Gramercy Park Block Association
Gramercy Stories

23 Gramercy Park South

A quiet house. A life in the public world.

The red-brick façade of 23 Gramercy Park South, with its pale cornice, pedimented doorway, and raised stoop.
23 Gramercy Park South, built in 1847 in the late Greek Revival style for attorney William Templeton Johnson and Laura Winthrop Johnson, rising four stories in red brick with a pedimented entrance doorway and dentiled roof cornice.

A PRIVATE HOUSE IN PUBLIC HISTORY

A suffragist’s parlor where Elizabeth Cady Stanton, Susan B. Anthony, and Lucy Stone debated the future of the vote. A transatlantic journalist’s study. A Revolutionary War descendant’s bequest that helped rescue and restore Fraunces Tavern. An anti-fascist intellectual salon during the Second World War and Cold War. Behind the composed red-brick front of 23 Gramercy Park South, the domestic life of a twenty-six-foot townhouse repeatedly intersected with national history.

Built in 1847 in the late Greek Revival style for attorney William Templeton Johnson and author Laura Winthrop Johnson, No. 23 is one of the earliest surviving residences on the south side of Samuel B. Ruggles’s square. Across more than a century and three-quarters, its rooms have sheltered Civil War ordnance inventor Norman Wiard, equal-rights organizer Margaret E. Winchester, journalist Kate Field, Episcopal Diocese Chancellor George Zabriskie, and New School dean and Reporter founder Max Ascoli and philanthropist Marion Rosenwald Ascoli.

Explore the history

A house with a public life

1847–1865 · GREEK REVIVAL ORIGINS

The quiet authority of brick

William Templeton Johnson and Laura Winthrop Johnson (1847)

Completed in 1847 as the first generation of brick-and-brownstone townhouses framed the newly landscaped grounds of Samuel B. Ruggles’s Gramercy Park, 23 Gramercy Park South embodies the transition from austere Greek Revival proportions to the taller rhythms of mid-nineteenth-century Manhattan architecture. Above a rusticated English basement and a short stone stoop set at the western bay, the doorway is framed by pilasters, a three-light rectangular transom, and a crisp triangular pediment. Beside the doorway, a tripartite parlor window bay framed by paneled white pilasters and a continuous entablature—refined during the house’s early twentieth-century restoration—supports three upper ranks of six-over-six sash windows beneath eared stone lintels, graduating to compact attic windows just below the bold dentiled roof cornice.

The classical entrance surround and stoop of 23 Gramercy Park South.
Detail of the late Greek Revival entrance and tripartite parlor window bay at 23 Gramercy Park South, framed by a classic cast-iron Bishop’s Crook streetlamp and iron-fenced forecourt.

The house was built as the home of Columbia-educated attorney William Templeton Johnson (1815–1869)—son of New York Supreme Court reporter William Johnson—and his wife, writer Laura Winthrop Johnson (1825–1889), a direct descendant of Massachusetts Bay Colony Governor John Winthrop. Together with her younger brother, novelist and explorer Major Theodore Winthrop (1828–1861), the Johnsons belonged to a close-knit literary circle that included George William Curtis and painter Frederic Edwin Church; after Theodore Winthrop became one of the first Union officers killed in battle in the Civil War at Big Bethel in June 1861, Laura edited his posthumous books and published his celebrated Life and Poems.

Norman Wiard’s Civil War ordnance laboratory (1861–1865)

After the Johnsons relocated to Staten Island in the 1850s, 23 Gramercy Park South became the wartime residence and workshop of Canadian-born inventor and metallurgist Norman Wiard (1826–1896). Already renowned before the war for inventing a steam-propelled “ice boat” designed to travel across frozen northern rivers, Wiard turned his ingenuity in 1861 to the Union war effort.

Serving as Superintendent of Ordnance Stores and a trusted technical adviser to President Abraham Lincoln and Secretary of War Edwin M. Stanton—who frequently summoned him to the White House—Wiard designed rifled steel field artillery (the “Wiard Gun”) and heavy naval cannon for Union gunboats, even constructing an experimental metallurgical testing furnace at the rear of 23 Gramercy Park South to study the heat expansion and bursting strength of cannon metals until the end of the war in 1865.

