical counterpart on the block. To the west, No. 31 and the neighboring 1859 Quaker Meeting House preserve the mid-nineteenth-century scale of the protected historic district; immediately across its eastern lot line rises the eighteen-story postwar brick wall of 32 Gramercy Park South, built in 1956. By holding its twenty-five-foot footprint, No. 31 forms the architectural threshold between Third Avenue and the historic square.

TODAY · COOPERATIVE LIFE

A shared house

Eleven homes in a freestanding 1852 townhouse

The eight-story elevator building proposed in 1900 never rose, allowing the 1852 brownstone to enter its second century at its nineteenth-century scale. Converted into an eleven-unit residential cooperative under 31 Gramercy Park South Owners Corp., the five-story walk-up building today combines the proportions of an Italianate townhouse with the airy layouts of its 1910s studio conversion—from high-ceilinged parlor apartments to the skylit fifth-floor penthouse atelier, complemented by rooftop bulkhead improvements approved by the Landmarks Preservation Commission in March 2013.

More than 170 years after its brownstone walls first went up on East 20th Street—and a century after prison commissioners and master etchers worked behind its casements—31 Gramercy Park South continues to link its shareholders directly to the locked iron gates of Gramercy Park.

  • Claude Augustine Frink, M.D.Surgeon and Fellow of the American College of Surgeons (1876–1949); World War I Army Medical Corps captain and Polyclinic Hospital surgeon who maintained his office at 31 Gramercy Park South in the 1920s and 1930s.
  • Francis J. LantryNew York City Commissioner of Correction (1898–1901); directed the city’s penal system from the department’s headquarters at 148 East 20th Street
  • Abbo OstrowskyPainter, master etcher, and founder-director of the Educational Alliance Art School (1889–1975); lived and kept his etching studio at 31 Gramercy Park South in the late 1920s and 1930s
  • Jacob A. OttoNineteenth-century New York merchant; longtime resident owner of the four-story brownstone at 31 Gramercy Park prior to 1885
  • William Tod OttoJurist, Lincoln’s Assistant Secretary of the Interior, and Reporter of Decisions of the U.S. Supreme Court (1816–1905); conveyed 31 Gramercy Park as executor of his brother’s estate in 1885
  • James SlaterHead of the society boot and shoe firm J. & J. Slater (1846–1919); owned 31 Gramercy Park South in the 1890s until selling the property in 1900
Building at a glance

Also 148 East 20th Street · Built 1852

The building record

Address
31 Gramercy Park South · 148 East 20th Street
Built
1852 (reconfigured into a five-story studio apartment house by 1919)
Original architect
Unknown (1910s studio conversion under Murchison Realty Co.)
Architecture
Freestanding five-story altered Italianate brownstone (25 x 109 ft. lot; Block 875, Lot 48)
Documented uses
Single-family residence (1852–1895) · NYC Department of Correction headquarters (1896–c. 1910) · Studio apartments (by 1919) · 11-unit residential cooperative
Park access
Deeded key privileges to Gramercy Park
Historic protection
Gramercy Park Historic District (LP-0251, designated September 20, 1966; forms the district’s southeastern boundary)

Over time

1852

The Italianate brownstone is built

A four-story stone-front Italianate dwelling rises on a 25-by-109-foot lot at 148 East 20th Street (31 Gramercy Park South), carrying deeded rights to Gramercy Park.

Jan. 5, 1885

The Otto estate conveyance

William Tod Otto—former Assistant Secretary of the Interior under Abraham Lincoln and Reporter of Decisions of the U.S. Supreme Court—conveys his late brother Jacob A. Otto’s house at 31 Gramercy Park to Theodore C. Schell for $32,500.

May 1894

James Slater’s mortgage

Owner James Slater, head of the shoe firm J. & J. Slater, mortgages 148 East 20th Street (“also known as No. 31 Gramercy Park, with rights in park or square”) to Henry Burden as trustee.

1896–c. 1910

Headquarters of the NYC Department of Correction

Following the division of the old Department of Public Charities and Correction, the City of New York establishes the central office of the Department of Correction inside 148 East 20th Street under Commissioners Robert J. Wright, Francis J. Lantry, and Thomas W. Hynes.

Nov. 1900

An unbuilt eight-story plan

Slater sells No. 31 to developer Jacob L. Lissner, who announces plans for an eight-story apartment building that is never erected.

Aug. 1919

Five-story studio conversion

After being raised to five stories with a street-level entrance and skylit top-floor studio ateliers under the Murchison Realty Company, 31 Gramercy Park is sold to the Rouglandes Realty Corporation.

Late 1920s–1930s

Etcher Abbo Ostrowsky’s studio

Painter, printmaker, and Educational Alliance Art School founder Abbo Ostrowsky (1889–1975) lives and works at 31 Gramercy Park South.

Sept. 20, 1966

Gramercy Park Historic District

The Landmarks Preservation Commission designates the Gramercy Park Historic District, drawing its southeastern boundary along the eastern property line of 31 Gramercy Park South.

Today

An eleven-unit townhouse cooperative

Owned by 31 Gramercy Park South Owners Corp., the freestanding five-story brownstone houses eleven cooperative apartments—including a skylit top-floor studio atelier—with rooftop restoration work approved by the Landmarks Preservation Commission in March 2013.

The life of a house

  1. 1852 · The Italianate house rises
  2. 1885–1894 · The Otto & Slater years
  3. 1896–1909 · NYC Department of Correction headquarters
  4. 1900 · An eight-story tower proposed
  5. 1919–1930s · Studio apartments & etcher Abbo Ostrowsky
  6. 1966–Today · The Historic District boundary & cooperative
Sources cited
Photo credits for this page