1866–1872 · RECONSTRUCTION & EQUAL RIGHTS

A parlor enters the argument

Margaret E. Winchester and the American Equal Rights Association

At the close of the Civil War in 1865, 23 Gramercy Park South was purchased by Jonas Winchester (1810–1887)—a pioneering New York newspaper publisher who had co-founded the literary weekly The New World with Park Benjamin and Horace Greeley before establishing the pharmaceutical firm J. Winchester & Co.—and his wife, reformer Margaret E. Winchester. Far more than a society hostess, Margaret Winchester sat on the executive committee of the American Equal Rights Association (AERA), founded in May 1866 by Lucretia Mott, Elizabeth Cady Stanton, Susan B. Anthony, Frederick Douglass, and Lucy Stone to campaign simultaneously for universal suffrage without regard to race, color, or sex.

Stanton and Anthony already knew East 20th Street well. Since the 1850s, they had been regular guests at the Sunday evening receptions of Ohio-born poet sisters Alice and Phoebe Cary, where suffragists mingled with Horace Greeley and P. T. Barnum. Their neighborhood circle also reached the Women’s Bureau on East 23rd Street, from which they published their weekly reform journal. Winchester’s parlor belonged to this lively world of writers and reformers.

In the wake of the Civil War, the parlor of 23 Gramercy Park South served as a working venue for the movement’s organizers as fierce debates over the Fourteenth and Fifteenth Amendments tested the alliance between abolitionists and women’s-suffrage advocates over whether Black male enfranchisement and women’s suffrage could be won together.

The final coalition meeting of May 14, 1870

Those debates reached their historic culmination inside Margaret Winchester’s parlor at 23 Gramercy Park South on Saturday, May 14, 1870. With the Fifteenth Amendment newly ratified and the organization fractured between the rival National Woman Suffrage Association (led by Stanton and Anthony) and the American Woman Suffrage Association (led by Stone and Henry Browne Blackwell), the members of the American Equal Rights Association gathered at No. 23 for what proved to be the coalition’s final meeting.

With Elizabeth Cady Stanton in the chair and Susan B. Anthony, Lucy Stone, and Henry Blackwell in the room, the attendees debated the future of the four-year-old organization and voted over the objections of Stone and Blackwell to fold the AERA into the National Woman Suffrage Association—making the front parlor of 23 Gramercy Park South a turning point in the history of the nineteenth-century suffrage movement.

1873–1874 · A TRANSATLANTIC WRITER

Kate Field, at work

From Florence and London to Gramercy Park

When financial reverses around the Panic of 1873 led Margaret Winchester to open the upper floors of 23 Gramercy Park South to cultivated paying guests while continuing her work with the Association for the Advancement of Women, one of her first residents was the celebrated journalist, critic, lecturer, and actress Mary Katherine Keemle Field—known across America and Britain simply as Kate Field (1838–1896).

Educated in Massachusetts and in Florence—where she had been the beloved young protégée of Walter Savage Landor and Robert and Elizabeth Barrett Browning, and a close friend of Anthony Trollope and George Eliot—Field had made her name as a star correspondent for the New-York Tribune and public lecturer on Charles Dickens and John Brown in the Adirondacks. Returning to New York from Europe in the autumn of 1873, she settled into 23 Gramercy Park South for the winter of 1873–1874, at the center of a neighborhood literary circle that included Richard Watson Gilder, poet Edmund Clarence Stedman, and Tribune editor Whitelaw Reid.

Fifty-seven articles and eighty-six columns

Field’s letters and journals from 23 Gramercy Park South, preserved in Lilian Whiting’s 1899 biography Kate Field: A Record, capture the relentless pace of a self-supporting nineteenth-century woman of letters. While studying dramatic acting and voice in the city, she dispatched a regular column titled “Notes from the United States” to London’s prestigious literary journal The Athenaeum, interpreting American theater, literature, and opera—from the New York premiere of Wagner’s Lohengrin to William Dean Howells’s novel A Foregone Conclusion—for British readers across the Atlantic.

Tallying her output for the twelve months ending in July 1874, Field recorded fifty-seven newspaper articles spanning eighty-six printed columns alongside six magazine essays, wryly remarking in her diary that “it hardly seems as though I had written at all.” Armed with letters of introduction from Gramercy art critic Henry T. Tuckerman to Harper & Brothers, she turned her rooms overlooking the square into a busy transatlantic news bureau before embarking on her stage debut the following season.

Historical photographic portrait of Kate Field in a dark lace mantilla.
Journalist, critic, lecturer, and actress Kate Field (1838–1896), photographed by Charles Reutlinger in Paris shortly before she took up residence at 23 Gramercy Park South for the winter of 1873–1874.
1904–1940 · PRESERVATION & RESTORATION

The house that helped save Fraunces Tavern

Frederick Samuel Tallmadge’s 1904 bequest

At the turn of the twentieth century, 23 Gramercy Park South was owned by attorney and bibliophile Frederick Samuel Tallmadge (1824–1904). A graduate of Columbia College and longtime president of the Sons of the Revolution in the State of New York, Tallmadge carried a direct personal link to the American Revolution: he was the grandson of Major Benjamin Tallmadge (1754–1835), George Washington’s chief of military intelligence who organized the Culper Spy Ring in New York and rode beside Washington into Lower Manhattan on Evacuation Day in November 1783.

When Frederick S. Tallmadge died on June 20, 1904, at the age of eighty, his will bequeathed 23 Gramercy Park South—together with his prized collection of Shakespeare folios and Revolutionary War relics, including Washington’s order book and miniature portrait—to the Sons of the Revolution with the intention that the Gramercy townhouse serve as the Society’s permanent headquarters and historical museum.

Selling No. 23 to rescue Fraunces Tavern (1905)

Just weeks after Tallmadge’s death, however, the Sons of the Revolution took title to a far older landmark at 54 Pearl Street: Fraunces Tavern, built in 1719 and immortalized on December 4, 1783, as the room where General George Washington bade farewell to his Continental Army officers—including Benjamin Tallmadge himself. Rather than divide its resources between two buildings, the Society obtained the consent of Tallmadge’s sister and sole heir, Mary F. Seymour, to sell 23 Gramercy Park South and apply the bequest directly toward retiring the mortgage on Fraunces Tavern and financing architect William H. Mersereau’s landmark 1906–1907 restoration of the tavern.

Painted portrait of Frederick Samuel Tallmadge seated in a dark suit with a society insignia.
Frederick Samuel Tallmadge (1824–1904), longtime president of the Sons of the Revolution in the State of New York and grandson of Revolutionary War spymaster Colonel Benjamin Tallmadge; his 1904 bequest of 23 Gramercy Park South helped finance the acquisition and restoration of Fraunces Tavern.

Chancellor George Zabriskie restores a twenty-room family mansion (1905–1940)

In December 1905, the Sons of the Revolution sold 23 Gramercy Park South for $55,000 to prominent Wall Street attorney George Zabriskie (1852–1931) and his wife, Sarah Forrest Gray Zabriskie (d. 1933). Senior partner of the law firm Zabriskie, Sage, Gray & Todd and longtime Chancellor of the Protestant Episcopal Diocese of New York, Zabriskie restored the nineteenth-century house from its decades as a boarding house into a gracious twenty-room single-family residence.

For thirty-five years, the Zabriskie family anchored the south side of the square. After George Zabriskie’s death in 1931 and Sarah’s death at 23 Gramercy Park South in September 1933, their son George Gray Zabriskie—who succeeded his father as Chancellor of the Episcopal Diocese and also served as president of the Sons of the Revolution—maintained the family home until October 1940, when he sold the twenty-room townhouse to Max and Marion Rosenwald Ascoli.

1940–1970S · THE ASCOLI YEARS

A home for an international life

Max Ascoli and Marion Rosenwald Ascoli move in (1940)

On October 11, 1940, The New York Times reported that George Gray Zabriskie had sold the twenty-room residence at 23 Gramercy Park South to newlyweds Max Ascoli (1898–1978) and Marion Rosenwald Ascoli (1902–1990). Their marriage united two remarkable traditions of public commitment: European anti-fascist scholarship and American educational philanthropy.

Born in Ferrara, Italy, to a prominent Jewish family and trained in law and philosophy at the universities of Ferrara and Rome, Max Ascoli had been arrested and imprisoned by Benito Mussolini’s Fascist regime in 1928 for his underground democratic writings. Escaping to the United States in 1931 on a Rockefeller Foundation fellowship, he joined Alvin Johnson’s newly created “University in Exile”—the Graduate Faculty of Political and Social Science at The New School for Social Research on West 12th Street—serving as dean from 1939 to 1941 and president of the anti-fascist Mazzini Society while working tirelessly to rescue endangered European scholars and artists. His bride, Marion Rosenwald, was the daughter of Sears, Roebuck & Company leader Julius Rosenwald, whose Rosenwald Fund built more than 5,300 public schools for African American children across the segregated South, and a lifelong leader in child-welfare and civil-rights philanthropy in her own right.

The Reporter and three decades on Gramercy Park

From their townhouse on Gramercy Park—where they hosted scholars, diplomats, and family milestones, including the October 1947 wedding of Marion’s daughter Adele Stern—the Ascolis helped shape postwar American political journalism. In April 1949, financed in part by their family resources, Max Ascoli founded and became editor-in-chief and publisher of The Reporter, an influential fortnightly magazine of politics, foreign affairs, and arts criticism that ran until 1968. Under Ascoli’s editorship, The Reporter published landmark investigative journalism—including early exposés of Senator Joseph McCarthy, the China Lobby, domestic wiretapping, and nuclear fallout—while championing liberal internationalism across two decades.

Proudly describing himself not as a temporary exile waiting to return to Europe, but as “an American citizen of Italian origin,” Ascoli and his wife lived at 23 Gramercy Park South for more than three decades. Included within the Gramercy Park Historic District upon its designation in September 1966—and sensitively updated with a Landmarks-approved rooftop and rear restoration in 2010—the 1847 townhouse remains a private single-family residence overlooking the square—its red brick and white Greek Revival pediment preserving more than 175 years of civic and literary history.

Archival black-and-white portrait of Max Ascoli wearing glasses.
Italian-born anti-fascist legal scholar, New School Graduate Faculty dean, and founding editor-publisher of The Reporter Max Ascoli (1898–1978), who lived at 23 Gramercy Park South with his wife Marion Rosenwald Ascoli from 1940 into the 1970s.
  • Marion Rosenwald AscoliPhilanthropist, child-welfare leader, and daughter of Sears, Roebuck executive and Rosenwald Schools founder Julius Rosenwald (1902–1990); lived at 23 Gramercy Park South from 1940 into the 1970s
  • Max AscoliItalian-born anti-fascist legal philosopher, Dean of the Graduate Faculty at The New School, and founding editor-publisher of The Reporter (1898–1978); lived at 23 Gramercy Park South from 1940 into the 1970s
  • Kate FieldJournalist, transatlantic correspondent, lecturer, and actress (1838–1896); lived and wrote at 23 Gramercy Park South during the winter of 1873–1874
  • Laura Winthrop JohnsonAuthor, editor of her brother Major Theodore Winthrop’s works, and descendant of Governor John Winthrop (1825–1889); first mistress of 23 Gramercy Park South from 1847
  • William Templeton JohnsonColumbia-educated attorney (1815–1869); built 23 Gramercy Park South in 1847 as his family residence
  • Frederick Samuel TallmadgeAttorney, bibliophile, and president of the Sons of the Revolution in the State of New York (1824–1904); owned 23 Gramercy Park South and bequeathed it in 1904 to help save Fraunces Tavern
  • Norman WiardCivil War ordnance inventor and weapons adviser to President Abraham Lincoln (1826–1896); lived at 23 Gramercy Park South and operated a metallurgical testing furnace here during the Civil War (1861–1865)
  • Margaret E. WinchesterWomen’s-rights and abolitionist organizer; executive committee member of the American Equal Rights Association who hosted the coalition’s final meeting in the parlor of No. 23 on May 14, 1870
  • George ZabriskieWall Street attorney and Chancellor of the Protestant Episcopal Diocese of New York (1852–1931); purchased 23 Gramercy Park South from the Sons of the Revolution in 1905 and restored it as his family’s twenty-room residence
Building at a glance

Built 1847 · Late Greek Revival

The building record

Address
23 Gramercy Park South (Manhattan Block 875, Lot 60)
Built
1847 (for attorney William Templeton Johnson and Laura Winthrop Johnson)
Style
Late Greek Revival red-brick townhouse with pedimented entrance and dentiled cornice
Original architect
Unknown
Present use
Single-family residence
Park access & landmark status
Deeded key privileges to Gramercy Park; within the 1966 NYC Gramercy Park Historic District (LP-0251) and 1980 National Register of Historic Places district
Notable historical associations
William Templeton & Laura Winthrop Johnson · Norman Wiard · Jonas & Margaret E. Winchester (May 14, 1870 AERA suffrage meeting) · Kate Field · Frederick Samuel Tallmadge (Fraunces Tavern bequest) · Chancellor George Zabriskie · Max & Marion Rosenwald Ascoli

Over time

1847

The William Templeton Johnson House rises

Attorney William Templeton Johnson and his wife Laura Winthrop Johnson build a four-story late Greek Revival brick townhouse above a brownstone English basement at 23 Gramercy Park South.

1861–1865

Norman Wiard’s Civil War ordnance laboratory

Inventor and metallurgist Norman Wiard, ordnance adviser to President Abraham Lincoln and Secretary of War Edwin M. Stanton, lives at 23 Gramercy Park South and operates a testing furnace for Union artillery metals.

1865–1870

Margaret E. Winchester and the American Equal Rights Association

Purchased by publisher and pharmaceutical executive Jonas Winchester and his wife Margaret E. Winchester, the house becomes a gathering place for equal-rights organizers; on May 14, 1870, with Elizabeth Cady Stanton in the chair, the American Equal Rights Association holds its final meeting in the parlor.

1873–1874

Journalist Kate Field’s winter study

Transatlantic correspondent, critic, and lecturer Kate Field lives at 23 Gramercy Park South during the winter of 1873–1874, writing her “Notes from the United States” for London’s Athenaeum.

June 1904–Dec. 1905

Frederick S. Tallmadge’s bequest helps save Fraunces Tavern

Owner Frederick Samuel Tallmadge, president of the Sons of the Revolution and grandson of Revolutionary War spymaster Benjamin Tallmadge, bequeaths 23 Gramercy Park South to the Society; sold in December 1905 for $55,000, the house’s proceeds help retire the mortgage on Fraunces Tavern and fund its landmark restoration.

1905–1940

Chancellor George Zabriskie’s family home

Wall Street attorney and Episcopal Diocese Chancellor George Zabriskie and his wife Sarah Forrest Gray Zabriskie restore No. 23 into a twenty-room single-family mansion, owned by the Zabriskie family for thirty-five years.

Oct. 1940–1970s

Max and Marion Rosenwald Ascoli

Italian anti-fascist scholar, New School Graduate Faculty dean, and Reporter founder Max Ascoli and philanthropist Marion Rosenwald Ascoli purchase the twenty-room house in October 1940 and make it their home for over three decades.

Sept. 20, 1966

Gramercy Park Historic District

The 1847 townhouse is designated within the Gramercy Park Historic District.

Seven moments in the life of a house

  1. 1847–1865 · The Johnsons & Wiard’s laboratory
  2. 1866 · Winchester takes a role
  3. 1870 · A coalition’s final meeting
  4. 1873 · Kate Field returns
  5. 1904 · Tallmadge’s bequest
  6. 1905 · Saving Fraunces Tavern & the Zabriskie home
  7. 1940 · The Ascoli chapter
Sources cited
Photo credits for this page